Originally Posted by
nnelson54
Illidan was one of the worst main characters Blizzard has ever come up with. I mean, I get why he's so popular. He looks cool. Nobody understands him. He thinks he's just doing what's best for everyone around him even though none of them get it. More than anything else he just wants the love of his family and friends. He's dark and brooding. He's every emo kid's wet dream. But he's an awful, awful character with no development beyond, "RAAAAAR DEMONS BAD!" and it would be the most terrible setback of all Blizzard setbacks if he were to make a return.
Hell, he wasn't even the end boss of what was advertised as his own expansion.
(And before anyone points out the complete and utter incorrect notion that somehow people cling to as truth, he was never intended to be the end boss and SWP wasn't added at the last second because WotLK wasn't ready, as people continue to assert. The entire narrative from start to finish in that expansion was about the Burning Crusade, not Illidan. Including Kael'thas flat out saying that his true master was coming to Azeroth and we would soon meet him before Black Temple was even released. People who just don't understand the lore and just saw Illidan was commanding demons couldn't tell the difference and started that annoying, annoying idea that SWP was a bandaid and Illidan was always supposed to be the end boss.)
Not to mention, nothing about your idea makes any sense what so ever.