But you see, this is just what I mean. I even wrote it earlier somewhere. The Player Character is not one of the evil Forsaken, because the plot does not work when they are. That is a canonical fact. They surely have issues, to put it mildly, but they are not hellbent on murder and mayhem. The question is, is the PC an example of how the Forsaken are? Because most Forsaken players here seem to not agree to that. @
omeomorfismo here famously stated he wants his character to be a "sick sociopath". So is the PC an exception to the rule, because the Forsaken could not be intergrated into the plot otherwise? This would basically confirm that they are unfit to be part of the Horde's story.
If however the folks here are all wrong and the Forsaken PC is not a psychopathic killer, then I don't see what the problem with Calia is. Obviously Sylvanas would be a bad ruler in the eyes of someone like that and a change to a more positive personality would be welcome.