There are 24 dps specs and 12 dps classes vying for 14 dps slots in a raid.
Its even tougher for melee with and 13 dps specs on 9 dps classes fighting for 4-5 melee dps spots.
That means no matter what, its a rolling wave of what is the "melee meta" and gets into those spots and the rest fight on the forums about why their class sucks. No matter what.
Using WCL data Outlaw is fairly solid, only typically behind Feral and Unholy on most fights.
So keep posting/fighting of course, but it doesn't end because the game is so meta focused and there are so few slots for such a wide number of specs and classes.
- - - Updated - - -
I'm looking at Sludgefist WCL right now (link at the bottom) and compared to other melee Rogues look like 4th in # of parses? Where is this "lowest" coming from? And Arms sucks on many fights, but execute damage is really strong here.
Melee parses:
Warrior - 50 (48 arms, 2 fury)
DK - 34 (unholy 34, frost 0)
Paladin - 13
Hunter - 0
Shaman - 0
Rogue - 27 (outlaw 23, sub 4, mut 0)
Monk - 28
DH - 17
Druid - 1
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/zone/st...s/26#boss=2399