Originally Posted by
SirCowdog
I repeat: "Making a dynamic where every player of a raid has to repeat the attunement process every single time a member of their raid swaps out is bad design, and WORSE than having nothing to do after raid-logging."
Yes, the alt or new raid member is getting some gain. But at the expense of every other person in the raid getting nothing besides wasted time.
The cost of running through an attunement, when an attunement has already happened for that player, so far outpaces the gain for that individual character that it's pedantic to claim benefit. Badges don't equate a significant enough value to warrant repeating the attunement.
And yes, I'm speaking from the context of actual TBC experience, not some private server which is known to not use the same rules or settings as the original game, and often gets things VERY wrong.
Well, unpopular opinion really nails it. I'm done here. Believe what you want.