Quote Originally Posted by Aimeez View Post
By extra damage do you mean Essence of Yu'lon, the proc? That damage doesn't contribute to Atonement healing - it would be way too good if it did! The two advantages for healing are the lack of Spirit and incidental cleave from Essence of Yu'lon allowing for a higher ToF uptime.
No, meant the stat contributions, specifically Crit. More Crit being more damage being more Atonement.
The proc is just a damage bonus, akin to using SW:Pain is just a bonus, as you say to ToF. The stats of the DPS cloak are better geared for greater offensive capacity.