You do realize the bat swings both ways right?
If the nightborne recruitement quest states Alleria was not an exile until after the sunwell incident, then it means she was not exiled.
See, here is the issue with your arguments.
You go "Alleria is an exile because all high elves are exiles!" This was your original premise. It was a false one
Then I point out "She wasn't exiled on account of being a high elf since she wasn't there for the incident" That was my point
You then go "but she was exiled after the sunwell incident. So im glad to see you agree with me." This is your point.
It is a rather pathetic attempt at a gotcha attempt that completely undermines your argument entirely.
Want to try that again in a format that does not allow people to read the line of arguments?
Sorry, Alleria was not exiled because she was a high elf, especially when everyone thought she was dead when she and auric and the others went to Outland. It makes absolutely no sense from any narrative point.
I can see it now
Lorthemar: I exile ALL high elves, including Alleria who we think is dead along with auric sunchaser and the others who we think are dead in Outland even though they aren't responsible for the schism in anyway! 8D
I don't believe you thought that argument through.
Sunwell in WotlK
This is bad logic. You do realize the blood elves do work and associate with high elves in the Suramar campaign, so does this mean they are no longer exiles? The logic does not make sense at all. Being an exile means you are barred from your home, but we know this is not the case given the WotLK expansion as well as the latest nightborne recruitement quest. So you can't keep making a statement that is unsupported.
This isn't real life bud, its a video game. Why would the devs put in such background details without reason?
Secondly, high elves are an extreme minority, you wouldn't expect to see them peppered all over the place.
Thirdly, devs stated the high elves left are those that chose not to return home. So if they didn't return home, and the blood elves are still at home, why would they be present?
Fourth, none of the areas that are in game have been updated in Cata. This is a silly argument for you to even make.
"Well we should see it".
yeah and Silvermoon was rebuilt but this isnt shown in game. I guess silvermoon is still in ruins.
- - - Updated - - -
Dude, I am not going to waste time reading your paragraph long complaint. Either address the argument, or you'll need to secede the point.
Your counter argument is false given the statement by the developers in regards to the body types as well as the statements made by them preceding shadowlands.
In essence, now, when you make your dwarf look like a wildhammer dwarf, you can say you are a wildhammer. You are no longer going to be a human who is of stormwind and only stormwind. You are a human, and your background is your own. Per the devs, this is to give players more freedom in their own origin and how they view themselves.
That's a nice story and all, feel free to explain how, otherwise, you're just making a claim for the sake of making one.
You do realize this is the exact point I was making right?
That what you like and accept is silly and not worth a serious discussion.
Your lack of self awareness is worrisome.
You do realize design and the like is entirely relevant towards faction identity yes>
I am glad you like the word demagogy but do not use it to describe my arguments when it describes yours.
After all, you're the only one going on and on about how you feel about others arguments and how those feelings determines whether or not they hold relevance.