Yeah, I am totally delusional when I see him pulling his hand back and giving short thumbs up when Herb grabs his hand.
I personally don't understand the 'limp' arm argument, considering the kneeling position he was in, wouldn't his whole body crumble if he was out?
The rematch should happen, no question about it. In my eyes it isn't a decisive win when it is clouded by controversy. Even Big John said Herb made a mistake and could video review his own decision as the event took place in Nevada - the only place where it is possible.
If Askren is so good, he definitely should be able to defeat that tough motherfucker again to validate himself. Because if anything, the bad stoppage takes away more from him than it takes from Lawler.