Originally Posted by
Hitei
Just because you use your enemies to cull the weak doesn't mean you like them.
At the end of the day, the reason they are culling the weak is so that they remain superior.. they're entire mentality is that they are the purest and greatest and that everyone else is scum and lesser.
Even as a player when you not only revive the paragons, but basically save the Klaxxi from destruction and reach exalted, you're still seen as a lesser a member of a lesser race and all you earn is a warning that they serve the old gods and will not hesitate to cut you, and all other lesser races down when the time comes.
I just don't understand how you can possibly thing that the Mantid would ever considering putting themselves below a half-naked troll.
This still doesn't explain WHY the mantid join the Horde.
They don't have allies. Even you, the player working with the Klaxxi, are just a servant kept around to do their bidding. And they still originally have no problem slaughtering you on the spot after you just helped them until it's suggested that you can be used further.
So unless you're suggesting that the entire Horde faction will fall under Mantid leadership, and help the Mantid pursue their goals, there's just no room for it to happen.
This isn't like Sylvans and the Forsaken, who have their own goals but also assist the Horde, the Mantid just wouldn't bother assisting the Horde... everything about them says that. So unless you're saying the Horde factions would be fine with being used by the Mantid and then the Mantid not helping in return...
Again. There's absolutely no evidence to suggest that there are Mantid who would stop serving the Old Gods.
The Paragon encounter clearly shows that serving the Old Gods is everything that drives them... to the point where they agree to work with Garrosh, because they believe they can serve Y'shaarj that way.
Obviously Blizzard could implement reasons for the Mantid to join the Horde.
They could also implement reasons for the gnomes or Night Elves to have splinter factions that join the Horde.
That doesn't change the fact that EVERYTHING we have seen on the Mantid so far, says that they do not care at all about any other race, and are xenophobic to the point of genocide, have no problem slaughtering other races to strengthen their own forces, and live only to serve the good of the swarm and Y'shaarj and those two things ONLY.
When a Mantid NPC that doesn't care about the other mantid and just wants to learn about Pandaren mist weaving comes along, you point can be completely valid but until then, there is just no room in current lore for a group of Mantid to join the Horde.
Faceless =/= Old Gods.
There is nothing that suggests that the Nerubians stopped serving Yogg-Saron. They angered the faceless ones deep below Northrend and fought a war against them.
It's literally the exact same situation as the Mantid and the Sha.
The Mantid don't serve the Sha or care about it, and the Klaxxi fight against the Sha-touched Mantid, but they always have and according to their own words always will serve the Old Gods.
I'm not saying that Blizzard couldn't come up with some retconning story that explains why the Mantid suddenly forsake the beliefs they've followed for tens of thousands of years, the beliefs that were literally made into them when the Old Gods created them, their intrinsic hatred and xenophobia against non-insect races.
I am saying that in current lore, there's just no way that the Mantid would do such a thing.