CSPAN has done a survey since 2000 involving a bunch of US Presidential historians to rate the at-the-time former Presidents of the US, in order, using a numerical scale on multiple factors such as "Economic Management" and "Administrative Skills".
Since Trump is now a former, he's on the list. In position #41.
"Who was #40?"
William Henry Harrison.
"...didn't he die like a month into his tenure?"
Yes.
"
Ouch."
Trump's final score was 312, tied with Franklin Pierce. (Lincoln, untouchably #1, has a 897. Obama is #10 with 664)
"He got the tax cut for the rich passed. Surely his Econominc Management result was high."
I mean, it was one of his better scores. He ranked 34th in that one.
"But the man could lead a crowd, sometimes even into a murderous insurrection. Did he get any credit for that?"
Public Persuasion was his best showing. He came in 32nd.
"Well at least he didn't come in dead last."
He did in Moral Authority and Administrative Skills. No big surprise to the man who blew off COVID while being impeached the
first time.
"Wait, he didn't bl--"
Trump said, 'yeah, okay' and hung up the phone when his health secretary warned him about the coronavirus in January 2020, a new book says
"Wait, what?"
Now I know we've all heard this story before: after a big disaster, we get info about the people who mentioned it beforehand. We saw it with the 9/11 planes, we are seeing it unfold in real time with the Florida building collapse, and this is just another one. People in charge likely hear tons of reports about problems or potential problems. We rarely hear about this kind of warning when nothing happens. But bear in mind the scope of this one, plus the fact that Trump hired Azar
for exactly this reason. There is a differnce between some random guy saying "I heard your brakes squeaking, you might want to check them out" versus your mechanic saying "You're out of brake fluid, you can't stop your car, for the love of God please let me fix it before you try to drive home". Trump ignored his mechanic, pulled onto I-95 in rush hour, and caused a massive pileup.
And we'll never know if Trump hung up because
1) Xi had already told him this wasn't a problem, and Trump believed him
2) Trump was still angry at Azar for banning flavored ecigs, which apparently he was yelling at Azar for during that same phone call
3) Trump wanted some alone time and just didn't want to do his job that day
4) It was over 140 characters and Trump lost interest
None of these are redeeming options.
I'm sure Azar wants to be the 1,475th person to claim "I was the only one in the White House to bla bla bla" and escape from having Trump's Shitshow ruin his legacy. Considering how many times I cited what Trump said on Jan 22, this claimed behavior from Trump seems 100% on brand, and therefore I choose to believe it based on existing evidence. But even if Azar
claims he did everything he could as HHS, he neither went public with this info to sound the alarm when Trump refused, nor did he resign in protest. I looked for anything in the news from Azar from Jan 1-22
and found only this that was relevant. Oh,
and Trump yelling at Azar Jan 17th for not doing enough to lower drug prices. Nothing about Azar screaming for help, nothing about Azar resigning until a full year later Jan 16th 2021. So he can claim he did all he could, but that's a lie. Just like Barr, honestly.
With 400,000 dead while Trump was in office (or was it higher?) Trump's proven inactions killed more Americans than nearly any natural disaster in US history, and any war other than the Civil War. I'm saying the "dead last" place for Trump is warranted.
By the way, people
flocked to fill out this survey. In 2017 they had 91 responces, this time it was 142. Historians and professors in history were lining up to answer this. Gee, I wonder why. The survey's website gives scores for everyone, but I don't see a lot of written explanations from the responses so I don't have any quotes. Just the results of an army of professional, qualified experts who said that Trump was equally as bad as Franklin Pierce,
slavery advocate in 1853 to 1857.