youre right
i forgot he didnt actually say it and all of his actions could have been interpreted as not that...you know the only way to get free will is to take it away and obviously the jailer who made Anduin Arthas 2.0 via Sylvanas was totally the good guy
also i will never watch a video from that soppy bollocks especially when all i need to do is look at the titles to know that its algorithm bait

Basically the only way you can interpret Sylvanas at this point is ridiculously incompetently stupid heroic, or over the top evil and just plain boring.
but dude
listen he told her he could help her not die right
and she just had to work with all the baddies that we have seen recently like helya who was totally a good guy in legion
we cant blame her for helping the jailer out because she was sad and people kept triggering her so she had to
start a war
free an old god
let thousands die
kill her own people
abandon her own people
enslave Anduin
because she truly believed that this dude who tortured souls for a living was just the most upstanding guy
"Whaaa???? The evil-looking bald dude with BDSM chains and an evil-sounding voice wants to dominate the Universe??? No way dude, how could I have known!"
- Sylvanas, probably
Though as the Horde goes, that's par for the course. The only thing the Horde can do is regularly get manipulated by an evil power because they're too dumb and stupid to realize that the evil power doesn't actually care about them. And as usual it falls to the Alliance to fix their mistakes (Anduin giving Sylvanas the therapy session she desperately needed, for example). I just described to you the lore of Warcraft since WC1![]()

Great way to start the morning! https://twitter.com/jeffahamilton/st...991875074?s=21
"There is a pervasive myth that making content hard will induce players to rise to the occasion. We find the opposite." -- Ghostcrawler
"The bit about hardcore players not always caring about the long term interests of the game is spot on." -- Ghostcrawler
"Do you want a game with no casuals so about 500 players?"
Why shouldn't Sylvanas have trusted the guy who (basically) made Frostmourne and the Helm of Domination... just looking at the Jailer you know he's a nice and dependable guy. Honestly I was shocked by the "serve" line in the cinematic, I really thought he was a good guy... then I was proven right in the end cinematic, he was really a good guy...
PS: just in case, I'm being sarcastic
Last edited by NikolaiShade; 2022-03-21 at 01:06 PM.
My question with the whole Sylvanas / Jailer meeting is how did he circumvent the Arbiter in the first place?
Or was it just an illusion because he had part of her soul?
Or was she really destined for the Maw because the Arbiter knew what she would do. In which case, why didn't the Arbiter try to warn anyone what Zovaal was doing?

What they should have done is made it so that everyone made undead by the jailor's power (ie, the scourge) instantly went to the Maw because they were considered a minion of zovaal and thus a threat to the Shadowlands (which is what the maw is supposed to contain).
This would explain why everyone whose seen the shadowlands before the expansion saw the maw pretty much. This would also give the Forsaken extra impotus to not want to just pass away now that they have their revenge.
The only problem is this robs us of the 'uther tossing arthas into the maw' storyline.
I don't think the Arbiter sees what souls will do in the future once they reach their destination. So it could be that she was destined for the Maw.
It also could be as you said that he could connect with part of her soul since he had it in a domination piece.
Tbh this isn't really a plot problem since there are many ways it could happen. And we also don't really know how talkative the Arbiter replacement was or did it just have the task to filter souls and sometimes say something prerecorded about the Purpose.
#1 Hype-Thread Shitposter - Overlord of the Hypethread

Sylvanas went to the Maw thanks to the Jailer having her Soulshard in his posession.
Her being "destined for the Maw" is laughable when Rev has souls in it that make Sylvanas look like a saint.
Last edited by Raetary; 2022-03-21 at 02:41 PM. Reason: typo

I'm actually quite excited for the Sylvanas novel. I'm not happy that her story is being told in a novel versus in-game. However, since we can't change that fact, I'm still interested to see what is said.
Thing is this isn't anything new in recent expansions. There was always plenty of stuff being told in books, and a lot of character development being done. It is an easier media for that goal than ingame, unless you want to bore the player base with short quests followed by long cutscenes.
But I do agree that they should with a book put in also some info about it ingame, not everything but the important.
But I think the worse for this was MoP (SoO) to WoD transition.
#1 Hype-Thread Shitposter - Overlord of the Hypethread

It's been very apparent the true goal their posting: baiting and derailing. And perhaps shitposting sprinkled on.
I fully expect them to eventually ditch that account altogether and create a brand new one, in order be more successful at what they are doing... or rebrand this current account to a different theme. Let's say... Yrel for instance.
- - - Updated - - -
I'm not. I think the novel getting pushed back as much as it did in order to either 1.) re-organize the story or 2.) scrap story elements altogether in fear of massive backlash (not confirmed, just speculation) makes me wonder if Blizzard anticipated a base amount of backlash regardless.
But I already got it pre-ordered so /meh
- - - Updated - - -
Still waiting for the "Garrosh was playing 6D chess the entire time..." twist.