
Originally Posted by
ravenmoon
Yeh, void elves are basically the human buddy high elf that can be playable so they could avoid giving high elves who looked like blood leves, but then eventually just ended up doing so anyway, so now you have 2 thalassian elf factions on the alliance. Which is also fine. It frees night elves now to be night elves as they were originally meant to be, as you now have the thalassian taking on the human friend elf position for your LotR type fantasy.
The Thalassians are a core portion of the alliance, their origin and beginnings in the series is tied directly to the alliance and they are a core part of it's identity. Even when giving the blood elves to the horde, blizzard left the high elves around. Now we have void elves too.
To me that's fine, the driving force of the elves should always be the alliance. And they should be stronger on their because the race is very alliance themed and centred, especially the Thalassians.
Right now the horde doesn't need blood elves being so big on, mi think it would do the faction identity a huge favour if the bulk of elven development sat squarely on the alliance, while the horde remained a token force to allow pretty model options for players who wouldn't play it otherwise, rather than driving huge developments for elves on a faction that clearly has little to nothing in common with it. Blood elves are too alliance in character, and Nightborne too kaldorei - they are blatantly alliance and night elves on the horde - and if they are given limelight on the horde, they detract away from the contrast between the factions making them seem too similar.
the best solutions is to stoop promoting them on the horde, and instead focus on building alliance night elves (with their Highborne, druids and priests ) as hte main centre of all things kaldorei (past and presents) and void elves and high elves to carry on most of the developments regarding Thalassians.
Three options that could take major steps to shifting this perspective amongst players would either be:
1. Take Silvermoon and Suramar to the alliance and convert the blood elves living in them to high elves, and Nightborne to night elves -with only a remnant remaining horde blood elves and true Nightborne on the horde). Compensate the horde losses by adding the city of Zul'aman + amani, City of Zul'drak plus the Drakkari, a city for the Mag'har (my fave location is Warsong hold Borean Tundra), and either a new goblin city (expanded Kezan or undermine) or the Farakki and Zul'farrak - this would reinforce the horde major themes. And whiles blood elves and Nightborne still remain on the horde, they are a very minor part in the larger scheme.
2. Share Silvermoon with the void elves and high elves, Share Suramar with the night elves and Nightborne - this helps reinforce in game the fact that Silvermoon is the home of the high elves, and Suramar the home of the Night elves even though Nightborne are there, but they are night elf off shoot even though on the horde.. same with blood elves.
In this scenario Silvermoon has a enforced sanctuary status and elves don't kill each other or fight to in order to defend the Sunwell and protect their heritage while they argue and try to sway one another to the cause of one of the 3 factions of Thalassians. Meanwhile it's different in Suramar - Nightborne aren't that attached to the horde at all. Blood elf friendship kept them there, when the kaldorei refugees needed homes they were allowed to return to their former capital now having lots of extra space due to the high death toll of the legion. Nightborne do not hate kaldorei, in fact quite the opposite, and events of legion should have removed the last vestiges arcane stigma, now their is a cure and Thalyssra drained the nightwell.
night elves/Nightborne are ancient, the alliance and horde really should be secondary concerns to the, not dominate them. it's so weird to write them as ancient civilizations that have lived for over 10k millennia and dominated the world only to now seem to entirely define themselves by the horde and the alliance.. it's just poor, it's as if they write something and forget the main description and what it means.. they need to fix that, a capital share would achieve this.
3. Create 2 great new cities for both Night elves and the alliance Thalassians. That show off the best of the kaldorei people and the high elf and void elf. So while Silvermoon and Suramar remain horde, basically these new homes for night elves and void elves with high elves blow them out of the water. in this scenario, the horde elves are untouched, but most of the elven developments are now done and advanced on the alliance, whereas on the horde, focus is given to the orcs, trolls tauren, goblins etc.
This is what they should do in order of preference. 1 would be the best, if not 2, if not 3.