Lord of the Rings TV Series Purchased by Amazon

[Raisei]

There was nothing to "fix," given that what she's shown wearing it in the same exact scene that we first see Elendil's armor. And since she doesn't actually go into the battle herself, it seems pretty obvious that it's supposed to be more decorative than practical. Therefore thinner gilded cloth instead of quilted padding like the rest of the soldiers were wearing.

Guards that let their queen or king go onto a battlefield with "decorative" armor usually end up without said queen or king. This isn't a friggin state meeting with another ruler, this is a warzone, representation counts very little. In fact, being visibly the leader while there are still quite possibly archers around is extremely stupid.

If the people would actually allow their queen to be there, then she would be clad in so much steel that she could barely see (which might have been smart in hindsight). Especially since her father is close to death anyway, there is no way they would risk the heir. Especially not for the grand prize of a dozen orcs in a village in the middle of nowhere that means nothing to them.

Just look at this amor... a sword would cut her arm off throught that shirt with ease and her friggin neck is completely unprotected, she isn't even wearing a mail shirt for a bit of protection around the neck. You could take her head clean off with a simple swing.

It's a bad complaint and people making it should feel bad.

"Critics are patently evil!!"

[Flurryfang]

I'm sorry, what? How'd you come to that conclusion?

They're clearly capable of making plate armor, given the set they give to Galadriel (unless that was supposed to be an elven suit they just happened to have laying around).

Then why the hell is all their armor leather? O.o The forces they send to the Southlands, the knights on horses, are clerly just wearing the scale-lookalike leather armor. If that is meant to be actual plate armor, than its badly made and easy to see as fake armor.

Rings of Power should not be a show, that has to take the cheap way. If they want their soldiers to look like they have plate armor on, they should be able to actually make some plate armor for them wear.

[Ghost of Cow]

Is it me, or did his character radically change in the last 20 minutes? Before that you could actually take his claim seriously that he was going to try to heal and help. But then after the reveal his entire tone seems to suggest how much pleasure he took in tricking people, it felt jarring somehow. As if a mask dropped that I never felt he wore. Knowing who he is from the start made me look out for details that betray his real character, but all his talk seemed genuine...

In a better show I would say that he tricked me, despite me looking at him, but here I just think that they wrote a break in his character so that Galadriels rebuttal wasn't too forced.

You're right, he did pull an almost immediate change of personality. I just assumed that he was getting a little too excited now that his stuff was falling into place or something? I dunno.

[Kumorii]

You're right, he did pull an almost immediate change of personality. I just assumed that he was getting a little too excited now that his stuff was falling into place or something? I dunno.

Nah, he was "caught" even though he wasn't. But Galadriel were on his tail and knew who he was because apparently there was no record of him being heir of a king of southlands, which he never said he was and even pointed it out. The show trying to multiple things. Presenting Galadriel to be this great detective who figured him out and having him a master manipulator... Not even sure why the first suspicion of someone "lying" (but never actually did lie) about being an heir means he must be Sauron. He could've easily just say he took the role because she so vehemently pushed it on him despite what he said.

Not even sure why he agreed to be king in the first place if he was Sauron... he never ruled, he said "Yes i'm your king" they cheer and then he's off smithing in Eregion.
Would be cool if he actually became their king and crafted the rings for men there before going to Eregion. Getting their loyalty. Would actually serve a purpose of him lying about being a king in that one moment that amounted to nothing.

EDIT: Have to correct myself a little.
It was the saying "Not of the flesh, but over flesh" that caused the suspicion, but the list of heirs is what she used as proof.

[rhorle]

No, what I'm saying is you're wrong, and at this point you're outright lying about it. NLC wasn't even involved for a decent part of the project. And to urge someone is not synonymous with encouraging someone. If you have to lie about the definition of words in the english language to try to make your point, I'd suggest you at least put some effort in your lie, not just make shit up.

How am I outright lying? Jackson was going to make a watered down script with Miramax until it fell apart. He was shopping that watered down script to different studios. New Line Cinema is who told them to expanded their vision and add in all the things they cut. If it wasn't for NLC getting behind it 110% the movies as we know them wouldn't have existed. Urging and Encouraging are similar words. You are choosing to make a huge difference between them just so you don't have to admit that NLC made the project possible. It is just nitpicking a word I used when if I used the word you wanted the argument would remain the same, strange right?

[Ghost of Cow]

Nah, he was "caught" even though he wasn't. But Galadriel were on his tail and knew who he was because apparently there was no record of him being heir of a king of southlands, which he never said he was and even pointed it out. The show trying to multiple things. Presenting Galadriel to be this great detective who figured him out and having him a master manipulator... Not even sure why the first suspicion of someone "lying" (but never actually did lie) about being an heir means he must be Sauron. He could've easily just say he took the role because she so vehemently pushed it on him despite what he said.

Not even sure why he agreed to be king in the first place if he was Sauron... he never ruled, he said "Yes i'm your king" they cheer and then he's off smithing in Eregion.
Would be cool if he actually became their king and crafted the rings for men there before going to Eregion. Getting their loyalty. Would actually serve a purpose of him lying about being a king in that one moment that amounted to nothing.

It would have been much funnier if he wasn't Sauron at all.

"I just checked Elvipedia, you're not a king at all! ...so you must be Sauron!!!"

"...what? No, I'm just some rando that you picked to be king and kept on my ass about it so I just rolled with it eventually. The fuck is a Sauron?"

[rhorle]

Not even sure why he agreed to be king in the first place if he was Sauron...

His pride. Sauron enviosned himself as some god king of Middle-earth. The only reason why he remained after the first age was because he was to prideful to seek the judgement of Valinor.

"Now Sauron's lust and pride increased, until he knew no bounds, and he determined to make himself master of all things in Middle-earth, and to destroy the Elves, and to compass if he might, the downfall of Númenor. He brooked no freedom nor any rivalry, and he named himself Lord of the Earth. A mask he still could wear so that if he wished he might deceive the eyes of Men, seeming to them wise and fair. But he ruled rather by force and fear, if they might avail; and those who perceived his shadow spreading over the world called him the Dark Lord and named him the Enemy; and he gathered under his government all the evil things of the days of Morgoth that remained on earth or beneath it, and the Orcs were at his command and multiplied like flies."
— The Silmarillion, Akallabêth

[Nerovar]

You can't point out bad costume design for this flagship production with a billion dollar budget because that's nitpicking. Yeah, ok...

[Kumorii]

His pride. Sauron enviosned himself as some god king of Middle-earth. The only reason why he remained after the first age was because he was to prideful to seek the judgement of Valinor.

I'm not questioning his desire to rule or to be "king" over middle earth in general or what his personality is.
By removing the rest of the quote you ignore context.

[rhorle]

The point is that in a 2 billion dollar show they are not using decent costumes.

There is no need to exaggerate the budget. Season 1 was around $715 million. People lump the cost for the rights to bring it closer to $1 billion. However an article a week or two ago stated that it was Netflix that offered $250 million and Amazon's offer was actually lower though it didn't give the amount. HotD still has some complaints and "nitpicks" that equal caring about an undershirt on a Queen not being "real scales". It is just people hand wave those critiques away because they don't dislike the show overall like they do with Rings of Power. Hence why the person randomly brought up the Queen's Shirt again because their other critiques were being countered.

- - - Updated - - -

I'm not questioning his desire to rule or to be "king" over middle earth in general or what his personality is.
By removing the rest of the quote you ignore context.

I didn't ignore any context. You used ... which broke up the sentence and separated the first from the rest. Not to mention even the forum rules say not to use whole post quotes if you don't need to.

His pride still answers your question. He wanted to be king of all. The show implies a "falling out" between him and adar which gives a strong reason for why he would be seeking a "replacement" for his pride. It also gives him a stronger connection to be present for things instead of just the sea hobo Galadrial rescued.

[Skulltaker]

How am I outright lying? Jackson was going to make a watered down script with Miramax until it fell apart. He was shopping that watered down script to different studios. New Line Cinema is who told them to expanded their vision and add in all the things they cut. If it wasn't for NLC getting behind it 110% the movies as we know them wouldn't have existed. Urging and Encouraging are similar words. You are choosing to make a huge difference between them just so you don't have to admit that NLC made the project possible. It is just nitpicking a word I used when if I used the word you wanted the argument would remain the same, strange right?

That's another lie right there. It was always Jacksons aspiration to stay as close to the source material as possible. It was Miramax and Weinstein who tried to force him to do a strongly cut version, and since Miramax/Weinstein held the right to use the material at the time, they imposed the condition that any other studio would have to pick up the costs, which Weinstein/Miramax back then considered to be a dealbreaker. They assumed that Jackson would ultimately give in, which he didn't. NLC picked up the costs and gave Jackson the funding to make a faithful adaptaion, as was always his goal.

And no, it's not just nitpicking, you've been grossly misrepresenting the entire situation from the get-go, starting by the tremendously stupid lie that Jackson wasn't the key figure in getting these movies made. Which he was. And not New Line. They financed it, sure. They acknowledged the potential earnings and had the wisdom to fund a proper movie, sure. It's still Jacksons project.

[rhorle]

That's another lie right there. It was always Jacksons aspiration to stay as close to the source material as possible.

And yet he was working with a watered down script and pitching that script to other studios. So he was clearly more interested in adapting the books then remaining faithful. I'm not grossly misrepresenting the situation. You are nitpicking between encourage and urged. New Line Cinema were the ones that got the movies to be as grand as they are.

[Orby]

I do have to ask.

Did they really need to give the Dwarf Princess gospel magic?

Wait what? I don't think she was singing gospel... it was more of a chant which was similuar to the chants that dwarfs sing. like the misty mountain song from the hobbit movie and how that was sung...

Or at least to my minimal knowledge of gospel I wasnt seeing this

[Veggie50]

So, I've finished the show, and while I appreciate that they're kinda trying to do their own thing, some things don't add upp.

The biggest thing is "Mithril" being explained as containing the light and can heal the corruption by just existing completely rewrites the context surrounding the elves. If Mithril has this trait by default, the elves don't even need the Rings of Power -- and more importantly, the Rings wouldn't even stop working after Sauron's ultimate defeat which is what forces the elves to leave after the fact because they can't sustain themselves and the land.

Further, places like Greenwood who eventually turn into Mirkwood(where Legolas is from) would never change, because Mithril could just keep the decay at bay. Tolkien-wise there simply was no Ringbearer in Greenwood and thus they weren't able to protect the land like say Imladris where Elrond hangs out. And then Greenwood becomes Mirkwood.

I really wanted to discuss the Sauron reveal here but I'm not sure if spoilers are allowed. Long story short, the showrunners have a lot to explain to make this line up with the general lore whatsoever. They've made big bombastic changes and frankly I'm not sure they're able to keep track of everything that now needs to also change or be explained.

- - - Updated - - -



To be fair, Galadriel simply "thinks" that he is dead/lost whatever - when indeed we know that he is not.

I do think it's awful writing. They never even mentioned Celeborn when building Galadriel's character only to namedrop him afterwards as lost/dead. And then of course the whole fandom started shipping Galadriel x Sauron which almost made me physically sick.

I am glad that the actors came out and clarified -- Sauron can't even love in that way and his motivation is ultimate domination no matter what.

Im not sure the mithril plot is counter to your points…

1) the rings were designed to amplify mithrils restorative powers

2) when sauron made the one ring, he tied the elven rings to it aswell. When the one ring was destroyed, the elven rings lost their light aswell.

3) greenwood fell to corruption because there was no elven ringbearer there, as you yourself indicate. This is not inconsistent.

The power of the elven rings was always to “preserve”. I think they did something very creative tying it to mithril.

[bledgor]

Calling out bad armor/cosplay tier armor (actually worse compared to some cosplay I have seen) is not nitpicking.

Nitpicking would be asking why the fuck they have so many scenes of women in the show showing their legs, like seriously half the female cast had a scene where they walked just right to show leg (can only guess that like the nickelodeon/foot guy, there is an amazon/leg guy).

- - - Updated - - -

Im not sure the mithril plot is counter to your points…

1) the rings were designed to amplify mithrils restorative powers

2) when sauron made the one ring, he tied the elven rings to it aswell. When the one ring was destroyed, the elven rings lost their light aswell.

3) greenwood fell to corruption because there was no elven ringbearer there, as you yourself indicate. This is not inconsistent.

The power of the elven rings was always to “preserve”. I think they did something very creative tying it to mithril.

There are some big issues with it, as the leaf/mithril bit implies it straight up just heals the tree/the elves, and isn't consumed. In theory you can then just a large enough chunk of mithril that elves could walk past and they would be "cured". Also would mean that Frodo's mithril chainmail would be invaluable to the elves, and they would want it as it could save them.

It is a stupid plot point to make, as it complicates things now and in the future while adding little good to the story (in my opinion). Like while having some details about it, they left it vague enough to not answer the numerous questions they themselves have now made. I am just left asking why, which to be fair I feel that way about so many of the decisions they made.

[Orby]

anyone else been posting a review on IMDB? Cos my review has been pending for like 4 days :S

[Kumorii]

anyone else been posting a review on IMDB? Cos my review has been pending for like 4 days :S

Did you rate it 5 or below? :P

[Triceron]

So taking a look at these last 2 episodes post Mt. Doom exploding...

I really think Arondir was completely unnecessary to Season 1. He doesn't even show up once in these last two episodes, and as a POV character he has no real conclusion whatsoever to his 'arc', if you can even call it an arc. We just see him appear once throughout the 2 final episodes, and just as a 'cameo'...

I really don't get what kind of story they needed to tell for him and why they bothered having so much focus on his character when ultimately EVERYTHING that was necessary to the plot ended up being given to Galadriel instead once she arrives in the Southlands. Everything. EVEN in the role as the only Elf who is actively shown helping the Southlanders after the eruption.

[Orby]

Did you rate it 5 or below? :P

I rated it a 5. Yes... But the review itself was very constructive... I mentioned all the stuff I loved and tried to be diplomatic as possible. While its easy to rip into the show I did think there was a lot of good. :P

[Kumorii]

I rated it a 5. Yes... But the review itself was very constructive... I mentioned all the stuff I loved and tried to be diplomatic as possible. While its easy to rip into the show I did think there was a lot of good. :P

Yeah, I don't doubt that, seen your posts.
Just couldn't pass up the joke