Originally Posted by
Soulwind
Black Mesa was a somewhat-fanmade remake of Half-Life 1. It had been in development for quite a while, and released a few years ago. Unfortunately, the game ends before the last chapter of the original game, with the devs essentially telling you "we're almost there, give us some more time to properly remake Xen".
What is shown here is not just a remake of the environments shown in Half-Life, but a massive, mostly original, world created from scratch. It is impressive, very much so, but one can't help but wonder if making a more faithful remake of the original wouldn't have saved them a lot of time and effort.
Nobody asked them to improve on what Valve made (which they most likely have, given the trailer), so it's slightly bittersweet that they have taken this long to create their own version of Xen, beautiful as it may be.
I guess if they had spent all this time and creativity on a project of their own, it wouldn't have gotten nearly as much attention as this will. I can't say I don't understand their reasons or appreciate their work, I just wish this could have been included in the release version of Black Mesa somehow.