Originally Posted by
Shiza-Chan
Am I the only one who thinks that Blizzard painting the Horde commiting genocide by burning them alive on the Night elves and painting it as grey comes off as sociopathic at best and as if the writers have some fascist tendencies at worst? Especially since we know that the Horde will be perfectly forgiven without any consequences. And I don't even talk about Horde Genocide, I talk about really the basic stuff like starting a process where leading members of the Horde who are responsible for the invasion and involved in the Genocide get executed and the Horde tries to atone for what they did to the Night Elves and honor the memories of the innocents they killed and simply accept that they put some immense guilt on themselves and have to act better in the future to atone. There will be nothing and the Horde will treated like some innocent little snowflakes, which paints an inhumane and again, either sociopathic or in the worst case fascist picture of the writers, who somehow think that Genocide is morally defendable and that they can portray the Horde as not evil after they commited multiple genocides without the slightest remorse. And it isn't even as if the Horde had to be portrayed as evil or cucked anything like this if they acknowledged their guilt, quite the opposite. Saurfang in Wotlk was endearing because he was portrayed as a regretful war criminal who doesn't hide the crimes he commited and wants to make up for it and who himself seems to suffer under PTSD because of his warcrimes, which made him more human (in the sense of a character we emotionally can relate to).
There is already the problem that the writers have this tendency of preaching a peace message through the protagonists while at the same time portraying war as something honorable and glorious where bad things only can happen because one side doesn't stick to the code of honor, where in real life even the western allies in WWII, probably the most "good guys" we ever had in any historical conflict, still raped and commited war crimes. You can't write an anti-war narrative and then paint a picture of war that borders on Propaganda in its glorification. Even fucking Warhammer gets war better because the setting acknowledges what a brutal business war is and builds on it. Everyone is kinda evil and this makes everyone kinda grey.
- - - Updated - - -
They have not. Count me one time when a main storyline, not some obscure little leveling questline, had a satisfying conclusion.