Multiple times I have had really bad luck and been hit with critical hits even when the move was suppose to be weak against me. They are elite( purple pets) up to legendary( orange) and of course one counters those pets with the proper pet counter but still they critically hit you a lot. To say that doesn't happen is a lie or you are always lucky and I have the worst luck ever. I do have horrible luck with rng in this game anyway I did the x-mas thing everyday on 22 toons and did not get the grumpus mount so my usual rng luck. Heck I get bad rng crit hits when doing the pandaria trainers to level pets to this very day. Not always but enough to have to lose and have to redo the fight every now and then. In the CT random crits happen a lot more often.
I know plenty of friends and/ or guildies that gave up on the CT due to frustration over rng. And I would tell them level up a few extras so rng isn't a factor some listened some didn't.
Yes those guides are great but some depend on certain breeds to pull them off and people looking for short cuts tend to over look that. People can and do make mistakes and hit wrong moves at times and that will cost you in the CT. All I am saying is level a few extra pets to take rng and human error out of the equation. One doesn't even need to level the pets open up pet menageries and one gets a free level 25 stone. Or do it a pet bonus xp week and it literally takes two panadrian pet tamer battles.
I don't see why you are arguing to not make it easier on oneself? Really don't see the logic behind your arguing.
My problem with the guides was i'd always be missing some obscure pet (not blue, not level 25 etc) like Brown Marmot or a second blue s/s Nordrassil Wisp.
The howl bomb combo is getting addressed in legion, so you might as well seek additional pets and mass train them to blue status for future pet battles.
I was frustrated with having to restart every time xu fu crit my chrominus, however on the wowhead page for xu fu there are many pet combos that will down him regardless of crit and are not used in previous rounds, such as the micro sentry lil bling tranquil mechanical yeti
rank 1 dk
find me on vindicatum.com