Official High Elf Discussion Megathread

[MyWholeLifeIsThunder]

should just split the silver covenant into 2 groups and make them disappear. ones that will turn into void elves and the ones that decide its better to rejoin their home with the blood elves.

Agree with the conceit, yet not the means. At this time in history, any High Elves with a desire to have rejoined Silvermoon would already chosen to. I would find hard to believe that any thalassian population remains in the alliance with any desire to join the horde. That's not to say that this would have already happened if it did, probably since the end of BC, to the point I could envision blue eyed Blood Elves from those that rejoined Silvermoon since the end of BC.

But of the current alliance high elves? Highly unlikely, since those HE are basically defined by how hardcore alliance they are.

Agree with the "assimilation" theory tho. But instead of forcing them rejoin Silvermoon, just have them assimilated into human culture. Who knows, maybe 5 years from now that would mean the Silver Covenant being a half elf organization. But the best way to "get rid" of most of the High Elves IN GAME as the lore SHOULD, would be by replicating the Void Elf process, thus also solving the issues of Void Elf population.

[Syegfryed]

It was so true that he somehow forgot, that same thing applies to void elves

not rly, void elves are not fair skinned and all other things

[Deleted]

not rly, void elves are not fair skinned and all other things

That certainly wasnt thing which he repeated from blizzcon, i had in mind that population argument

And where's your proof that he can't replicate it, seeing as you keep making that claim.

I'll even help you: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7pWL9xB8Zc

The whole chain from beginning to end, and no where is it stated that this is a one off, that it can't be replicated. What were your words? Quit headcannoning.

No, you are headcanoning, because nobody has proof, how or if the new void elves are created
You all are just asuming, that new recruits will do poof, and here we have new void elf,

[Gerron]

Ahhh, if only Ion, blessed he be, how I wish he had given his negative answer while he at least acknowledged the points raised by the pro-Helf side. Instead, he literally just repeated what he said back in November -which on itself sparked the discussion- disregarding the last 6 months of discussions about the issue. Fastest way to piss off a fraction of the audience that we can all agree is very vocal.

You can either double down on your original argumentation -the one that sparked these few last months of yelling in the first place lets remember- or at least take into account what the feedback said on the last 6 months even if your answer is still no. And I still believe the later would have been by far the better option.

NOTE: This is all based on the premise that High Elves are just not gonna happen for the alliance, that's said and done. But this show us how dispensable feedback from their audience is for WoW. And before you go "High Elves are a stupid issue" that's the point, it goes beyond how pointless you perceive the request to be, Blizzard is a company that SHOULD WANT to be respectful of their audience, not a single person giving/agreeing with an opinion. This is wholly a PR issue at this point, and no matter how vindicated some of you feel by Ion's answer, some of you seem not to understand that a company should be appeasing of its audience instead of simply alienating it.

But Alas. Ion said nothing new, offered no new insights of their reasons or what the future holds for Alliance High Elves. Just no. For me, that's enough, but even for me, I can't help to say his answer was mishandled, regardless of the decision, but how he approached the request. He just doesn't seem to understand that is more than just about a "fair skinned, blonde, blue eyed elf" and that "the horde is waiting for you."

And that honestly, just pisses on the reason why people want to play High Elves, regardless that Ion and some of you misunderstand.

So what can we do? Just expect that BfA is so good that it just pushes the High Elf issue on the wayside? Or so bad that HE are the least of issues to worry? Certainly I wish for this whole thing blows up someday.

And personally, that they DO something about the Silver Covenant cause I just want a pay off for that. Void them? (Ohh "Void Covenant") Kill them? reveal next expansion that they are actually mostly Half Elves and make them playable? Honestly I'd love the third one, but at this point I settle for ANY resolution, instead of them remaining the unplayable elephant in the room.

I think there is a larger issue underlying all of this. Alliance players haven't really gotten the Allied races they have asked for. Dark Iron when people have been requesting Wildhammer. Lightforged Draenei instead of Broken. Void Elves instead of High Elves. There are good reasons why they didn't go with what players asked for but it does give off the sense that Blizzard isn't really listening to Alliance player requests. The issue now is that we won't be getting Broken or Wildhammer.

[MyWholeLifeIsThunder]

are we implying now that he didn't acknowledged?

I'm literally saying he didn't acknowledge any points made by the pro-helf side. He just doubled down on his previous answer

maybe because what he said was true no matter how the high movement tried to change with headcanon and fanfics, so there was no need to change hi statement?

It's baffling how hard for some people is to understand the difference between "being in the right" and "respecting your audience's feedback."

If you think that his answer is justified by the pro-helf side being in the wrong, you are missing the point I'm making.

And really, by thinking that this whole HE issue had a wrong/right side is so naive at this point. It's literally just about what the developers want to go for, there were arguments for, there were arguments against, yet people like you still believe somehow one side was "empirically correct." But this is besides the point.

- - - Updated - - -

What it showed was, regardless of how much feedback they get, with supporting evidence from in-game. Or even suggestions/compromises that the community themselves could come up with to hope for their race choice to be implemented.

None of it matters. Even for a topic where they said let us know what you'd like to see. Didn't matter. They have set plans for what they want to do. It makes the whole "tell us" look like complete hogwash. Especially when multiple interviews they laid out the criteria for what factors in when selecting an AR as a candidate, and one of the biggest was community interest.

They even noticed it was a popular request, regardless of them saying no.

So really it's a case of "don't even try to be passionate since we already have our own plans"

Even the newest Sethrak continuation thread on the forums, made after the Q&A. The first few posts give their condolences to the HE group and some talk as if "maybe it's good we're not noticed by the Blues - look what happened to the Helf community" That's a pretty crazy turn around for what people should be saying on the forums.

The developers have all the right to make the decision they want, that is simply not the issue. Feedback is not about merely giving in to a request, but understanding why people are making the request.

And the calible of Ion's response makes it evident the large of the pro-high elf feedback was simply dismissed without consideration.

"Thanks for your consideration" is a polite response I wish pro high elf people could have given to Ion and Blizz.

[Syegfryed]

That certainly wasnt thing which he repeated from blizzcon, i had in mind that population argument

thats is the problem from you and the others, the population argument is not the only argument

and just because one argument is not used to A situation don't mean they should not use in B situation

[rpdrichard]

your argument is flawless when we, and with WE i talk both factions, spend most of wow lifetime killing orcs, trolls undeads and elves

the most recent expansion was about killing orcs, and shitting on orc story

TBC we prob kill more elves and orcs than actually "demon" i guess

undeads are the main kill loot in WtlK, with one dungeon now and then

and of course trolls, the most loot pinata of all races, one troll raid per expansion was not just a meme afterall.

So, your argument is invalid. For alliance they don't have problem with the "faction wall" because they have no eminent danger of one of their races going to horde, this problem is only for the horde and then alone, screw then

And of course they( only the ones who want HE prob) don't care about the faction wall if this mean getting what they desire, selfish? maybe, i bet alliance players would not want lose dwarfs and humans to the horde in the trade.

I wouldn´t have mind giving dark iron in exchange for high elves, we´ve been fighting them since vanilla anyway so it was odd to me having some of them as allies in cataclysm. I can say the same about defias or alterac human.

Truth is I've always found nonsensical the faction wall, specially after WC III Reing of Chaos and Frozen Throne, my first tought when I played WoW on WoTLK and found the races were locked behind two factions was "WTH didn´t got over this stupid thing in WC II?"

[Deleted]

thats is the problem from you and the others, the population argument is not the only argument

and just because one argument is not used to A situation don't mean they should not use in B situation

So you agree that ion's words arent holy and that he can be sometimes wrong,even though he is god

[Highwhale]

Who exist as a fraction of the main race.

Again, you do not deserve high elves, nor is Blizzard expected to cater to you being unable to move on with the story.

You talk of headcanon and yet pretend as if high elves are something you are owed.

Speaking of irony...

[Aldo Hawk]

blood elves are what we see ingame, exactly the same as high elves


its not me, its the HE crowd who suggest that, for then hairstyle and tattoos is enough



i suggest white eyes, the sign of no magic, but guess what? only blue eyes is ok




again this come up the argument of horde players wanting maghar orcs from outland, but with changing facial structure and another idle, thats just nonsense to back up your desire


it was exactly what i suggest, skinny( slightly changed in the body who could mean another idle) pale skin( not void elf like) and white eyes due to the withdraw of magic

but again, no, people want an enhanced model of BE/HE who don't make then different enough like many times i see in the topic

there is even the suggest of half-elves, so they would look bulkier than normal elves, due to human blood, but people don't want it, they only want pure elves



you don't need to prove yourself right when you didn't even try to be right



high elves and nightborne work in the same way, without a source of magic their body become weak, and could lead to sequelae, its the addiction their share since they were highborne. its jut like eating, if you don't eat enough or don't eat at all,you become weak, more fragile, skinny, not bulky

the frozen throne campaign kael stated his kin is becoming weak, fragile, with the hunger, their eyes become white cause they have no magic to feed, the exiled elves from lorthemar stated the same thing, and the relief they felt when Sunwell came back

Atleast you are being kind of constructive...

But just one thing, i didn't saw any evidence of nightborne getting sick for suck too much mana, and high elves transforms into wretched when they suck too much.

[MyWholeLifeIsThunder]

I think there is a larger issue underlying all of this. Alliance players haven't really gotten the Allied races they have asked for. Dark Iron when people have been requesting Wildhammer. Lightforged Draenei instead of Broken. Void Elves instead of High Elves. There are good reasons why they didn't go with what players asked for but it does give off the sense that Blizzard isn't really listening to Alliance player requests. The issue now is that we won't be getting Broken or Wildhammer.

Definitely agree to a point. I don't believe there is some sort of bias here, but it is true that the most requested alliance Allied Races haven't been added, which certainly feeds the perception that Blizz simply is not considering what alliance players request. They don't have to by any means, but it just adds to the perception of bad faith, intentionally or not, which is not good.

Had we had Broken and Wildhammer-even as just cosmetics for Dwarves- the perception that the alliance is being unheard would have been much lower, so the whole Helf movement would be less pissed because it wouldn't me mired in the notion that the alliance as a whole isn't getting what they want.

If HE were the only of the requested races to be a no-go, the request for them would certainly be at least more insular, don't know if less vocal though.

[Syegfryed]

I'm literally saying he didn't acknowledge any points made by the pro-helf side. He just doubled down on his previous answer

thats because he don't need to acknowledge wrong points at all

It's baffling how hard for some people is to understand the difference between "being in the right" and "respecting your audience's feedback."

its baffle how people are so over sensitive that everything is "disrespecting"

he just said blood elves are high elves, they are already playable, and if you want play one you can, but in horde

all those points are true, no matter how people tried to work around

you think would be better if he just said: thanks for the effort but they are all meaningless cause they are all wrong

[Zulkhan]

It's really, absolutely hilarious to see so many people getting mad and insulting Ion, calling him ignorant and whatever, when those very people are the first to puke, shit and piss over all logic and reason, let alone the game's lore, in order to get a whim of theirs satisfied. Can't say I'll ever feel particularly sympathetic for High Elf faithfuls of any kind but for sure, concerning these people in particular, I'm nothing but glad of the response Ion gave them (again) because they never deserved, not even once, to have their wishes realized.

[Syegfryed]

So you agree that ion's words arent holy and that he can be sometimes wrong,even though he is god

no, i agree that one argument can be used for a thing, but cannot used for others, there is exceptions for a rule

the void elf is the exception cause others reasons.

[Aldo Hawk]

I think he has never played alliance not really and doesn't realize just how much HE are used/thrown in our faces

I did not had to play in the alliance to see this, as i said before, i never leveled more than 20 levels in alliance, i am horde from 2009.

[Friendlyimmolation]

Speaking of irony...

You keep misusing that word.

[Jastall]

People were also willing to have High Elves come using the Human skeleton or Night skeleton approach if using the Blood Elf skeleton/model was the biggest issue. The fact Ion's answer didn't seem to take into consideration, which was known for several months is what I believe led to a lot of people not appreciating the way he answered.

His answer didn't seem to take the discussion that had been going on for months, it more seemed like an answer to communicating that "high elves need to be in now!" when also the other well known high elf discussion topic said in big bold that I guess people didn't read at all: they understood high elves would come much later after other playable races got their own version of allied races (goblin/worgen/undead/gnomes).

But that makes no sense. High Elves are physically identical to Blood Elves, save the eyes and even then. Making them different for its own sake, just to justify giving them to the Alliance, is pretty much exactly what the Void Elves are yet people complained about that.

Whereas Nightborne being different from Night Elves is easily explained by the 10 000 years of divergent history and over reliance on Arcane magic.

[Deleted]

The thalassian elves are not an integral part of the identity of the Alliance. How can they be when only a tiny number of them exist on the Alliance faction?

They were present long before Silvermoon's finally came out of the shadows in TBC, and joined the Horde. They didn't pack up and go back to Silvermoon, they stuck with Jaina/Vereesa and other separate groups.

At a first glace, it might seem odd, given Garithos and all, then again, Stormwind/Theramore are entirely different political entities. Just because Garithos's clique tried to purge them up in Lordaeron does not extend to the other human nations.

And they were called upon in war with the Horde ever since. Like I said before, it's a similar status as the Pandaren. The race is present in both factions, and either considers the other an enemy.

Their efforts as significant as any of the other members of the Alliance, to not count them alongside Humans, Dwarves, Gnomes, Worgen, Night Elves, Draenei, and Void Elves would be quite the disservice to the High Elves.

[Deleted]

It's really, absolutely hilarious to see so many people getting mad and insulting Ion, calling him ignorant and whatever, when those very people are the first to puke, shit and piss over all logic and reason, let alone the game's lore, in order to get a whim of theirs satisfied. Can't say I'll ever feel particularly sympathetic for High Elf faithfuls of any kind but for sure, concerning these people in particular, I'm nothing but glad of the response Ion gave them (again) because they never deserved, not even once, to have their wishes realized.

That reminds me that self fulfilling prophecy with tyrande... lets mock them how bad and entitled are they.. Oh, they are indeed behaving badly, i was right all along.

[Highwhale]

You keep misusing that word.

Ofcourse you start to play your favorite game "what this word mean and how you uneducated ape wrongly using it". Huh. Nothing new I see.