Last edited by Raetary; 2021-11-19 at 05:06 PM.
I believe the explanation given is that the core that Zovaal reclaimed is the thing that gives the Arbiter the ability to actually judge souls. Furthermore I have to wonder whether it is also the actual sigil, in which case we do remake it before Zereth Mortis seeing as it is a plot point that we need to remake it before we can enter, and indeed the Primus has been hard at work doing just that since 9.1 ended.
The world revamp dream will never die!

What? Where are you getting all that stuff from? There's definitely hints that the Maw was once a different place, though not that it was the Jailer's. If anything, the expectation would be that he originally stood in the Arbiter's place, since he was doing that very job. His 'rebellion' also definitely wasn't before the Shadowlands, he's part of that construct.
And of course they'd want a new arbiter. Bastion et al are still vastly better than getting shoved into the Maw. It's not like people wouldn't die without one.
- - - Updated - - -
Not wanting to mess with it to avoid Zovaal getting his hands on it, i'd imagine. As well as having more pressing matters on their hands.
Maybe the whole Pelagos thing is what allows us to go to Zereth Mortis?
How would that allow it to get into Zovaal's hands? They were in Oribos and Zovaal was still trapped in the Maw before the raid. Hell, they could have done it soon after the Arbiter broke before they were starved for Anima. And how would stopping souls from going into the Maw and empowering the Jailer and his forces by making a new Arbiter not a pressing matter that needed attention?
Honestly, i am deeply disappointed that they never actually used the Arbiter for anything.
I wanted to interact with her and see her model in action, but nah.
Great model design, all that set up for her to be this grand being, only for us to find out she was just a glorified macguffin.
The same reason as to why none of them sent some messenger or something to Oribos, to check out what's going on with the stream of souls.
Incompetence and bad writing.
Damn, some of these tier set bonuses are bonkers. Survival hunter AoE burst may be through the roof.
Sometimes, the light of the moon is a key to other spaces. I've found a place where, for a night or two, the streets curve in unfamiliar ways. If I walk here, I might find insight, or I might be touched by madness.

Saw a rumor today that Blizzard may announce "World of Warcraft: Complete Edition" for consoles at the Game Awards. I generally don't give these sorts of rumors any real attention but on a lark I thought about it and still feels like it's odd though not improbable.
Though what "Complete" means is what intrigues me because it obviously wouldn't be truly complete as more expansions come out. Presumably.
The Kyrians could just stop chugging people into the broken machine and therefore the maw. They need someone to sort it, but frankly it wouldn't have to be an arbiter per se. We don't really know how flawless she was anyway. It is clearly implied some people had to change afterwards because they couldn't manage to become harvester, ascended, etc. Since we have no clue what happens in other afterlives, maybe you could just go with the supernatural version where every prick get's their own little piece of heaven where they relive their best offs in an eternal dream. Maybe we could just have some other people sort them like an old post office. Frankly I'm not even sure why we can't just use the old arbiter, the reading magic is clearly something all the (higher) caretakers are capable off, so any kind of machine could probably do it, at worst they'd need some extra anima.
If there is a special property to the Roomba's/Zoofie's core, Blizzrd didn't explain it yet.
You are welcome, Metzen. I hope you won't fuck up my underground expansion idea.

It does and I always brush it off too, but I dunno, something grabbed me this time.
I still doubt it though yeah.
That was one of my thoughts too, but I then thought about how they have enough trouble delivering content more than like, once a year.
You are welcome, Metzen. I hope you won't fuck up my underground expansion idea.
Evil only wins when it spreads. It can cause destruction, it can cause death—but those are consequences of its nature, not its victory. Not its goal. The danger of evil, the purpose of evil, is that it causes those who would oppose it to become evil also.

Maybe, but why risk it? And as we've seen in the raid, being trapped in the Maw was utterly irrelevant.
Also, they didn't even find out about it being broken until after the starvation set in.
You've seen what happens when the realms are deprived of Anima. That wouldn't work in the long term. It's not like the Kyrians were specificially throwing people into the Maw, either, they just automagically went there after being brought to the Shadowlands and not being sorted by somebody.
So we're left with the situation that they can both not afford to not do it and have to have something in place to sift through the arriving souls. The arbiter worked just fine for eons, no surprise they'd want to use a solution that has served them perfectly well for so long.