Official High Elf Discussion Megathread

[Sanguinerd]

774 pages and the debate is finally over, High Elves are officially Horde.

Yay!

[Itisamuh]

Yes, the blood elves are physiologically the same, but they are disgusting, pathetic, little pieces of shit ! My single best time in WoW is the Purge of Dalaran, were I could slaughter them again and again in the streets, because those damn rats have joined with the Horde and proved that they have an utter lack of moral and values.

Fascinating.

[Sekach]

You anti-Helf really are dense, it's impressive.

OF COUSE IT'S ALL POLITICAL !

Is it clear enough here ?

Yes, the blood elves are physiologically the same, but they are disgusting, pathetic, little pieces of shit ! My single best time in WoW is the Purge of Dalaran, were I could slaughter them again and again in the streets, because those damn rats have joined with the Horde and proved that they have an utter lack of moral and values.

I want to play the High Elves. Those who said "Fuck you" to their Kingdom when they finally realized how corrupt it was; those who were exiled because hey refused to survive at the cost of their morality. I want the High Elves. Those of the Lodges, Stormwind and the Silver Covenant. I hate the Blood Elven zone. I hate interacting with Blood Elves NPCs, who are all either corrupt or hypocritical.

But I love being around HE NPCs because of their moral compass, their values, their determination to endure, no matter what, by staying true to themselves and the morals their profess.

That's why Blood Elves aren't High Elves. Not anymore. The former are despicable when the latter are admirable.

That's really as simple as that.

Oh dear that's tragic. I guess you will just have to keep on alternating between fantasizing and frothing at the mouth on the forums while High Elves run around wearing Horde colours.
On a related note how neat would it be if Vereesa returned to the fold? I mean at this point its just a formality, might as well have her join the council. Loose a Windrunner, gain a Windrunner!

[FossilFree]

Here's a question. Who the fuck is sticking to just one side and intentionally missing out on half the game?

If you're sticking to just one side you deserve to miss out, that includes for alliance fair skinned thalassian elves.

So why didn't Nightborne have the peach skin tones of Blood Elves? Shouldn't Horde players have been required to experience the Alliance half of the game to get arcane purple tones?

That is what you call a double standard.

[Kallisto]

So why didn't Nightborne have the peach skin tones of Blood Elves? Shouldn't Horde players have been required to experience the Alliance half of the game to get arcane purple tones?

That is what you call a double standard.

No a double standard would be putting a horde race on the Alliance and just give nothing back like high elf fans want.

Also why would anyone want to play a race that basically has been victims of abuse by the Alliance no fewer than 3 times only to be on the side of the abuser? That's what playing a high elf is.

[Lieutenant Commander]

High Elves shouldn't exist in the first place. They were a mistake of WotLK, together with neutral Dalaran. Kirin Tor should've been HUMAN and Alliance only, with helves having been taken care of by good ol' Othmar while the belves (now comprised of all remaining thalassians) should've remained in the horde mudhut or something.

[Aeula]

You anti-Helf really are dense, it's impressive.

OF COUSE IT'S ALL POLITICAL !

Is it clear enough here ?

Yes, the blood elves are physiologically the same, but they are disgusting, pathetic, little pieces of shit ! My single best time in WoW is the Purge of Dalaran, were I could slaughter them again and again in the streets, because those damn rats have joined with the Horde and proved that they have an utter lack of moral and values.

I want to play the High Elves. Those who said "Fuck you" to their Kingdom when they finally realized how corrupt it was; those who were exiled because hey refused to survive at the cost of their morality. I want the High Elves. Those of the Lodges, Stormwind and the Silver Covenant. I hate the Blood Elven zone. I hate interacting with Blood Elves NPCs, who are all either corrupt or hypocritical.

But I love being around HE NPCs because of their moral compass, their values, their determination to endure, no matter what, by staying true to themselves and the morals their profess.

That's why Blood Elves aren't High Elves. Not anymore. The former are despicable when the latter are admirable.

That's really as simple as that.

You seem quite angry there, friend. Have you considered taking a break from the forums and all discussion about the game to calm down and come back to this thread with a clear head?

[McToaster]

OK Let Us Change Factions Now and All is Set.

Mod Edit: Don't use giant fonts in this fashion.

[Obelisk Kai]

Which just shows it was never about "lore", it was always about an aesthetic. If they cared about the lore so much they wouldn't ask for high elf options via void elves.

Of course it's about the aesthetic for the vast majority of those seeking this, which is why the abandonment of the goal of a High Elf Allied race in favour of ersatz high elves on a Void Elf won't trouble most of them.

Some probably genuinely care about the idea of a Warcraft 2 style high elf, however as this morning's datamining has helpfully demonstrated, that is in fact a Blood Elf.

[Obelisk Kai]

Considering how much people have been vocal about Warcraft outgrowing the Horde/Alliance dichotomy by this point, this is not even a question for many at this point.

The faction dichotomy is at this point both a part of the identity of the game as well at its biggest hindrance narratively, which was thoroughly tested and found wanting during BfA. WoW cannot rely on the factions if their design of them is so monolithical it breaks immersion and dumbs down the narrative -which has become exponentially more about the large world threats rather than petty political struggles-

My point is not that we should "get rid of the factions" but that faction dichotomy alone can't carry this game forward at this point; continuing to put "faction identity integrity" as a priority just seems to be a handicap rather than a feature at this point.

Hence why I support ideas such as third factions or unlocking races from their faction, because this game evidently is struggling by continuing to present a hard faction dichotomy in a manner that makes sense.

IMO there is a need to downplay the faction's importance to allow the world to evolve, again, BfA has only cemented the notion that the focus on horde/alliance and the NEED to make it balanced because it's so focused as the identity of the game just hinders the game.

There is no point in having two factions without faction dichotomy. So long as two factions exist, those two factions should be kept unique and distinct in order that their mutual antagonism and mistrust makes sense. Should the faction system be removed, and everyone is allowed to group with everyone, then that is a clear design change that does not favour one small group over everyone else.

The faction debate is also tangential to this debate. This debate would be permanently resolved if the faction divide was removed as those who wish to play a blood elf with the desired aesthetic among Alliance players could do that. But so long as the factions exist, they matter, and so long as they matter the preservation of their diversity is an important design goal.

[Frenchvince]

Before/after:







Good guys, Blizzard updates the High Elf NPCs: p

I do not make the parrot, I inform you.

[Strippling]

You anti-Helf really are dense, it's impressive.

OF COUSE IT'S ALL POLITICAL !

Is it clear enough here ?

Yes, the blood elves are physiologically the same, but they are disgusting, pathetic, little pieces of shit ! My single best time in WoW is the Purge of Dalaran, were I could slaughter them again and again in the streets, because those damn rats have joined with the Horde and proved that they have an utter lack of moral and values.

I want to play the High Elves. Those who said "Fuck you" to their Kingdom when they finally realized how corrupt it was; those who were exiled because hey refused to survive at the cost of their morality. I want the High Elves. Those of the Lodges, Stormwind and the Silver Covenant. I hate the Blood Elven zone. I hate interacting with Blood Elves NPCs, who are all either corrupt or hypocritical.

But I love being around HE NPCs because of their moral compass, their values, their determination to endure, no matter what, by staying true to themselves and the morals their profess.

That's why Blood Elves aren't High Elves. Not anymore. The former are despicable when the latter are admirable.

That's really as simple as that.

Just a game bud, no need to get so worked up over fantasy races.

And by the way, alliance aligned high elves are not a moral compass. From quelithian lodge to the purge, to forsaking family.

[Obelisk Kai]

Don't rage about this until you see the blue eyes in character creation, datamining can mean anything, and until it's implemented, don't freak out. I honestly believe Blizz isn't gonna touch the blue eyed blood elf issue, but we'll see.

They have literally added four or five blue eyed options to the Blood Elf files. The Death knight eye colour files were apparently specifically marked as such and not investigated during the stream. NPCs would only need one unique eye colour. Instead, we have several shades of blue which matches the several shades of green and gold that are also present. Heterochromia options involving blue eyes are missing, but they could easily be added before the end of the beta.

Whilst you are correct that all of this is no guarantee Blood Elves will end up with blue eyes, a dispassionate look at the available facts would conclude that the odds are overwhelmingly in favour of these being available. You are predicating your belief they won't be added on the idea that Blizzard considers the objections of the pro high elf crowd as something to gingerly step around, to accommodate. As I have argued before, why would they prioritise the feelings of those who wish to reserve blue eyes for alliance high elves, a group Blizzard has already ruled out, over the desires of people playing Blood Elves right now? That has never made sense.

I think it is far more likely than not Blood Elves will end up with blue eyes. But time will tell.

[MrLachyG]

OK Let Us Change Factions Now and All is Set.

you already can bro. using a faction change which you buy

[ilgynoth]

Finally the High Elves are there where they belong. As a customization option for the Blood Elves. They were the same race all long so its the only right option

Mod Edit: Don't use giant fonts in this fashion.

[Domm530]

Pretty sad how many of the same naysayers are still here, but eh, if that's what they find fun to each their own I guess. Just hope it won't be too long until the only faction I've ever really wanted to play for well over a decade is made available.

My idea as mentioned way back would still be to have the race option be added as a mix of High Elves and half-elves, with the majority of the customization being more in between so as to not overlap more than necessary with Blood Elves (but still having the option of making something that's a pure High Elf).

So the high elves that called themseves blood elves afther the massacre are now not high elves from within anymore? Dafuq, what kind of drugs are you using, read the lore about blood elves, youll fast figure out that they are the high elves you desperately want,

[Sylphe07]

I know it's hard to admit it, but no. This will not be a customization but an improvement for the HE npc's model. Blizzard already said it MANY times, you - wont - get - anything - from - the - HE ! Stop hyping yourself for nothing and then beeing in shock.

[Obelisk Kai]

I'll use a simple analogy to show you why you completely miss the point of the High Elf request. If WoW was a WWII game, telling people who wants to play the Free French Forces (High Elves) to play Vichy France (Blood Elves) would be ludicrous. Yet, that's what you and other do, parroting Hazzikostas, who has demonstrated time and again that he neither understand nor care to understand the demands of Alliance players.

And, for the millionth time. Blood Elves were High Elves, but they have discarded this name and the theme of the two groups have diverged widly. That you refuses to see it doesn't make it untrue.

Except WoW isn't a World War 2 game. It's faction based fantasy MMO where the factions comprise unique races not available to the other side of the divide. Duplicating a part of one faction to the other undermines the distinctiveness of those factions and degrades the faction barrier.

As for the 'themes' of Blood Elves and the exiles diverging wildly, they have not. Blood Elves and the exiles represent the same theme, generic fantasy elf. That theme is a part of the Horde experience now, just as the Orc theme or the Troll theme is. If you want to play a generic fantasy elf, the Horde is waiting for you.

If you cannot accept the Horde, the 95% Void Elf match is there for you.

The perfect is the enemy of the good. You cannot have 100% of what you want. You should settle for close.

[Manariel]

Void Elves are barely 5% of what I wanted. They are former Blood Elves, break the lore and already made uttelry irrelevant in the very same expansion they were added in.

I want to play the High Elves; not their orc-suckers, undead-whorshippers degenerate brethren from Silvermoon, sorry.

[Obelisk Kai]

Jesus obelisk you wrote me an essay when all I said was wait and see

You consider two paragraphs an essay? Frankly I'd love to just say that you aren't getting them and it's never going to happen and that these blues eyes are almost certainly part of blood elf customizations, but there's a mod warning on this thread saying doing so is considered trolling so anyone expressing an 'anti' point of view is obligated to give a detailed explanation.