How good was MOP?

[Grumpy Old Man]

No poll?
8/10

[Obtuse]

Is it fair to assume that any one who says something along the lines of "kung-fu panda crap made me unsub" is 12 years is old? Must be, because if that's your reasoning behind disliking MoP you're in for a shock when you finally move out of your mom's basement.

8.5/10 - PvP balance took a bit of a turn for the worst this expac but all 3 raid tiers have been a smash and the polish as a whole has never been better. They'll have to work hard to top it with WoD. I'm more excited to see all the threads next fall about how great MoP truly was.

[PrairieChicken]

I wonder if the guys who are giving it a low score are now burnt out from SoO. It's been out for 7 months now.

No I hated MoP launch due to its massive grinding and gating and heroic dungeons being useless and being forced to run LFR. I prefer 5.4 compared to these days.

[Redpanda]

9/10 would play again

[jrockviggy]

Vanilla: 9/10
BC: 9.5/10
WotLK: 9.5/10
Cat: 8/10
MoP: 8/10

The game is not as fun as it once was, but is still a very fun, very addicting game. It has become less challenging at lower levels, and remained highly challenging at upper levels.

Up until Siege of Orgrimmar, the story of MoP was boring, it didn't center around the lore that I enjoy of WoW (aside from Jin'rokh being a boss, that was neat.)

I think PvP is in a really good state right now, season 15 feels a lot like season 9 did, which was my favorite season thus far in WoW.

[gamingmuscle]

8.5/10 for me...which is on par with Wrath and slightly better than TBC/Vanilla.

[PrairieChicken]

Anyways my perception of MoP is negative overall. The reason is that there is too much grind and gating involved to actually start enjoying the game. If they stuck to wrath/cata progression model I would have called it the best expansion ever...

The patches I enjoyed was 5.3 (heroic scenarios) and 5.4.7 (522 honor gear), basically when you got useful loot without being forced to LFR or do dailies.

Plus they fucked up 10 man raiding since ToT which adds more negativity

[Immitis]

vanilla 10/10
bc 0/10
wrath 8/10
cata 5/10
mists 10/10

[quras]

MoP gets a solid 5 / 10.

There is nothing amazing or even all that interesting about MoP but at the same time it wasn't the worst game I've ever played.

It was average at best and it gets an average score.

In saying that, the longer live goes without content the worse MoP gets.

[Durbi]

Raiding wise it was one of the better ones. Throne of Thunder was magnificent, some of the bosses were in my opinion up there with the finest. SoO wasn't far behind, shame the end boss is mostly nothing more then a BIG gear check. Overral i'd give it 8/10

[badaku]

Pvp 8,5
Pve 7,5
Story 2

[Palmz]

9.5/10. This expansion introduced the most new content. And for the first time ever, every raid was polished and great. The daily grinds were't bad at all if you compare other daily grinds in the past. Not nearly as bad. My only grip with this expansion was the dungeons. They could of been more challenging at the start.

[Vaelorian]

Vanilla: 8 (the best experience in gaming for me at that particular time, loved the game apart from the clear issues with balance/classes/bugs/etc)
TBC: 9 (lacked Lich King Lore)
WOTLK: 9 (would have been a 10 for me if 5 mans would have been as hard as prenerf TBC)
Cata: 7 (loved raiding and prenerf 5 mans, the rest pretty much sucked)
MoP: 8

[Bad Ashe]

ill grade it as 2 out of 4, as in better than cata but worse than wrath or bc.

[crakerjack]

Vanilla: 8/10
TBC: 10/10
Wotlk: 9/10
Cata: 4/10
MoP: 6/10
Hopefully WoD will be better.

[Deleted]

if there were no pandas but something else, it could be good. I really dislike the pandaren idea that much. So it's like 5 for me, because there are good things too.

[Grishnok]

Vanilla - 7/10
BC - 8.5/10
WOTLK - 9/10
Cata - 2/10
Mop - 4.5 to 5 /10

I felt the xpac was put together well, I just didnt care for the shit-ton of dailies, the story, the lore, the pseudo fortune cookie wisdom shit jammed down my throat. And I am still up in the air about timeless isle. Good in concept, shit in execution and I hate the personal loot system being attached to flex.

Overall the xpac wasnt fuckin terrible like cataclysm was by its end, but tbh I have been burned out by the environment and setting/story far faster than any other xpac to date. Including cata.

[Ateista]

I love how people keep rating vanilla into 8 and above, which has me wondering if they really played it.

I quit halfway through this xpac, though not because I hated it - time constraints and me more being bored with wow in general.

Up to when I quit id give this xpax a 7/10. It was dark, the heroic raid content was fun, and monk was a blast (made new main).

Dailies, as per usual, were boring as fuck and questing to 90 was way to linear.

Also, lawl at the pvp complainers. This game will always, till the end of time, be a pve game; you should feel lucky it even has pvp.

[Deleted]

Before MOP Wrath was my number one all time favourite time in wow. Loved Wrath to bits! But Now i've played MoP all the way through, i've got to say MOP has been fucking amazing. (well for me personally) I've had so many good times, had so much fun with raiding, friends, farming stuff. It's by far my favourite expansion!

9.5/10

[mistahwilshire]

From a hardcore raiding perspective, 9/10.