Originally Posted by
XalAtoh
I know there are people that don't like Garrosh, because "he is a bully", oppressive, arrogant, he insults the player character, only cares about the Orcs (which is not fully true), violent, did some evil things in MoP...
But Garrosh started to really play a major role in WOTLK and that character was good for the game. Even without being Warchief... he correctly represent the more "violent" side of the Horde in a natural way.
Not only that, even as absolute political top dog as Warchief, he was very initiative, it's part of his character. To take action and walk into the danger and start wars. Give Alliance something to do.
Garrosh wanted to invade Northrend, before Scourge even could attack Orgrimmar, Garrosh always seeks for adventure and conquest. It's just who he is as a character. So because he was also a "major character" of the Warcraft story, the story is forced to continue in an interesting way, simply because of how his personality works.
Baine likes to sit in Thunderbluff and eat out of his nose with his "eat, sleep, talk" lifestyle, just like Vol'jin, Thrall, (pre-forced) Sylvanas, Cairne, Lor'themar, Varian always did.
After Garrosh died, it became quickly very quiet, you had some characters trying to fill his space Illidan (adventurous), (Nathanos (arrogance), Geya'rah (warmonger), Greymane (revenge), Sylvanas (suddenly out of nowhere a demi-god warmonger). But nobody of them could do it as well and all it once as Garrosh.
The only one who could replicate Garrosh character was the old school Warcraft 3 Grom Hellscream. The co-creator of Garrosh. Grom is an excellent character to have next to Thrall.
Blizzard tries to replicate Garrosh with Sylvanas "in her own ways"...
But Sylvanas .... she never had real personality, irrational forced mood swings, boring sociopathic, calm character. Took never initiative (outside of Arthas vengeance thing). She herself tried to kill herself after there was nothing left for her. Garrosh would never do that. Yet Sylvanas was forced back into the lore with a "fake mysterious cloud around her". Did basically pretty much nothing because the devs seriously didn't knew what to do with her.
Not surprising, because the character of Sylvanas has literally no goals in her life, nobody to fight for or life for. So not only visually a lifeless corpse, but also personality wise a lifeless corpse. So when she suddenly takes over the story, filling the space of Garrosh, it feels all so forced, people even calling her Garrosh 2.0. But unlike Garrosh... Sylvanas as character is nothing.. she is an empty shell, both story and personality wise. (I admit, shell looks visually nice, lots of people love her perfection in the visual department, but that's it).
But if you going to rely on someone's visual appearance for a story, that's not going to work out well, for people who like to dive deep into the story.
With Garrosh return, and if the character stays intact (he probably will, his iron will is pretty much unrivaled), I greatly cheer for the return of Son of Hellscream. There is a nearly infinite amount of GOOD possibilities they could do with the return of Garrosh Hellscream.