Instead of quoting people, you should try it yourself first. It's not doing great for that manager and his company since it cant drive sale up like W7. It has no major feature to draw people in, and the strange touch-mouse/kb hybrid startmenu might scare off chickens and hares here and there, but W8 is definitely not a failure like Vista - simply an improved W7 with strange interface. If you happens to use multiple monitor, W8 is a must.