Lord of the Rings TV Series Purchased by Amazon

[Xath]

It’s not a retcon because it doesn’t necessarily change the continuity of the narrative. She could very well be made queen for a season and the narrative remain the same with her losing the throne to Pharazon and being forced to marry him with everything turning out the same way as the appendices outlined.

It’s a change, but not a retcon.

And what’s more, it’s a good change since a character who never had any agency is barely a character at all. Too many of Tolkien’s characters in this time fit that bill, just a name and nothing more.

It's a retcon and a garbage change. So is making Pharazon an advisor. He rebelled against the throne he didn't serve it. If you wanted a woman to be queen there were multiple other options instead they choose the tragic one who never gained power.

[Adamas102]

The thing i am most sad about when it comes to the shows ending, is the rush of making the rings.

Because ohh what a sequence of scenes it could have been, if they had really put care into showing the amazing work, that would have gone into making 3 extremly powerful magic rings. Like not only the artistry of making the designs and the smithing, but the grinding down of the mold, the fine working of adding jewels and fine art to the surface of them, not even to mention the idea of infusing the rings with tremendous magical power.

Instead, they make it seem so simple and the creation is over so fast. It completly removes the tremoundous importance this has for the world and why this was not a simple solution for the problem of the elves.

I know it is a bad word, but it does give Halfbrand a "mary-sue" moment, coming in with just the right knowledge at the right time.

Sorry, but this is just a crock of nitpicky bullshit.

Yeah it was not a simple solution because the entire season (from episode 1 to the end) involved finding said solution. As for the time spent showing the actual jewel crafting, they spent like 10 times longer on it than they spent on the forging of the One Ring in the Peter Jackson prologue. Crafting porn is certainly not necessary to convey the point.

On top of that, there wasn’t anything in the lore that indicated the crafting itself was some epic, momentous event. Celebrimbor crafted the Three on his own after spending 10 years making dozens of magic rings with his crafting buddies and Annatar. The importance wasn’t in the creation of the rings themselves, but rather all that came after.

[Shadowferal]

Yea...called "Rings of Power," and the rings aren't important.../s

[Flurryfang]

Sorry, but this is just a crock of nitpicky bullshit.

Yeah it was not a simple solution because the entire season (from episode 1 to the end) involved finding said solution.

What are you talking about? The entire season was about galadrial trying to find sauron, and about harfoots finding a meteor man, and about people in the south fighting orcs, and about Elrond rekindling his connection to the dwarves and Durin..... ohh and a little bit about Celebrimbor wanting to make some smithing with a big forge. So no, the making of the rings has not been focus of this season, so they do NOT earn the right to just swoop over the entire ring making process.

As for the time spent showing the actual jewel crafting, they spent like 10 times longer on it than they spent on the forging of the One Ring in the Peter Jackson prologue. Crafting porn is certainly not necessary to convey the point.

And there is reason for why they did not spent time on creating the one ring in lord of the rings, because the creation was not the focus, not even the one ring is that much in focus. The focus is on Frodo and Sams journey to morder, and the humans fighting to survive and beat Sauron. If you follow the story, it becomes quite clear, that the ring is not in focus very often.

On top of that, there wasn’t anything in the lore that indicated the crafting itself was some epic, momentous event. Celebrimbor crafted the Three on his own after spending 10 years making dozens of magic rings with his crafting buddies and Annatar. The importance wasn’t in the creation of the rings themselves, but rather all that came after. .

There is nothing in the lore?? It says, that it took many YEARS to make the rings and that it was a huge endeavor for both Celebrimbor and Sauron to make. Skipping those years, of the making of the lesser rings, removes the grandour of what the 3 elven rings are. They are the climax of the making of the rings, perfected to a point by Celebrimbor. Again, just ignoring that it took so long to get the rings right, makes it seem like such a small thing to make these rings and its does nothing to make them appear important or powerful.

The show is called "The Rings of Power" and the rings are in focus until they are made. The entire creation of them sets up EVERYTHING for the rest of the show and is supposed to be one of the primary climaxes of the story. Instead, it is done over in a matter of a few minutes and a few montages..... It feels hollow and the rings lose all sense of power from that. If it really was that easy, and the only thing holding them back is valinor steel and mithrel, they have to make up some horrible reason to why they don't make more O.o

[Triceron]

Sorry, but this is just a crock of nitpicky bullshit.

Yeah it was not a simple solution because the entire season (from episode 1 to the end) involved finding said solution. As for the time spent showing the actual jewel crafting, they spent like 10 times longer on it than they spent on the forging of the One Ring in the Peter Jackson prologue. Crafting porn is certainly not necessary to convey the point.

It doesn't matter how much time Rings of Power spent on showing the rings being crafted if the sequencing and materials are completely wrong, lol.

The show just doesn't take the care and pride in making itself believable when they show one Dagger being completely melted down somehow bearing separate ingots of gold and silver, then the ingots themselves are wrong since they don't match up to the rings (one gold ingot two silver, but two gold rings one silver ring).

The show banks on being created for audience that is unattentive to the details of how things are presented in the show. A general lack of care in the details is quite common throughout this series.

[rhorle]

Yea...called "Rings of Power," and the rings aren't important.../s

Lord of the Rings doesn't feature Sauron that much. He is only referenced and never present I believe.

[Adamas102]

What are you talking about? The entire season was about galadrial trying to find sauron, and about harfoots finding a meteor man, and about people in the south fighting orcs, and about Elrond rekindling his connection to the dwarves and Durin..... ohh and a little bit about Celebrimbor wanting to make some smithing with a big forge. So no, the making of the rings has not been focus of this season, so they do NOT earn the right to just swoop over the entire ring making process.

Elrond’s story with the dwarves kicked off BECAUSE of this crafting project. It didn’t start as rings, but the underlying need was there from the start.

What the also fleshed out was giving an explanation for why rings (something that the legendarium didn’t do) and that’s all tied together between Elerond’s, Durin’s, and Celebrimbor’s story lines.

This was the first of several seasons, the creation of the elven rings being only one piece of the overall story of the Rings of Power. If it feels hollow to you then so be it, but it definitely wasn’t something that was just glossed over.

[rhorle]

The show just doesn't take the care and pride in making itself believable when they show one Dagger being completely melted down somehow bearing separate ingots of gold and silver, then the ingots themselves are wrong since they don't match up to the rings (one gold ingot two silver, but two gold rings one silver ring).

Again. It is plausible that the molten pool has a different composition if things are not evenly distributed. Not to mention how mithril behaves in an alloy is an unknown factor. It could simply be that it takes hues of what it is mixed with. You know like copper mixed with gold makes it pinkish. It is silly to keep including that part in the criticism when the only attention to detail they missed was the color of the ingots being mismatched to the rings.

The show doesn't bank on people not paying attention. Mistakes happen hence why Game of Thrones had a starbucks cup and House of the Dragons forgot to digitally remove fingers and left the green tape around the fingers.

[Adamas102]

Yea...called "Rings of Power," and the rings aren't important.../s

Who said the rings weren’t important? Or are you just looking for a straw man to jerk off?

[Orby]

Lord of the Rings doesn't feature Sauron that much. He is only referenced and never present I believe.

To be fair though Sauron was ever present throughout the movie even when you didn't see him, his influence is there. whether it's in the one ring, or influence over people or his armies

[rhorle]

This was the first of several seasons, the creation of the elven rings being only one piece of the overall story of the Rings of Power. If it feels hollow to you then so be it, but it definitely wasn’t something that was just glossed over.

An interesting tidbit is they cut some stuff from the end of Season 1 because they felt it was to big to do. So they will cover that stuff in Season 2. The curse of having few episodes.


"Producer Lindsey Weber says, “Season 2 is fundamentally different in that our main villain is out and about and doing his thing. I think in some ways, it’s going to grittier, more intense, maybe a little scarier. There are things that we saved that were going to be in the final bit of [S1] that we thought, oh, just it’s too big right now to do, to fit that in with everything else and let’s save it, and we’re actually doing some of those things now in Season 2”"

The full article has some pictures of early set construction for season 2 as well. https://www.theonering.net/torwp/202...ings-of-power/

[Adamas102]

The show doesn't bank on people not paying attention. Mistakes happen hence why Game of Thrones had a starbucks cup and House of the Dragons forgot to digitally remove fingers and left the green tape around the fingers.

I wouldn’t even call it a mistake at all. The point of melting down the dagger is more thematic anyway. Getting so drawn up in such a minor detail as the color of the metals during the smelting scene while touting the source material as some magnificent work of art that shouldn’t be tampered with despite it being devoid of SO MUCH detail is just more nitpicking from the usual suspects. Taking extra time to go into detail on the crafting process wasn’t going to make them happy anyway.

[rhorle]

I wouldn’t call it a mistake at all. The point of melting down the dagger is more thematic anyway. Getting so drawn up in such a minor detail as the color of the metal while touting the source material as some magnificent work of art that shouldn’t be tampered with despite it being devoid of SO MUCH detail is just more nitpicking from the usual suspects.

If each ingot was turned into a ring then it does indicate a mistake unless one is just gold-plated. There isn't much silver-colored metal on Vilya. It is possible they just had a extra ingot or left over material I guess. It could be something Sauron steals in Season 2 or used to create the other rings. It isn't a big deal that a mistake like that exists but it is still a continuity goof for the show as far as we know. It being a mistake has nothing to do with Tolkien's work.

[Adamas102]

If each ingot was turned into a ring then it does indicate a mistake unless one is just gold-plated. There isn't much silver-colored metal on Vilya. It is possible they just had a extra ingot or left over material I guess. It could be something Sauron steals in Season 2 or used to create the other rings. It isn't a big deal that a mistake like that exists but it is still a continuity goof for the show as far as we know. It being a mistake has nothing to do with Tolkien's work.

Rewatching the two second scene where you see the three ingots, the one in the background, though slightly out of focus, doesn’t look quite silver like the one closer to the foreground (not quite gold either, though). Looks almost more brass colored. Maybe just the lighting. Is there somewhere else the three ingots were seen more clearly?

[Fortress of Arrogance]

Who said the rings weren’t important? Or are you just looking for a straw man to jerk off?

Are they, though?
How is it spelled story-wise?

[Triceron]

Again. It is plausible that the molten pool has a different composition if things are not evenly distributed. Not to mention how mithril behaves in an alloy is an unknown factor. It could simply be that it takes hues of what it is mixed with. You know like copper mixed with gold makes it pinkish. It is silly to keep including that part in the criticism when the only attention to detail they missed was the color of the ingots being mismatched to the rings.

Yes but it's the same pool of metal used for all 3 rings. They didn't split the mithril into multiple parts to use for 3 different rings, they literally tossed what they had into the same pool of metal, and there's no reason why a 'copper mixed with gold' alloy would yield three different colored results. If it's pinkish, then it's pinkish when split three ways, not one being pink another being copper colored and another being gold. What you're trying to explain doesn't make sense in how one pool of molten metal yields three different results, because we literally see them creating a single alloy out of the mithril, not three separate alloys.

The show doesn't bank on people not paying attention. Mistakes happen hence why Game of Thrones had a starbucks cup and House of the Dragons forgot to digitally remove fingers and left the green tape around the fingers.

Well it's not a mistake that they showed one pool of metal with the mithril dropped in right? Not a mistake that they melted the dagger as a whole as one piece instead of separating the gold and silver parts right? If this whole sequence is a mistake then sure, I can agree with you, but it's clear that they don't care enough about the entire sequence to really show how the ingots were differentiated. It's as magical as Arondir's buzzcut.

Like, people can call this shit out as nitpicks, and sure, that's what these are. But it's details that have been clear they haven't been putting effort in making sense in their own world, and it's a criticism that still holds true to the final episode for the most important part of the show - the creation of the rings. Even if these are nitpicks, even if it's movie magic, it's not excusable by merely saying 'it was a mistake like the Starbucks cup in GoT'. No, it's not comparable to the Starbucks cup at all here. These are deliberate sequences presenting something that simply isn't realistic or sensible. These are scenes that were watched over many times by many people who work on the show, going through multiple iterations of approval. And this final result is what was approved. It's not a random exposition scene we're talking about here, it's quite a pivotal moment.

As someone who works in film and vfx, it really boggles the mind how this got passed into the final cut. It comes down to two explanations - either hundreds of people fell asleep at the job and missed it, or the more sensible reason that who ever approved the sequencing ultimately didn't care about the realism to have it fixed, be it pushing mistakes through because they had no time for reshoots or meeting a deadline or whatever it may be.

[Adamas102]

Are they, though?
How is it spelled story-wise?

Is that a real question? I already explained above to someone that needed it spelled out that the crafting of the rings is connected all through the Elrond/Celebrimbor/Durin story that kicks off in the first episode. The rings are the culmination of a major project. It also draws in part of Galadriel’s arc with her giving up the dagger (symbolic of her revenge quest) as well as linking them to Sauron’s plans. If you weren’t paying attention then that’s on you.

[Shadowferal]

Who said the rings weren’t important? Or are you just looking for a straw man to jerk off?

You did.
But I'm sure you'll try to clean yourself up.

[rhorle]

Yes but it's the same pool of metal used for all 3 rings. They didn't split the mithril into multiple parts to use for 3 different rings, they literally tossed what they had into the same pool of metal, and there's no reason why a 'copper mixed with gold' alloy would yield three different colored results.

We already had this conversation. It would if the composition of the individual metals is different. Just like you can make different tints of Gold with what metal is mixed in. If some ingots had a higher ration of Gold, Silver, or Mithril it could impact the final color. It also isn't 3 different colors which we already covered in a past conversation.

The steel could have been important to the final product just as much as the purity of the gold and silver. We also don't know if the blade was 100% steel, right? One pool of metal could have a different ratio if not mixed fully. We also don't know what impact a magical metal will have. So you can't call it a mistake. Arondir's buzzcut isn't magical either. You really do have a grudge against the character huh? Manually clippers exist.

2 silver ingots and 1 gold ingot can be called the same as a starbucks cup or fingers still existing on a hand after being cut off. Because it is a simple error of color. If the ingots were clearly 2 gold and 1 silver then it wouldn't be an issue.

[Shadowferal]

Is that a real question? I already explained above to someone that needed it spelled out that the crafting of the rings is connected all through the Elrond/Celebrimbor/Durin story that kicks off in the first episode. The rings are the culmination of a major project. It also draws in part of Galadriel’s arc with her giving up the dagger (symbolic of her revenge quest) as well as linking them to Sauron’s plans. If you weren’t paying attention then that’s on you.

And the creation of the Rings "isn't important" as you stated earlier.

The importance wasn’t in the creation of the rings themselves, .