Thing here is that its good for low population servers, while punishing for high population servers, if it was merging lots of low pop sure but why on earth go and take in the servers that are alrdy fine, aka high pop servers. I can totally understand why some people dislike this to the point of quitting, especially as it is just a terrible bandaid fix for forcibly merging smaller servers to get the populations on them to be adequate.
Also, WTF is up with this dark portal ganking fetish that lots of people have started to get, it makes no sense 0,o