Hungering Darkness Sylvanas vs Night Warrior Tyrande?

[chrisisvacant]

Tyrande does not trust nathrezims... and does not resurrect those who can, you know, shoot her head

Tyrande trusted Fandral Staghelm who grew a corrupted tree for Nzoth that Tyrande happily lived in and then whinged about when Godvanas burned it down for the sake of Azerothian prosperity.

[Powerogue]

Hard to say since we don't know "Who is this 'Darkness' anyway'?"



I'm going to say if they both have their cutscene powers off cooldown they'd kill each other in an explosion that manages to level all of Ashenvale, ruining the last bit of nelf land left, to really rub it in.

[Mehrunes]

sylvanas plot armor is thicker

Sylvanas, the character that is repeatedly forced by the plot not to use even a sliver of her whole power set whenever the writers want her opponent to survive. Plot armor. Pick one.

she will ascend to godhood or some shit like kerrigan

At lest thrall got crippling depression and its now a joke, and malfurion almost died, she always get away with barely scratch

Funny how Malfurion almost dying - let alone Thrall merely getting depressed (after he won the relevant fight no less) - counts for you but Sylvanas literally dying in Gilneas doesn't. But hey, as long as it allows you to complain about the character in increasingly nonsensical manner some more.

[Syegfryed]

Sylvanas, the character that is repeatedly forced by the plot not to use even a sliver of her whole power set whenever the writers want her opponent to survive. Plot armor. Pick one.

cause she is thanos lv of power amright

Funny how Malfurion almost dying - let alone Thrall merely getting depressed (after he won the relevant fight no less) - counts for you but Sylvanas literally dying in Gilneas doesn't.

i mean she backs, 2 times, if its not plot armor someone that can back even from the death then nothing is.

[Daevelian]

I'd probably go with Tyrande solely based off "failure" being a character trait of Sylvanas now.

One is doomed to stupidity, the other is doomed to failure. Stupidity can still bumble it's way to a win, failure can not.

[LarryWithTheWeatherReport]

Sylvanas easily at the moment but Night Warrior Mode Tyrande should be up there in the power chart just not on Sylvanas's level.

[TheRevenantHero]

cause she is thanos lv of power amright





i mean she backs, 2 times, if its not plot armor someone that can back even from the death then nothing is.

Just because she is revived, doesn't mean she has plot armor. The complete opposite actually. She has been shown as being killable. Whereas with pretty much EVERY FUCKING ALLIANCE PLOT CHARACTER, they are immune to death. Varian was killed for shock value. That's it. Malfurion should be dead. He got an axe buried in his body and just seemed slightly inconvenienced. Vol'jin got stabbed the same way and fucking DIED. So...yeah. Alliance plot NPCs have invincible plot armor. Sylvanas easily could have killed everyone in that Undercity cut scene but somehow they all escaped completely unscathed.

[Kyphael]

Where's the "they kill each other" option?

[Syegfryed]

Just because she is revived, doesn't mean she has plot armor. The complete opposite actually. She has been shown as being killable. Whereas with pretty much EVERY FUCKING ALLIANCE PLOT CHARACTER, they are immune to death. Varian was killed for shock value. That's it. Malfurion should be dead. He got an axe buried in his body and just seemed slightly inconvenienced. Vol'jin got stabbed the same way and fucking DIED. So...yeah. Alliance plot NPCs have invincible plot armor. Sylvanas easily could have killed everyone in that Undercity cut scene but somehow they all escaped completely unscathed.

one may think she died just for some drama and shock value too

[Daevelian]

Wouldn't Sylv's plot armour be in the same vein as the dragon balls?

Sure she can die, but it has absolutely zero meaning if she can come back at any time. Hell, next Val'kyr raise she should be eligible for a free sunday.

[Cyram]

one may think she died just for some drama and shock value too

But it wasn't shocking, though. You could see it coming like 25 quests before it happened.
Sylvanas has died twice post Arthas - the worst that has happened to an Alliance character is getting a boo-boo from A FUCKING BELL FALLING ON THEM - and that bell gave him magical spidey-sense against lies or whatever.
People complain about plot armor for Sylvanas but can't see that it ain't worse than the least plot-armored character from the Alliance...

[Dead Moose Fandango]

Can't say till we find out who's backing Sylvanas and what level of power they've given her.

[wooootles]

Regardless of power levels, this is how it will play out:

-Tyrande will be aggressive
-Sylvanas will exploit her aggressiveness, find an opening and gain the upper hand
-Just as Tyrande is down, Sylvanas will twirl her evil mustache and say "something something death something"
-Tyrande will get help from Elune, strike and get back the winning position
-Sylvanas escapes, but that was her plan all along! *twirls mustache some more*

Tyrande wins?

[darkoms]

Tyrande trusted Fandral Staghelm who grew a corrupted tree for Nzoth that Tyrande happily lived in and then whinged about when Godvanas burned it down for the sake of Azerothian prosperity.

Trusted him? Have you read Stormrage? Even before everyone knew about Fandral's betrayal, Tyrande did not trust him and entrusted Broll with a mission (I don’t remember exactly what, but this was supposed to help Malfurion) and asked not to tell Fandral
Burning tree damaged Azeroth

- - - Updated - - -

Just because she is revived, doesn't mean she has plot armor. The complete opposite actually. She has been shown as being killable. Whereas with pretty much EVERY FUCKING ALLIANCE PLOT CHARACTER, they are immune to death. Varian was killed for shock value. That's it. Malfurion should be dead. He got an axe buried in his body and just seemed slightly inconvenienced. Vol'jin got stabbed the same way and fucking DIED. So...yeah. Alliance plot NPCs have invincible plot armor. Sylvanas easily could have killed everyone in that Undercity cut scene but somehow they all escaped completely unscathed.

If Sylvanas could easily kill Genn (who had already given her a face in Stormheim), Anduin (a pretty strong priest, you know, those guys who own the Light and the Light is usually harmful to the undead), Alleria (who literally ate Naara and hearth of Void revenant ) and Jhaina (the strongest mortal mage in Azeroth), then she really is Mary Sue

[Neryaf]

Regardless of power levels, this is how it will play out:

-Tyrande will be aggressive
-Sylvanas will exploit her aggressiveness, find an opening and gain the upper hand
-Just as Tyrande is down, Sylvanas will twirl her evil mustache and say "something something death something"
-Tyrande will get help from Elune, strike and get back the winning position
-Sylvanas escapes, but that was her plan all along! *twirls mustache some more*

Tyrande wins?

This.

We are in cartoon villain territory now boyzzz

[valax]

In the end Elune is a bigger deus ex machina so I give it to Tyrande

that worked out well for Teldrassil

[chrisisvacant]

Trusted him? Have you read Stormrage? Even before everyone knew about Fandral's betrayal, Tyrande did not trust him and entrusted Broll with a mission (I don’t remember exactly what, but this was supposed to help Malfurion) and asked not to tell Fandral
Burning tree damaged Azeroth

That was somewhere in the realm of 5000 years or so after he grew the damn trees all over the world. It took her 5000 years to be mildly distrustful (and this is RIGHT before he flips).

[TheRevenantHero]

Trusted him? Have you read Stormrage? Even before everyone knew about Fandral's betrayal, Tyrande did not trust him and entrusted Broll with a mission (I don’t remember exactly what, but this was supposed to help Malfurion) and asked not to tell Fandral
Burning tree damaged Azeroth

- - - Updated - - -



If Sylvanas could easily kill Genn (who had already given her a face in Stormheim), Anduin (a pretty strong priest, you know, those guys who own the Light and the Light is usually harmful to the undead), Alleria (who literally ate Naara and hearth of Void revenant ) and Jhaina (the strongest mortal mage in Azeroth), then she really is Mary Sue

Alleria and Jaina would be the only ones there that would put up a fight against Sylvanas. Genn should have died in Stormheim but plot armor prevented it. Anduin is a pally/priest hybrid with little to no combat experience. Plus, Sylvanas would have simply wore them down a bit before retreating and blowing up the blight bombs. That cinematice should have ended with those four idiots dead.

[Pheraz]

Ofc sylvanas loses.
Silly poll

She (Tyrande) also looks better.

[darkoms]

Alleria and Jaina would be the only ones there that would put up a fight against Sylvanas. Genn should have died in Stormheim but plot armor prevented it. Anduin is a pally/priest hybrid with little to no combat experience. Plus, Sylvanas would have simply wore them down a bit before retreating and blowing up the blight bombs. That cinematice should have ended with those four idiots dead.

Realy? Plot armor? Sylvanas not die after meeting Alleria, Genn, Anduind and Jhaina and even stand against fucking Malfurion and was equal to him