1. #67601
    Over 9000! Lahis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    9,607
    Quote Originally Posted by Makorus View Post
    The last two Season 1 Dungeons are Shadowmoon Burial Grounds and Halls of Valor.

    Happy about SBG, even if it has some tough sections, but Halls of Valor is such a snorefest.
    I just wish WoD dungeons had proper loot tables.

    I still don't know if ID or GRD have any good loot in them.

  2. #67602
    I am Murloc! Nymrohd's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2022
    Location
    Greece
    Posts
    5,017
    Quote Originally Posted by Lahis View Post
    I just wish WoD dungeons had proper loot tables.

    I still don't know if ID or GRD have any good loot in them.
    I think they absolutely will need to change the loot tables for the old dungeons. I get not doing it fully for the Fated season because it was entirely an experiment but it should be done for this.

  3. #67603
    Quote Originally Posted by Lahis View Post
    I just wish WoD dungeons had proper loot tables.

    I still don't know if ID or GRD have any good loot in them.
    I mean, honestly, it's only WoD that has fucked up loot tables, because of the way they did dungeon loot, where every dungeon essentially shared loot and trinkets were just stat sticks.

    The only dungeon from WoD that had somewhat interesting loot was UBRS.

    But yeah, modernizing loot would be great. Comparing trinkets and even gear with effects from Legion and BfA to stuff from WoD/MoP makes it really lop-sided and annoying.

    Same with necks and rings having main stat. It's stupid.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by Sondrelk View Post
    People were refusing to accept that there were actually 8 dungeons at launch, with half being used in M+ S1, even when you linked them directly to the interview were they stated it.
    I mean, I can see where people are coming from.

    After the first two weeks of the expansion, there are pretty much gonna be four new dungeons.

    No ones gonna run the other dungeons outside of leveling/quests that require them.

    Or how often did you run Theater of Pain in Season 4?

  4. #67604
    If we do indeed have halls of valor in season 1 I want blizzard to update Hyrja so it's not randomly killing dps in your group during tyrannical weeks.

  5. #67605
    Herald of the Titans Lady Atia's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2015
    Location
    The Rumour Tower
    Posts
    2,722
    Quote Originally Posted by Skildar View Post
    If we do indeed have halls of valor in season 1 I want blizzard to update Hyrja so it's not randomly killing dps in your group during tyrannical weeks.
    Well let's hope they learned with Karazhan so we won't get fucked up tuning during the first month of season 1.

  6. #67606
    Does anybody else feel like this new season design takes away even more from the world building aspect? We are on the Dragonflight isles and suddenly go back to Halls of Valor to retrieve the Aegis. Jade Serpent ... ?? Feels more and more like Diablo 3 Season 27. On top of that we only get 8 Dungeons AGAIN which, quite frankly, is just not enough. 10 is the minimum imo to get a good rotation going.

    If they repackaged old Dungeons through the Caverns of Time by making new Dungeons but with the old assets it would be fine by me. But this copy paste and changing numbers feels so lazy and immersion breaking. Cant really stand it even though I understand why they're doing it. They always come up with these ludicrous design decision why something can't work or is designed this way and explain it with their "lore" and "makes sense" reason. And then they do something like this with 0 reason, lore why we are going back there in the first place. More design for esports less for the MMORPG player. Terrible way of implementation.
    Last edited by Arai; 2022-09-14 at 11:23 AM.

  7. #67607
    Herald of the Titans Lady Atia's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2015
    Location
    The Rumour Tower
    Posts
    2,722
    Quote Originally Posted by Arai View Post
    Does anybody else feel like this new season design takes away even more from the world building aspect? We are on the Dragonflight isles and suddenly go back to Halls of Valor to retrieve the Aegis. Jade Serpent ... ?? Feels more and more like Diablo 3 Season 27. On top of that we only get 8 Dungeons AGAIN which, quite frankly, is just not enough. 10 is the minimum imo to get a good rotation going.
    My personal headcanon is that we have to timewalk back there because the infinite flight messed up the timeways and made it so that our original dungeon group didn't arrive. Basically Caverns of Time: TotJS/CoS/HoV/SMBG. Similiar to season 4 and the Dreadlords trying to manipulate stuff (although the WoD dungeons were kinda weird haha).

    The fated raid quests also imply that someone tries to mess with the timelines already, although it's weird with Shadowlands as time should work differently there anyways.

    Also imo 8 Dungeons is the golden number. Season 3 felt far too overwhelming for new players.
    Last edited by Lady Atia; 2022-09-14 at 11:30 AM.

  8. #67608
    Quote Originally Posted by Arai View Post
    Does anybody else feel like this new season design takes away even more from the world building aspect? We are on the Dragonflight isles and suddenly go back to Halls of Valor to retrieve the Aegis. Jade Serpent ... ?? Feels more and more like Diablo 3 Season 27. On top of that we only get 8 Dungeons AGAIN which, quite frankly, is just not enough. 10 is the minimum imo to get a good rotation going.

    If they repackaged old Dungeons through the Caverns of Time by making new Dungeons but with the old assets it would be fine by me. But this copy paste and changing numbers feels so lazy and immersion breaking. Cant really stand it even though I understand why they're doing it. They always come up with these ludicrous design decision why something can't work or is designed this way and explain it with their "lore" and "makes sense" reason. And then they do something like this with 0 reason, lore why we are going back there in the first place. More design for esports less for the MMORPG player. Terrible way of implementation.
    Does M+ in general even have any 'lore'? Even back before we started going back to old dungeons, what exactly was the immersive and lore-friendly reason that we took these keystones to these places that we've already been and then did the shit that we already did, but harder and as fast as possible so our keystone would be more empowered when we picked it back up at the end? How did seasons "build the world" to begin with, let alone start taking away from it now that we're doing the same shit, just super elsewhere instead of just locally elsewhere?

  9. #67609
    Quote Originally Posted by CalamityHeart View Post
    Does M+ in general even have any 'lore'? Even back before we started going back to old dungeons, what exactly was the immersive and lore-friendly reason that we took these keystones to these places that we've already been and then did the shit that we already did, but harder and as fast as possible so our keystone would be more empowered when we picked it back up at the end? How did seasons "build the world" to begin with, let alone start taking away from it now that we're doing the same shit, just super elsewhere instead of just locally elsewhere?
    Pretty sure M+ was always bronze Dragonflight shenanigans. The fact that the Keystone is a bronze hourglass seems like a fairly large tipoff.

    Might even have been offhandedly mentioned as the lore reason some time way back in Legion.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by Makorus View Post
    I mean, honestly, it's only WoD that has fucked up loot tables, because of the way they did dungeon loot, where every dungeon essentially shared loot and trinkets were just stat sticks.

    The only dungeon from WoD that had somewhat interesting loot was UBRS.

    But yeah, modernizing loot would be great. Comparing trinkets and even gear with effects from Legion and BfA to stuff from WoD/MoP makes it really lop-sided and annoying.

    Same with necks and rings having main stat. It's stupid.

    - - - Updated - - -



    I mean, I can see where people are coming from.

    After the first two weeks of the expansion, there are pretty much gonna be four new dungeons.

    No ones gonna run the other dungeons outside of leveling/quests that require them.

    Or how often did you run Theater of Pain in Season 4?
    You don't really have any reason to do dungeons at all outside M+ though, even more so now that the expansion is basically over.

    Mythic dungeons will likely be needed for profession reagents, so i imagine many might rerun all the DF dungeons, and not just the M+ ones.

    Still, the reason to split the dungeon up like this is likely to ensure that not many run the remaining four dungeons outside once or twice for story purposes, or in general for gearing at the start of the expansion like usual. That way when Season 2 begins you have a fresh set of dungeons to run instead of just doing the same ones again.
    The world revamp dream will never die!

  10. #67610
    I mean, Season 4 literally has a lore reason why we go to those dungeons: The defeat of the Jailer sent the Dreadlords into a panic and we are sent out to capture them to interrogate them.

  11. #67611
    Quote Originally Posted by Lady Atia View Post
    Again, there is no change in the Beta for me. So I assume it's a bug if someone sees Kyrians there lol. They already replaced the classic Spirit Healer with the HD version with Shadowlands.
    Theres a Toy that replaces the SpiritHealer with a Kyrian.

  12. #67612
    Quote Originally Posted by Lady Atia View Post
    My personal headcanon is that we have to timewalk back there because the infinite flight messed up the timeways and made it so that our original dungeon group didn't arrive. Basically Caverns of Time: TotJS/CoS/HoV/SMBG. Similiar to season 4 and the Dreadlords trying to manipulate stuff (although the WoD dungeons were kinda weird haha).

    The fated raid quests also imply that someone tries to mess with the timelines already, although it's weird with Shadowlands as time should work differently there anyways.

    Also imo 8 Dungeons is the golden number. Season 3 felt far too overwhelming for new players.
    Well there has to be a real reason not something I make up in my head. Not that hard for blizzard to implement a proper way.

    I definitely hard disagree with the number of Dungeons. 8 get old real fast even if it is just for 1 season but maybe experiencing it first hand will change my mind as in 8 new dungeons every 6-9 months. Legion was the best model for me as the new dungeons also made sense for patch reasons.

  13. #67613
    Quote Originally Posted by Nymrohd View Post
    I think they absolutely will need to change the loot tables for the old dungeons. I get not doing it fully for the Fated season because it was entirely an experiment but it should be done for this.
    I hope they do a Season tab in the Journal as well. Having to individually search for the dungeons is annoying.

  14. #67614
    Herald of the Titans Lady Atia's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2015
    Location
    The Rumour Tower
    Posts
    2,722
    Quote Originally Posted by huth View Post
    I hope they do a Season tab in the Journal as well. Having to individually search for the dungeons is annoying.
    You can get an addon for that =)

  15. #67615
    Quote Originally Posted by Lady Atia View Post
    You can get an addon for that =)
    You can get addons for everything. It doesn't mean that it shouldn't be introduced in the base game. I agree with him, you should have a dungeon journal window with everything season exclusive, dungeon, affixes and rewards included.

  16. #67616
    Void Lord Aeluron Lightsong's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    In some Sanctuaryesque place or a Haven
    Posts
    44,162
    Does anybody else feel like this new season design takes away even more from the world building aspect? We are on the Dragonflight isles and suddenly go back to Halls of Valor to retrieve the Aegis. Jade Serpent ... ?? Feels more and more like Diablo 3 Season 27. On top of that we only get 8 Dungeons AGAIN which, quite frankly, is just not enough. 10 is the minimum imo to get a good rotation going.
    ......Omg not every little % of this game has to be immersive friendly. Suspension of disbelief exists for a reason. I mean do you actually think champions of Azeroth go in a raid every week to kill Denathrius and so on and so forth? There's a point where you just accept the fact this is a game, a very big and popular video game but still a game.
    #TeamLegion #UnderEarthofAzerothexpansion plz #Arathor4Alliance #TeamNoBlueHorde

    Warrior-Magi

  17. #67617
    I am Murloc! Nymrohd's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2022
    Location
    Greece
    Posts
    5,017
    Quote Originally Posted by Aeluron Lightsong View Post
    ......Omg not every little % of this game has to be immersive friendly. Suspension of disbelief exists for a reason. I mean do you actually think champions of Azeroth go in a raid every week to kill Denathrius and so on and so forth? There's a point where you just accept the fact this is a game, a very big and popular video game but still a game.
    I mean every single time in a raid or dungeon after the first is not really immersive. You already did it. I am all for a focus on immersion but some elements of an MMO just don't allow for it.

  18. #67618
    Stood in the Fire Melorandor's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Northern Michigan
    Posts
    436
    When is the soundtrack gonna drop?

  19. #67619
    Quote Originally Posted by Nymrohd View Post
    I mean every single time in a raid or dungeon after the first is not really immersive. You already did it. I am all for a focus on immersion but some elements of an MMO just don't allow for it.
    Exactly. We won't have 4 new dungeons in Season 1, we will have 0. Hell, other 4 may feel more fresh after 2 weeks of Heroic/M0 farming for XP/gear/quests.

  20. #67620
    Epic!
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Location
    Northern California
    Posts
    1,730
    Quote Originally Posted by Melorandor View Post
    When is the soundtrack gonna drop?
    You mean OST? I have not heard any music, but I don’t think the music has been great for SL and BFA. Legion was amazing, specially the login music

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •