Alleria Windrunner, why would the Blood elves even want her?

[Jonathan]

As my title says why would the blood elves even want her when she returns.

She was part of the alliance of lorderon that turned its back on them when they need help the most.

it was Garithos and the alliance of lorderon that imprisoned their leader kal and made him make an alliance with naga just to survive.

Everyone likes to point out in all the forums how loyal she is is to the alliance so why would to Blood elves want a person that is loyal to the very group that betrayed them back at all?

I have nothing against Alleria and think if she comes back she will try to med fences but all elves, be they night elves, high elves, or blood elves are a pretty stubborn bunch.


On the whole what will she think of the dark lady argument because i know it will be brought up. She can love and respect her sister for dying to save their home but does not have to like the fact that her sister was raised into undeath. Had Alleria been there she would prob have died right along with sylanas and been raised as well. Not off hiding in the human world.

[Sandrox]

She was part of the alliance of lorderon that turned its back on them when they need help the most.

The Blood Elves are the ones that turned its back on the Alliance, not the other way around.

Had Alleria been there she would prob have died right along with sylanas and been raised as well. Not off hiding in the human world.

Being trapped on Draenor isnt hiding in the human world.

[Netherspark]

Because she's their greatest living hero?

[JudgePayne]

She was there greatest hero as mentioned above and her skill surpassed her other two sisters as botha tactican and a leader.

So why would they not want her back.

[Maximus Testiculos]

As my title says why would the blood elves even want her when she returns.

She was part of the alliance of lorderon that turned its back on them when they need help the most.

it was Garithos and the alliance of lorderon that imprisoned their leader kal and made him make an alliance with naga just to survive.

Everyone likes to point out in all the forums how loyal she is is to the alliance so why would to Blood elves want a person that is loyal to the very group that betrayed them back at all?

I have nothing against Alleria and think if she comes back she will try to med fences but all elves, be they night elves, high elves, or blood elves are a pretty stubborn bunch.


On the whole what will she think of the dark lady argument because i know it will be brought up. She can love and respect her sister for dying to save their home but does not have to like the fact that her sister was raised into undeath. Had Alleria been there she would prob have died right along with sylanas and been raised as well. Not off hiding in the human world.

It was the elves who left lordaeron. Thousands of humans died for the forests of quelthalas even then elves did not even send full help and they left as soon as the war ended. They did not even try to help humans and dwarves rebuild.
Only alleria and few elves went to alliance.
Blood elves have nothing to complain about her. Alleria must have a thousand things to complain if she returns.

[Deleted]

I have nothing against Alleria and think if she comes back she will try to med fences but all elves, be they night elves, high elves, or blood elves are a pretty stubborn bunch.

The Night Elves would never become friendly with the Blood and High Elves, they'll never forgive either of them. The only reason they don't attack the High Elves is because that would lead to the Night Elves getting kicked out of the Alliance and left for the Orcs to annihilate.

[Slowpoke is a Gamer]

To properly understand how the BElves work, you have to understand this man. He was a racist that gave the BElves impossible work, and then imprisoned them when they consorted with Naga to complete those impossible tasks.

For the longest time, BElves believed Garithos was directly following the Alliance.

[KrazyK923]

I'm confused...is there something stating she was going to them?

[Vasti]

Why would she want the blood elves?
She is a high elf and her place is in the Alliance besides Turalyon.

[Maxilian]

Why would she want the blood elves?
She is a high elf and her place is in the Alliance besides Turalyon.

These, IMO the BE have no reason to not want her, but she does have a couple of reasons to not want the BE, she most likely stay with the HE and the Alliance

[Maximus Testiculos]

I am not trying to say garithos was a perfect man but everything was impossible work at the scourge invasion. He did not just give orders just to get elves killed.
And garithos did not force anyone to work with the naga or demons.

[Sal the Shieldhog]

I am not trying to say garithos was a perfect man but everything was impossible work at the scourge invasion. He did not just give orders just to get elves killed.
And garithos did not force anyone to work with the naga or demons.

He did. He was a racist who gave the blood elves tasks that's have been impossible even without the scourge. He drove then right to the naga, the blood elves wouldn't have survived otherwise.

[Combatbutler]

She was there greatest hero as mentioned above and her skill surpassed her other two sisters as botha tactican and a leader.

So why would they not want her back.

Their greatest hero? She was good but hardly their greatest hero.
Sylvanas was the most promising Ranger in their family, which is why she became Ranger General, making her Alleria's boss.

[Maximus Testiculos]

'He did not just give orders just to get elves killed.'
Read this. He did not just deliberately try to kill elves for no reason. Whole lordaeron was a huge battlefield. While the likes of tirion were hiding, garithos was figthing the war.
Garithos is not a good man but he also is not the demon that blood elves can put every blame for everything.

[Bwutty]

Why would we care what BEs want? She's alliance hero with an alliance husband.. Her place is with the blue team and no one cares what red thinks.

[Combatbutler]

As my title says why would the blood elves even want her when she returns.

She was part of the alliance of lorderon that turned its back on them when they need help the most.

it was Garithos and the alliance of lorderon that imprisoned their leader kal and made him make an alliance with naga just to survive.

Everyone likes to point out in all the forums how loyal she is is to the alliance so why would to Blood elves want a person that is loyal to the very group that betrayed them back at all?

I have nothing against Alleria and think if she comes back she will try to med fences but all elves, be they night elves, high elves, or blood elves are a pretty stubborn bunch.


On the whole what will she think of the dark lady argument because i know it will be brought up. She can love and respect her sister for dying to save their home but does not have to like the fact that her sister was raised into undeath. Had Alleria been there she would prob have died right along with sylanas and been raised as well. Not off hiding in the human world.

First the elves left the Alliance, so they did not really owe them anything.

Garithos shattered almost all what remained of the bond between blood elves and Alliance true, but ultimately spying dwarves and night elven incursion broke it entirely.

Why should they turn her away unless she openly denounces them they have no reason to. Alleria is lost somewhere she fought for her homeland seeing her as traitor now is utter nonsense she has yet to oppose Quel'thalas.

[Maxilian]

'He did not just give orders just to get elves killed.'
Read this. He did not just deliberately try to kill elves for no reason. Whole lordaeron was a huge battlefield. While the likes of tirion were hiding, garithos was figthing the war.
Garithos is not a good man but he also is not the demon that blood elves can put every blame for everything.

Actually the BE can blame him for everything cause he's at fault, but is also true that Garithos was a loyal soldier...

[Combatbutler]

The Night Elves would never become friendly with the Blood and High Elves, they'll never forgive either of them. The only reason they don't attack the High Elves is because that would lead to the Night Elves getting kicked out of the Alliance and left for the Orcs to annihilate.

They accepted Highborne back into their society and not just any highborne, the Shen'dralar some of the most vile beings on Azeroth. Siphoning fel power for thousands of years, killing off their own people to maintain immortality and fel power source.

[Maximus Testiculos]

Actually the BE can blame him for everything cause he's at fault, but is also true that Garithos was a loyal soldier...

Let's suck demons and naaru, it is all humans' fault.

Blood elf logic.

[Combatbutler]

'He did not just give orders just to get elves killed.'
Read this. He did not just deliberately try to kill elves for no reason. Whole lordaeron was a huge battlefield. While the likes of tirion were hiding, garithos was figthing the war.
Garithos is not a good man but he also is not the demon that blood elves can put every blame for everything.

If Garithos hadn't been a racist his campaign might have actually succeeded.