But there’s nothing being removed from dwarves. There is only something being added (to preconceived notions, mind you, and not original source material). Do you think adding POC dwarves suddenly makes them unidentifiable as dwarves? Is that the argument you’re going for? Dwarves aren’t known for skin color, are they? At least not in Tolkien’s work.
You ARE the one bringing attention and controversy. That’s the hilarious part. Show creator adds POC for nothing more than being there, and people on forums, YT channels, and articles take to their platforms to scream controversy, pandering, and ‘the message.’ It would be controversial if Tolkien created a world where that race never existed, or had something in stark contrast, such as breathed fire and farted rainbow sprinkles. Putting in POC characters is not controversial, especially when the source material never had anything about it.
So, you don’t fault the series for, as you put it, being hit or miss with the depiction of elves that don’t specifically match the description in the books; but, you do have issue with dwarves having a skin color other than white when that was never stated anywhere.
I also included taller than men, a description of Tolkien’s elves, which is not subjective.