Except inquisition is not a dps cool down. Just as slice and dice is not a dps cool down. It's a problematic charge up that makes us completely useless for three globals. That means an decrease in DPS outside of the hybrid tax, poor performance in PVP (I'd like to see you counter this statement as another person made it and it was ignored), and generally making ret feel like a cookie cutter spec. There is no complexity as a ret. We all know the rotation and we aren't given a system that compels intelligent gameplay. Look at Boomkin, that is a great spec that rewards smart choices and has significant complexity. You can't tell one good ret paladin from another, that is not the case for a boomkin. Playing ret with inquisition is straightforward, cut and paste. The vocal majority of ret paladins see these things as being true. I'd rather play a complex class than a keyboard roller.