1. #16881
    Merely a Setback Lorgar Aurelian's Avatar
    7+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Dec 2015
    Location
    Land of moose and goose.
    Posts
    26,871
    Quote Originally Posted by Edge- View Post
    https://www.pathofexile.com/forum/view-thread/3720737

    Huh...

    So they're removing the atlas passive tree and replacing it with, basically, relics for your map device inventory that have atlas passive effects on them. /
    Oh I absolutely hate that.

    The atlas at the moment is almost perfect having to fumble with drops instead is going to suck.
    All I ever wanted was the truth. Remember those words as you read the ones that follow. I never set out to topple my father's kingdom of lies from a sense of misplaced pride. I never wanted to bleed the species to its marrow, reaving half the galaxy clean of human life in this bitter crusade. I never desired any of this, though I know the reasons for which it must be done. But all I ever wanted was the truth.

  2. #16882
    Quote Originally Posted by Fencers View Post
    Most hate this change to the atlas it seems.

    While I appreciate that GGG is fairly experimental and this is merely a void league, don't mess with the best part of your game in favor of gambling. Jeez Louise.

    They got me sweating over this event just by that announcement and I am glad the reaction from the community is similar.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Imagine having to run regular maps or mechanics you hate/aren't built for just to pay 100 div for a Deli or Harbinger idol.

    What in the fuck.
    Looking at PoE2 and Devtalks it seems GGG really dont like determinism at all. If this is they way forward i dont know if i will stick around. I agree OG Harvest was too strong, but if they want to stretch gametime by adding even more RNG i am not enthusiastic to say the least.
    If the crafting of PoE2 is anything to go by, we are in for a bad awakening.

  3. #16883
    Quote Originally Posted by Fencers View Post
    While I appreciate that GGG is fairly experimental and this is merely a void league, don't mess with the best part of your game in favor of gambling. Jeez Louise.
    I know we've spent a fair bit of time testing out PoE2 designs and ideas over the past year but largely they felt good enough that folks didn't mind.

    I'm sure the relics are liable to be fairly cracked, but it just feels like such a weird decision to do away with a popular deterministic system and replace it with total RNG. It probably won't change, but I hope this reaction is informative for GGG.

  4. #16884
    Quote Originally Posted by Mevaya View Post
    Looking at PoE2 and Devtalks it seems GGG really dont like determinism at all.
    It seems they hate it, yeah.

    I agree OG Harvest was too strong, but if they want to stretch gametime by adding even more RNG i am not enthusiastic to say the least.
    I don't think 'stretching game time' is their intention. When RNG is brought up the devs often remark they find the aspect of the game(s) that are unpredictable to be fun. They specifically label their most RNG-based systems as "exciting", "unpredictable", "variety", etc.

    It seems, and I think their GDC talks point to this strongly, that a central part of GGG's design philosophy is that fun is derived from the player adapting to whatever the pull of a lever results in for the player. So to speak.

    If the crafting of PoE2 is anything to go by, we are in for a bad awakening.
    Well, we should all keep in mind two things; this event is only a month-long void league and GGG said many of these ideas are 'wacky'/'cutting room floor' concepts that didn't cut it for actual implementation.

    So we, myself included, ought to keep in mind this event is not a new league.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by Edge- View Post
    I'm sure the relics are liable to be fairly cracked, but it just feels like such a weird decision to do away with a popular deterministic system and replace it with total RNG. It probably won't change, but I hope this reaction is informative for GGG.
    The monkey paw has to run out of fingers eventually.

  5. #16885
    Its just a little baffling to me how they just cant get an easy win with the community. Like, they have no one actually playing the game who can tell them whats a terrible idea. I am all for wacky ideas, but please lets keep the best systems in the game and not bastardize them.

    If it was up to me, id have the new ascendancies, have these relics that are for Old/Unused league mechanics and call it legacy league 2.0.
    This way they could have another 3-4 months to work on PoE2 and 3.26.

    Ideas are a dime a dozen, theres plenty to shoehorn a quick league together. I dont expect a Settlers-like expansion every time.

  6. #16886
    The easiest and most logical extension of the idols was to simply have them replace scarabs. Scarbs suck anyway and I will die on the hill Sextants were better.

  7. #16887
    Quote Originally Posted by Fencers View Post
    The easiest and most logical extension of the idols was to simply have them replace scarabs. Scarbs suck anyway and I will die on the hill Sextants were better.
    How you like the PoE2 version of sextants in form of Towers? Its *hilarious* to me that sextants were removed bc they were too tedious to manage, and then they come up with towers

  8. #16888
    I mean the community is pretty good with the memes though. POE Reddit has to be up there with WallStreetBets, Prequelmemes and DetroitLions reddits in the quality of our memes.


  9. #16889
    I almost came to post that because it feels so fuckin real, lol.

    At least we know GGG prefers feedback like this or bingo cards vs. someone writing out a 5K word doctoral dissertation, lol.

  10. #16890
    Seems accurate lol

  11. #16891
    The smuggler's stash mod made me howl with laughter during a zoom meeting.

    The feeling is too real.

    - - - Updated - - -

    I'm glad GGG laid out how they see the idols and more behind their operation.

    That was a scary 24 hours. Whew!

    - - - Updated - - -

    Wand Ranger and Surfer Bro look fuckng broken as all hell. Damn!

    I thought Spider Shadow was the play, but Surfer Bro tech is very appealing.

  12. #16892
    Well the latest FAQ does alleviate some of my worries. Wand Ranger looks pretty dope honestly!

  13. #16893
    Herald Witch, lmao! You wilding, GGG.

  14. #16894
    Ranger - Whisperer: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2.../Whisperer.png

    Witch - Herald: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2...-12/Herald.png

    Duelist - Paladin: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2...12/Paladin.png

    Templar - Polytheist: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2...Polytheist.png

    Yo this shit is getting out of hand.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Current musing: Blade Blast of Dagger Detonation Polytheist. Just get a tri-ele dagger and you've got a pretty huge amount of base damage to work with on a targetable nova. Comes with 3 to all min charges making going into crit a bit easier, and you can either get the blind/crit nodes to lean into that harder and for nice phys defense layer or get reflect/hex immunity and a free point for whatever (prob immune the ground effects).

    Power Siphon Miner Whisperer looks like it could be very, very strong without needing to change the existing build much, if at all (may not even need pierce, just use the fork node). Lightning Strike also looking good too.

    I feel like there's gotta be something cool with Herald...like I want to say going all-in on HoPurity with 6 minions, using Ritual spectres for some auras, could be cool but eh.

    And Paladin...General's Cry Ice Crash? Infinite warcry power, nice support for elemental damage bonuses, and either a juiced aura or consecrated ground.

    I'm tired and just thinking of dumb things.

  15. #16895
    Quote Originally Posted by Edge- View Post
    Ranger - Whisperer: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2.../Whisperer.png

    Witch - Herald: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2...-12/Herald.png

    Duelist - Paladin: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2...12/Paladin.png

    Templar - Polytheist: https://web.poecdn.com/public/news/2...Polytheist.png

    Yo this shit is getting out of hand.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Current musing: Blade Blast of Dagger Detonation Polytheist. Just get a tri-ele dagger and you've got a pretty huge amount of base damage to work with on a targetable nova. Comes with 3 to all min charges making going into crit a bit easier, and you can either get the blind/crit nodes to lean into that harder and for nice phys defense layer or get reflect/hex immunity and a free point for whatever (prob immune the ground effects).

    Power Siphon Miner Whisperer looks like it could be very, very strong without needing to change the existing build much, if at all (may not even need pierce, just use the fork node). Lightning Strike also looking good too.

    I feel like there's gotta be something cool with Herald...like I want to say going all-in on HoPurity with 6 minions, using Ritual spectres for some auras, could be cool but eh.

    And Paladin...General's Cry Ice Crash? Infinite warcry power, nice support for elemental damage bonuses, and either a juiced aura or consecrated ground.

    I'm tired and just thinking of dumb things.
    I think this will be exciting, but i already predict forums overflowing with negativity and crying of how unbalanced these are, when the event launches.
    Im getting tired of it before it even happens xD

  16. #16896
    Gonna take a lot to pull me away for Fishing Rods though. Surfer Bro is amazing.

    - - - Updated - - -

    I will never use a link skill again. There is no allure stronger enough. No matter how you buff link skills, GGG.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by Edge- View Post
    I feel like there's gotta be something cool with Herald...like I want to say going all-in on HoPurity with 6 minions, using Ritual spectres for some auras, could be cool but eh.
    Annihilating Light or Rebuke of Vaal + Tinctures. Herald Witch can be a more powerful version of last year's Ranger Warden Summer blaster.
    Last edited by Fencers; 2025-02-12 at 02:56 PM.

  17. #16897
    Quote Originally Posted by Edge- View Post
    And Paladin...General's Cry Ice Crash? Infinite warcry power, nice support for elemental damage bonuses, and either a juiced aura or consecrated ground.
    Guys...I have never played a warcry/general's cry build but I cannot stop thinking about this build.

    45% increased elemental damage taken by enemies (45% MORE, baby)
    Tri-elemental damage auras to buff weapon/minion damage more.
    20% less damage dealt by enemies
    Infinite Warcry Power for Gen and maybe...Rallying/Inferal and/or Enduring Cry?

    Still unsure whether a level 30 aura or consecrated ground is better, but I feel like you can easily run determination/grace, get plenty of spell suppress, and take the 15% life recovered with each warcry mastery. Can use Ice Crash or something like Volcanic Fissure of Snaking? I dunno, I gotta look into this more.

  18. #16898
    Quote Originally Posted by Edge- View Post
    Guys...I have never played a warcry/general's cry build but I cannot stop thinking about this build.
    Yeah, I might have to revisit an old D2 Barb I made way back the day, Tantrum. He was all about warcries. Sadly, I don't think PoE has a Warcry that deals damage. (I also had Leaping Larry, sadly no ARPG has been able to properly reproduce the hilarity of that character; maxed out Leap was just stupid fun)

    Most of these are intriguing, to say the least, and seem to allow for some really bizarre and interesting characters. Additionally, the pathing on the trees are just as odd. Some have loops, then you've got the Herald which the 1st half of the tree is mandatory. This may be the most creative I've seen GGG in quite a long time.

    I did notice this, however:
    Is this content being used as a testing grounds for future expansions or Path of Exile 2?
    Not at all, as mentioned this was a throw-away development idea from the past, we have no current plans to use it for anything outside of being a future private league modifier.
    (emphasis mine)

    Does this mean they're finally looking into making Private Leagues actually fun and interesting?

  19. #16899
    Quote Originally Posted by Cyclone Jack View Post
    Yeah, I might have to revisit an old D2 Barb I made way back the day, Tantrum. He was all about warcries. Sadly, I don't think PoE has a Warcry that deals damage. (I also had Leaping Larry, sadly no ARPG has been able to properly reproduce the hilarity of that character; maxed out Leap was just stupid fun)
    Corrupting cry, though I don't think that's been decent for ages and it's a DoT vs. a big hit.

  20. #16900
    Quote Originally Posted by Edge- View Post
    Corrupting cry, though I don't think that's been decent for ages and it's a DoT vs. a big hit.
    Hmm, a 2 sec Corrupted Blood DoT. I might be able to work with that. LOL

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •