Originally Posted by
Niwes
seriously, thats the reason why i stopped playing core dps classes as main in an expansion.
first:
i only like 2 of 3 specs for all of the core dps classes. i LOVE my mage. i LOVE frost and arcane. but i hate fire. same with sub and outlaw for rogue. they play fast, while assa feels slow as chewing gum. i do not like surv of hunter but the other 2 specs. and i hate demo of lock, since they changed it a few years ago.
so, all in all, this means, if i play a core dps, at some point mid of the xpac, blizz will force me to be utterly bullshit or play a spec i hate (which happens with mage frost and fire in 8.2 as example). this means all my investment until then is lost and/or i have to play a spec i hate and end my fun of playing my class. this sucks.
on the other hand, the one and only dps spec some classes have, will always perform well. never as good as the one best spec of core classes, but not far away. and blizz has to keep it up, because every ret or shadow on this planet will shitstorm when they are longer than 4 weeks at a position like i.e. arcane mage, because its their ONLY dps spec.
this will be always the case. it happens since warcraftlogs exists and you can clearly watch it there from year to year to year. and its logical, when you say that core dps have to be a few percent better in average than hybrids and when you also say that hybrids only dps spec should be not garbage. with that mindset you MUST have the other core dps specs and the second hybrid specs like i.e. feral, enhancement, etc. at the bottom. because there have to be someone at the bottom. and this is the obvious choice when you think about it.
so, blizz is doing it absolutelly right here. and this lefts us with a rule of thumb: when you do not like playing really ALL of the 3 specs of a core dps class and you wanna be competitive and having fun, do not play a core dps class. play a hybrid class with only one dps spec instead, and you are safe.
second:
the investment (the problem you offered).
when playing a hybrid spec with 1 dps spec you will (as damage dealer) invest all of your time, currencies (manapearls, valor points or whatever), gearing (stats, essences, trinkets, gems, enchants, whatever) in that one and only spec. blizz rarely change stat priority for one spec. and if they do the difference will not be that huge. but when you have to switch core dps specs, it could happen something like this:
- spec 1 favors haste and crit over all. versatility is lower mid. mastery is COMPLETE garbage.
- spec 2 favors mastery completely over all. followed by crit and versatility mid way. and haste is COMPLETE garbage.
these relations exists at some core dps classes. if you played spec 1 and blizz decided to nerf it into the ground while overbuffing spec 2 like hell (as often happened mid xpac with core dps classes), you have to re-gear yourself heavily.
also all the other investment, like you said, essences, specific trinkets, etc. are now worthless (in some cases).
this will never happen with the one dps spec of some hybrid classes. it will ofc also change a bit here and there. but this is a whole another story. way less tremendous.
third:
this is foremost the case when you look at Legion and BfA (and their game concepts seem here to stay):
- hybrid dps perform super good, when you look at boomies or shadows in both xpacs.
- some core dps have lost their „a few percents ahaed“ throne, when you look at mages and hunters i.e. until 8.2
- both xpacs heavily focused on detailed spec specific investment. In Legion it was Legendaries, per spec AP and essences. in BfA it is better, but still Azerite Traits, Essences, Trinkets (and maybe stuff like benthic gear).
last words:
blizz WILL ALWAYS heavily buff and nerf core dps specs while an xpac is running. they HAVE to do that, just because otherwise all the players that decided to play the non-performing specs will never perform well the whole xpac and get angry. so, with core dps classes they HAVE to rotate the specs, performance wise, in one xpac lifetime. the ups and down with one-dps-only hybrid specs are way less dramatic.
so, if you have a lot of free time and like/accept re-gearing and really like all 3 specs, a core dps is the right choice and will put you always on top of the meters. but if you ok to accept to be second-fourth on the meters and do not wanna be forced into a spec you do not like, you better play a hybrid with 1 dps spec.
at least, these are my 2 cents after 14 years of wow gaming.