Originally Posted by
Scrod
I'm joining this conversation late, but here's what I think. It's basically incontrovertible that wearing masks will save 200, 300, maybe 500 hundred thousand lives over the next three months versus not wearing them. If no one wears masks, the average infected person will infect 2-3 other people, and the virus will grow explosively. If everyone wears masks, it is possible that the average infected person infects less than 1 person, and the outbreak starts to subside (like it did in China).
I think what you are proposing is that people who are at risk should take protective measures but those who aren't don't need to. This is where the important point of mask wearing comes into play. Wearing a mask is not about protecting yourself, it's about protecting others from you. So if I'm at risk and a wear a mask, and no one else does and the virus continues to rage through the population, it's not safe for me to be in contact with anyone, ever. To go to the grocery store, to walk outside, anything. My mask doesn't protect me if others aren't wearing masks too.
So your idea, that only those who are at risk should take precautions, basically implies that those who are at risk, which is about half the population, should become hermits for the next few months until the vaccine can be given to them. Otherwise they are exposed to unacceptable risk any time they go in public and run into people not wearing masks.
The alternative idea that many people are proposing is that everyone wears masks, which is a minor inconvenience for everyone but massively reduces the risk for at risk people, so they can actually have some limited social contact over the next 3-4 months.
Yes, freedom is lovely, but the obvious point that the no maskers seem to miss is that freedom has always come with some rules that stop people from taking actions that hurt other people. That's why drugs are illegal. That's why you can't smoke in an elevator.
Our country's response to the pandemic is a national embarrassment. The fact that we have become so selfish that we can't accept simple things like wearing a mask (and also that we have way too many influential people who are just dumb and telling everyone that it's fine not to), while a country like China can actually do what it's supposed to do and protect everyone, is pathetic. We used to be a country that came together in times of crisis - look at rationing and all the sacrifices we made in world war 2. Look at the hundreds of thousands who fought for the North in the Civil War (when they really had no skin in the game).
The people who are arguing that we shouldn't need to make sacrifices are mostly the same people who say we need to "make America great again", ignoring that when America was "great", people made sacrifices, there a sense of social consciousness, of community, and a willingness to think about others.
TLDR: With coronavirus, the biological weapon is other people. We need to put protective coverings on these biological weapons to protect everyone. We live in a community, and being part of a community means recognizing that you should care about keeping other people safe. Arguing that you can walk around in public without a mask is like arguing that you can walk around with a fox that eats children without any leash on the fox because is harmless to you, and saying that if it's so bad for children they should just stay at home.
And yes, at some point there was an argument that we couldn't afford to do this. We didn't know the endgame. It could have been years.
But now we know. The vaccines work. The virus will start to decline in the spring, most likely be a memory by fall. So we are talking about wearing masks for 3-5 months. To save hundreds of thousands of lives. There's nothing to discuss anymore. We just do it, or we show that we are failing nation.