Originally Posted by
anon5123
yes, just go ahead and strawman anyone who disagrees with your views
that's the way to start a constructive discussion
The problem with Atonement is not "wanting mindless dps", it's that by the time you've got Atonements set up on people, other healers have healed most of that damage. The only quick and effective way to get lots of atonements out is with a spell that has a cooldown, and provides much shorter duration Atonements.
When all the other healers are reactive, Disc has to work extra hard and plan ahead of time just to keep up with their healing.
"proactive healer" is a neat idea on paper, but in execution, it's clunky and demanding to play, outside of highly coordinated groups.