Originally Posted by
qu1rex
I'm aware that Gara'jal doesn't continue recording for people who jump into the other realm, but a protection paladin doing 16k dps is damn near auto-attacking.
It looks like your warlock and shadowpriest are going down into the spirit realm on every single totem, that's a large waste of dps.
You should be rotating people for who goes down, that way you can maximise the benefit of the spirit-realm's dps buff.
With my protection paladin, I go for the hit cap (7.5%) then expertise cap (15%) and after that I will go for haste.
Stat prio is as follows; Hit > Exp > Haste > Mastery >>>>>>> Parry > Dodge > Crit
Enchant hit rating on boots, he already has Pursuit of Justice (Pandara's Step doesn't stack with it).
Drop the bubblier brightbrew charm and grab the trinket from last boss in Scholomance (I think the above poster mentioned that).
The 'on use' of this trinket awards around 4k strength, equating to roughly 4~5% parry
Enchant the cape with hit rating.
Drop the stamina gems, in blue sockets you'll be wanting hit rating (or hit&expertise gems) in red sockets you'll want expertise gems and in yellow sockets, depending on your hit/exp you'll want 320haste gems.
Reforge away from dodge, not parry, into expertise/hit/haste.
There are arguments for either Haste or Mastery, Mastery will ensure he has a larger damage reduction than with a Haste build, but Haste allows more uptime on Shield of the Righteous, meaning the net effect is the same, however I favor the Haste build seeing as it is far less spikey and the added bonus of you doing more dps as well.
During bloodlust the tank takes virtually no damage as you'll have near-100% uptime on Shield of the Righteous buff and your battlehealer glyph coupled with seal of insight will make up most of the healing on yourself.
Lastly he should spec out of Holy Avenger and spec into Divinity for the "RNG" procs for free holy power, this is absolutely a must for a fight like Gara'jal seeing as if you use Shield of the Righteous and it procs, you'll be able to extend the duration of the Shield of the Righteous buff, most of the times long enough to generate another 3 holy power, so that you'll have even closer to 100% uptime on it.
This results in more dps and less damage taken.
Holy Avenger is only good for a short period of time every 2 minutes and Gara'jal is not a boss with any sort of short burst phases.