I know various characters have been talked about over the past few months but I just wanted to put this out there to try and consolidate things in one place.
The more I play BFA the more I realize that the writing is what saddens me the most about the expansion. I really never thought Blizzard to be great at writing but as time has gone by it's gotten clear they're running thin on ideas. I'm sure after 14 years it can be difficult to think of new and fresh ideas but Light above this is getting to the point where I don't even want to pay attention to the story. A lot of my issues thus far are with Horde characters because that's where I spend most of my time.
1) First up is Saurfang. I get why he's done with the Horde (for the time being anyway). He watch Garrosh nearly destroy it after kicking out all the other races and now it's being led by another awful leader. A blood thirsty monster who murders her own soldiers AND civilians. That's some pretty messed up shit. With that being said, I'd rather have him do something like challenge Sylvanas to Mok'gora even if that means his death (because lets be honest, they're not going to hurt Sylvanas) instead of lamenting in an Alliance cell.
2) Etrigg. Etrigg is a veteran of the First and Second wars along with many other battles and has served as adviser to several Warchiefs. So in short he's a tough, wise old warrior who has seen a lot of shit in his day. Then comes the quest to establishing your outpost in Drustvar where he's literally stuttering about how spooky witches are. Now I understand that not everyone has to be a big tough badass with no fears, there are tons of personalities out there but an old war vet stuttering over witches? Really? I also understand the importance of comic relief but I personally think Gallywix is more than enough comic relief without turning this old ass orc into a whimpering pup.
3) Rexxar, Garona and the rest of the Horde leadership. A wide topic including many characters I know, but aside from Gallywix (who's not exactly the most ethical person in the world especially when money is involved) I do not understand why the other leaders are following Sylvanas after she murdered an entire field of her own civilians PLUS the whole part where she plague bombs her own soldiers only to force rez them to fight for her. Force rez? Yes. Force rez. I find it hard to believe that the Alliance soldiers plus all the previously loyal soldiers of the Horde who she just murdered would just stand up and begin fighting for her had they any free will. That's some Arthas level shit right there. You're telling me that after both these events Lor'themar, Baine, Thalyssra, Ji, Mayla, and Rokhan (assuming he's the leader of the Darkspear) are totally okay with seeing their soldiers murdered then raised into mindless scourge-esq minions? I can't swallow that.
4) Sylvanas. I've never really liked her or the Forsaken and I've never pretended otherwise. I think she's a 'meh' character at best who has a sob story for a background that many people like to use as an excuse for her actions. I honestly don't mind making the Horde the aggressors in the war, I really don't. I enjoy the whole 'conquest' arc and the idea of taking Kalimdor for the Horde. My issue isn't with that aspect of Sylvanas. My issue is that she's gone from this broody, shadowy character to this forefront monster. There is nothing 'grey' about murdering your own civilians. There is nothing 'grey' about murdering your own soldiers and raising them as mindless zombies. Who in their right mind would see those qualities in a leader and continue to follow them!? It's just insane that she's this clearly evil villain and yet everyone seems to not notice?
5) Yrel. The Holy Pope of the Space Nazi's herself. I get that a lot of her character arc was cut from WoD because that entire expansion was botched but to see her transform into this genocidal zealot is insane. They clearly want to push the idea that the Light can be just as evil as the void and it really saddens me. I get most people don't like 'black and white' but I enjoyed the idea of Light = Holy and Good, Shadow = Corrupt and Bad. (Outside instances like the Scarlet Crusade) Sure it wasn't the most original idea but I personally liked it. I feel like they went for the easiest thing to do which was make both forces in the middle so that they could make potential enemies out of both for us to fight.
There are other things here and there that I take issue with but these are some of my bigger ones. I know I'm going to be told "The cutscenes aren't in, we don't have the whole story" but I don't believe the cutscenes will make sense of any of these things. I've been playing the Beta for over a month, I've played both sides a few times and the story just saddens me. I love WoW and I love the majority of the lore, especially the various races and their cultures and I hope I'm wrong. I'm hope there are reasons for everything I've seen and read thus far but as we get closer and closer that Hope is fading.
Feel free to discuss your own thoughts on the topic. Do you like everything they've done? Do you have characters you wish were given better treatment?