Genocide On The Border

[Doctor Amadeus]

Dude:

Like at least read when the person gives you a source.

You’re losing the plot it isn’t about his question it’s about hers. His answer doesn’t imply he did or didn’t read what she sourced.

We are talking about Genocide and she was asking if it is.

[Doctor Amadeus]

"By replying to me you're proving me right" is always where you end up when you're backed into a corner. Stop being a dickhead.

But she’s the one asking if it’s Genocide!

- - - Updated - - -

His country bombed mine to hell, one of the most bombed countries in the world and then try to pin the problems on communism. Not the fact they pretty much destroyed the country, no that surely isn't a huge part of the problems.

Which country are we talking about?

[Machismo]

"By replying to me you're proving me right" is always where you end up when you're backed into a corner. Stop being a dickhead.

What's next? I have to get the last word?

You bitched that I replied to something you deemed rhetorical, so I simply opted for that same line of rhetorical commentary.

As another poster once said about such things:

I get there are no such things are rhetorical questions on the internet, but they're not a reason for you to make an ass of yourself.

Well, this is awkward.

- - - Updated - - -

His country bombed mine to hell, one of the most bombed countries in the world and then try to pin the problems on communism. Not the fact they pretty much destroyed the country, no that surely isn't a huge part of the problems.

My country has bombed a lot of countries, could you narrow it down a bit?

[Machismo]

When your grandchildren ask where you were when the fascists came at least you can say you were whinging about communists on a gaming forum.

And you can say you supported fascist violence against non-violent people... on a gaming forum.

- - - Updated - - -

sdasdasdasd sdsdfsdfsdfsdf

You can say that again.

- - - Updated - - -

More baseless claims from a burner

Evidence, please.

[Vorkreist]

capitalist countries have caused more starvation than communist countries?.

From fanfiction alternative history did you get that one?

[Machismo]

You still don't understand what fascism is and you're living in a fascist state. Fuck me.

Oh, I'm well aware. It's a shame so many people support violence against non-violent people.

[Machismo]

Admitting he has no evidence.

Thanks for admitting you have no evidence.

[Machismo]

Of all people I didn't think it would have been you spilling shit into this thread. Can you stop now.

Once again, why do you feel the need to keep responding to me, and you replied to me first. You are under no obligation to reply, so don't.

Put me on ignore, for all I care.

I love that you are calling on me to do something you have shown you cannot do. Can you stop, now?

[Machismo]

Thanks for your confession.

Evidence, please.

[Mekh]

This thread about the US committing genocide in their concentration camps at the border derailed quickly.

[Thelxi]

This is literally the definition of genocide I do not care nor does anyone else care if you feel "it isn't genocide" it fucking is genocide.

I understand why you would be confused, but it is not. If common sense is not enough, going to Lemkin's own definition you will quickly find out that according to him, genocide:

"is intended rather to signify a coordinated plan of different actions aiming at the destruction of essential foundations of the life of national groups, with the aim of annihilating the groups themselves."

Unfortunately, I know that this is not enough to stir your common sense, so lets go a bit deeper to hopefully teach you and others the gravity and scale of the word.

Destexhe, Rwanda and Genocide in the 20th Century:
"Genocide is a crime on a different scale to all other crimes against humanity and implies an intention to completely exterminate the chosen group."
"Genocide is therefore both the gravest and greatest of the crimes against humanity"
He even warned that liberal use of the word makes it "dangerously commonplace".

Michael Ignatieff at one of his Harvard lectures elaborated:
"Those who should use the word genocide never let it slip their mouths. Those who unfortunately do use it, banalise it into a validation of every kind of victimhood"
He was talking about ignorant use of the word in regard to actual slavery btw, so imagine what he'd have to say to anyone pushing the word here.

Just in case the morbid nature of the word hasn't dawned on you yet, here is a list of genocides that wikipedia thinks fit the UN's 1948 CPPCG:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...tion_campaigns
Have a gander at the smallest-scale genocide on that list and look at the death toll. Ask yourself where this doctor's "genocide" would fit on that list.

Of course wikipedia is not a great academic source, so maybe the PITF will have a better chance at drilling in which events constitute genocide.

Now, if it turns out that this doctor was operating within a larger scheme, especially if government officials are implicated, then it might start looking like genocide, assuming his behavior stretches decades and thousands of victims. If it turns out that such an extremely unlikely scheme involved and occured at multiple facilities, then the word can start being used in an intelligent and more responsible manner to refer to this situation. Until then, saying this is genocide is nothing more than populist hyperbole, which of course we are all too familiar with these days.

[Machismo]

Just acknowledge the fact you basically shit yourself in this thread and go away rather than drag this on.

Dude, you are a Holocaust denier...

It's a shame your boy Trump and his administration keep trying to commit genocide.

[Machismo]

I was hoping for a slight bit of recognition that derailing this thread is really shitty. Instead you're doing you're usual routine trying to say im the one who fucked up for responding at all.

Your country is committing genocide and you're complaining about communism and slinging petty insults. You've made your priorities clear, congrats on becoming the thing that you're literally always complaining about.

Once again, put me on ignore. It's that easy. You chose to respond to me, and want to get pissed when I reply back.

My government is committing genocide, and I fucking condemned them for that. See, that's easy.

Now, let's see if you can summon even an ounce of restraint, and do what you are demanding I do. I fucking dare you.

[Doctor Amadeus]

This thread about the US committing genocide in their concentration camps at the border derailed quickly.

Where exactly was this thread expected to go?

[Doctor Amadeus]

Not at all clear what the point of the op is frankly. I couldn't work out whether there were major atrocities being carried out or just some thoughtless and unprofessional healthcare operatives underperforming.

This is the problem with literally every story in the us media being about how Trump is bad in some way.

You do realize the seriousness of this allegations correct and how that would directly impact Trump considering everything that has to do with the border ordinary falls on his shoulders even more so since he implemented the circumstance happening at the border.

[Machismo]

The fucking stupidity of pretending that a British socialist is somehow a Trump supporter. I was in a crowd literally throwing dogshit at him the last time he came here.

Did you just admit to holding dog shit for hours at a time? How long were you storing your dog's shit?

[Kotuthan]

Calling it now. Nothing will happen to those responsible outside of a slight slap on the wrist.

[Lorgar Aurelian]

Words.

Definition

Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide

Article II

In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

Killing members of the group;
Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.

https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/genocide.shtml

[Gelannerai]

Well they should have just not came here illegally and they would have avoided this.

Cite the law that outlines medical mutilation as a punishment for illegally entering the US, please.

[jonnysensible]

Well they should have just not came here illegally and they would have avoided this.

hope you find yourself against the wall trump builds.