Sometimes on sha mark goes out right before swelling pride goes out which can at the same time that swelling does pretty much one shotting someone. 2 people with gift of the titans 4 marks go out which means 2 can get dispelled for no pride leaving 2 to take it man mode.
My question is: dispel or shield one of the two that get the undispelled mark?
Personally I've been spirit shelling 4 groups for swelling and then tossing a shield but the druid in my raid has been crying that it needs to be dispelled but I figure that potentially crit shielding for ~500k on top of the spirit shell would be a stronger way for the person to survive than a dispel and letting the people with gift dispel when off CD again so that people don't gain unnecessary pride.
So am I doing this right or should I be dispelling? Btw the guild is pretty under geared for heroics since ~10 of our raid spots seem to be a revolving door of late so our raid dps is a lot lower than it should be and we have some tards taking extra damage when they shouldn't be.