Wanted to vote pandaren to meme, but the option isn't there
OP .... It'd be Humans but understand that the Human Kingdoms have probably suffered from their own race by about as much as the Horde races.
Also .... Forsaken =/= Scourge
- Silvermoon was devastated by Arthas (a human) & the Scourge (non-sentient, not the Forsaken).
- For Lordaeron, see above. Destroyed by one of their own & non-Forsaken undead.
Last edited by J012D4N; 2019-04-26 at 03:30 PM.
If you want to go that road by blaming the Alliance on everything Arthas did, then nearly each atrocity in WoW is connected to either Horde or Alliance. You can hardly call Arthas part of the Alliance at that point, since he and the Scourge devastated Lordaeron as well.
As far as I understand OP, it's more about the collective of a race attacking another race, such as the invasions and so on. If the Humans were on the side of Arthas while he wrecked everything, then yes you could blame it on the Humans, but this wasn't the case. Same thing you can't blame Gul'dan on the current Horde, only because he is an Orc.
I agree with you. My pick would be Draenei, and thehorde doesnt lose stuff to the alliance, largely only the stuff that was taken from them.
The Alliamce has failed to take or destroy any horde city, meanwhile the horde took/destroyed Stormwind, Lordaerom, SilvermoonTheramaore, Darnassus.
But we still love the horde , right ?
- - - Updated - - -
But people keep ignoring the fact that Arthas was commanded by Ner'zhul, an orc in a continuation of the original Orc mission to conquer Azeroth, this is why I included it, vut bear in mind I did point out the mitigating circumstances.
Is it really the horde if they're been manipulated?
Well, in the end, Lordaeron was also lost by the Horde and Silvermoon was not taken from the Alliance (like invasion or by force, they just joined the Horde), Lordaeron was not taken from the Alliance by the Horde not destroyed by them, it was third party, and when it became an independant nation, it joined the Horde.
Everything else is on point (though the Stormwind thing could be debated, as it was not the same horde, but whatever)
The Alliance have taken down a lot of Horde stuff but mostly Old Horde stuff (Like Zulaman), so in general, is hard to make this comparison.
Note: Also you missed Gilneas
Last edited by Maxilian; 2019-04-26 at 03:53 PM.
Taran Tzu: MY PEOPLE MORE THAN ANY OTHER.
Night elves: You sure about that?
Taran Tzu: You know what, maybe we can call it a tie.
Does this guy look like an Orc to you? https://66.media.tumblr.com/60d41837...wb5do1_400.jpg
or this one?
https://2static1.fjcdn.com/comments/...2bd6cd2baf.jpg
The Void. A force of infinite hunger. Its whispers have broken the will of dragons... and lured even the titans' own children into madness. Sages and scholars fear the Void. But we understand a truth they do not. That the Void is a power to be harnessed... to be bent by a will strong enough to command it. The Void has shaped us... changed us. But you will become its master. Wield the shadows as a weapon to save our world... and defend the Alliance!
those guys who take a boat to travel to ironforge. oh yes, they suffered...
hit & run posting lol
The amount of victim blaming in this thread is hilarious
clearly the whole world.
if only zandalari and the other trolls could exterminate the night elves way back, they couldnt summon the BL in first instance...
The Alliance at large did not aim to destroy the Orcs (they were in fact almost unreasonably lenient in allowing the infighting about the internment camps to make the Alliance collapse in turn instead of getting rid of what they could only see as genocidal monsters), Daelin was, Blood Elves was literally just Garithos and his forces, and Trolls was some rando Kul Tirans we've never heard about since. As a body the humans can only be maybe held responsible for trying to kill the (playable) Goblins, and even then I doubt they knew the entire Bilgewater Cartel was on that one ship and it's not like mankind ever pursued war on the goblins as any kind of objective considering most of them are neutral and one is an SI:7 spy.
As for the Wrathgate, ask Afriasabi.
They weren't just keeping them in camps..
a grand admiral of the alliance's navy acting in official capacity as such.
yes, just the Grand Marshall of the Alliance of Lordaeron and his forces and their allies (aka the alliance of lordaeron)... do remember Dalaran was party to these actions as well.
some rando Kul Tirans? It was Grand Admiral Daelin Proudmoore and the troops he had under his call when he took it upon himself to go purge the orcish threat for the sake of the Alliance.
You seem to argue that entities allied with or embodying the Alliance and what it stands for or fighting for the alliance are not the alliance at all. The Kul tirans you argue were random were still a main part of the Alliance until after the events concerning Daelin's death at the hands of Rexxar and Vol'jin. Garithos was still the leader of what was left of the Lordaeron forces at the close of the period where the Alliance was still the "Alliance of Lordaeron" (aka Alliance of Seven Kingdoms).
I'd still like a canon source over a writers thoughts that were never put into a written lore.
Erm, Kul Tiras left the Alliance after Dealin's campaigns precisely because the rest of the members did not endorse his actions, while Gilneas left because they didn't want to fund the camps. What Kul Tiras did was on their own ass (and I'd agree that the Horde has more reasons to hate the Kul Tirans than any other group in the Alliance). The entire point of the Alliance story in BFA is getting KT back in.
With that out of the way, Garithos was isolated, the exact level of support and political recognition he received is unknown apart from a Dwarven brigade who thought he was a racist douchenozzle as well. At that point the Alliance of Lordaeron had all but disintegrated with all its constituent kingdoms isolated or crumbled; that said, the BEs are right to carry a grudge regardless, but it remains the actions of a particular group, while many of the Horde's atrocities were carried out by the big boss themselves.
they left cause of how little the alliance seemed to care about his death. Note that the alliance actually would have agreed with his actions, but the timing was terrible as other issues ranked more important than a few ships slipping off into the unknown. Fact remains that he was still Alliance when performing his deeds.
He only had the ruler of an allied nation locked up in another nation's jail and not even secretly at that. So he HAD some support and recognition outside his immediate forces and a dwarven brigade.
Overall the Draenei, but second I'd say the Night Elves.
But if we're going to be brutally honest, Orcs have never hurt anyone as much as orcs. Blew up their own planet and ruined their own race. Yikes. They have a destructive record worse than the Forsaken.
Moderator of the General Off-Topic, Politics, Lore, and RP Forums
"If you have any concerns, let me know via PM. I'll do my best to assist you."