You are welcome, Metzen. I hope you won't fuck up my underground expansion idea.
Yeah, a Necromancer would have been fantastic, as much as I personally dislike the concept in WoW (they're generally mooks that are superceded by Liches, Warlocks and Death Knights). It would have been something. For the past decade or so, I've been judging expansions not on the content they bring to their own lifespan, but by the content they introduce that will still be relevant when the next X.0 patch hits. I didn't see anything in Shadowlands that had potential to carry over when its time was over.
Given the prominence of Sylvanas throughout that expansion, Dark Ranger would have made the most sense. Them not bringing out DRs, and giving Sylvanas' bow and quiver exclusively to Hunters was very surprising, and perhaps an indication of their general view of the class.


Imagine if 10.0 is full of borrowed powers, hope players will strongly react this time
True, but even then... what did BfA add, going forward? Previous entries played with raiding difficulties, introduced systems like glyphs, revamped ongoing systems like talents, added classes, added professions, introduced new modes like Keystone dungeons - all very significant features that would continue on into the foreseeable future once introduced. BfA and SL had nothing comparable. More reputations, a couple glorified reputations, more mounts, more armour, more toys and so on... none of is "bad," but it's all entirely standard. Status quo. No novelty or ambition or staying power.
Yeah, I really don't mind Torghast and I think the basic idea of it is really good, it just sucks when it becomes a chore you have to do for player power rather than something you do for fun/cosmetics. Loved doing gauntlet when that came out, hated having to farm torghast for cinders so I could craft a legendary I wanted this week.
And even in a best case scenario where Torghast was widely beloved and universally praised... they'd still toss it out at the end of the expansion. Maybe they'd bring it back for Timewalking or whatever during a content lull, but it remains that their original intent is that it is a Shadowlands-specific feature with no bearing on future content. It isn't something that comes with us an evolves in the same way as classes or talents or professions or dungeon/raid modes.

400 more pages![]()
But that's also the case with Island Expeditions, Warfronts and Visions and even worse with MoP/WoD CM Dungeons and Legion Artifacts as that content literally is no longer available. Btw I agree that we need more evergreen content with some expansion exclusive content sprinkled on top. Player Housing f.e. would be perfect for 10.0.
