WoW Bard Class Concept

[Triceron]

No. Heavy metal does not fit the aesthetic of WoW (outside of jokes). Drinking is as old as history. No reason why it wouldn't fit.

Sure it fits.

Grom Hellscream in WC2 was metal as fuck.

ETC's members would all fit in any raid, even with their metal inspired instruments. The Arcanite Ripper and Sun Lute were even obtainable weapons that let you turn into ETC members and play rock music. This is as far back as TBC.

Did you never play TBC or get these items? Cuz they were legit epic weapons, not just toys.

It actually is, because it's not grounded in lore.

Nothing is 'grounded in lore' until it actually enters lore.

Pandaria wasn't even truly grounded in lore until Mists of Pandaria formally introduced it.

Rock and roll does exist in WoW since ETC and Blight Boar are both canonical.

[AKCephalopod]

Never said they aren't.



No. Heavy metal does not fit the aesthetic of WoW (outside of jokes). Drinking is as old as history. No reason why it wouldn't fit.



It actually is, because it's not grounded in lore.

Warcraft has involved rock and roll as an aesthetic for a long time. Remember when you beat the Warcraft 3 campaign and were rewarded with a rock concert staring Arthas as the lead guitarist or ETC? What about the quest at the Darkmoon Faire with the band Blightboar? Or how so much of the early aesthetic of Warcraft was based on heavy metal album covers?

If you're looking for lore or aesthetics for the bard to be based around, the Darkmoon Faire is chocked full of it, not to mention how much the setting itself owes to the aesthetics of heavy metal.

[Shadowferal]

Never liked bards in EQ.
A year after the debacle that was WoD I quit and still haven't returned. Although I used to think I would. If they make bards then I won't bother.

[DatToffer]

Warcraft has involved rock and roll as an aesthetic for a long time. Remember when you beat the Warcraft 3 campaign and were rewarded with a rock concert staring Arthas as the lead guitarist or ETC? What about the quest at the Darkmoon Faire with the band Blightboar? Or how so much of the early aesthetic of Warcraft was based on heavy metal album covers?

If you're looking for lore or aesthetics for the bard to be based around, the Darkmoon Faire is chocked full of it, not to mention how much the setting itself owes to the aesthetics of heavy metal.

And don't forget Steve Danuser admitting he wanted Garrosh ending to be "metal as fuck", lol

[Teriz]

They are totally a thing, just not playable for reasons

They're spoof characters of a Blizzard employee cover band. There's zero lore surrounding any of those characters, including ETC, which is a spoof of the Tauren Chieftain from WC3.

- - - Updated - - -

You know, they made an entire questline with an easter egg character to Indiana Jones. Who's to say which cameo character is lore-valid and which is not ?

Considering that the ETC spoof has been around for almost 20 years and there's still no actual lore around it, I think it's fair to say that it isn't lore-valid.

- - - Updated - - -

Nothing really meshes if you're advocating for giant mech suits romping around next to dudes in cloth and plate.

Who needs to advocate for it? Blizzard put giant mech suits in the game, and they're lore based.

There's a vast difference between a class based on the technology of Gnomes and Goblins, and a class based on a Blizzard employee cover band.

Rock and Roll is no more absurd than giant mechs and drunken pandas.

Uh, yes it is. You can explain the giant mechs and Pandaren martial arts. Good luck explaining why a Tauren is running around Azeroth wearing a glam rock outfit and hitting people with an electric guitar.

[DatToffer]

Considering that the ETC spoof has been around for almost 20 years and there's still no actual lore around it, I think it's fair to say that it isn't lore-valid.

I wonder that you would consider lore to be valid. They have a presence ingame, anchored by npc dialogs. Would you require them to have a quest dedicated to them, a background ?

[Maljinwo]

They're spoof characters of a Blizzard employee cover band. There's zero lore surrounding any of those characters, including ETC, which is a spoof of the Tauren Chieftain from WC3.

The lore is that they are a band that plays in Darkmoon Faire and hangs out in Silvermoon

[Teriz]

I wonder that you would consider lore to be valid. They have a presence ingame, anchored by npc dialogs. Would you require them to have a quest dedicated to them, a background ?

I would require those characters to actually participate in the general lore of the game. Not simply be wallpaper for a variety of side activities.

- - - Updated - - -

The lore is that they are a band that plays in Darkmoon Faire and hangs out in Silvermoon

Which means they aren't heroes, just some random NPCs no different than shopkeepers or townsfolk. WoW's classes (especially the expansion classes) are based on heroes.

[AKCephalopod]

They're spoof characters of a Blizzard employee cover band. There's zero lore surrounding any of those characters, including ETC, which is a spoof of the Tauren Chieftain from WC3.

- - - Updated - - -



Considering that the ETC spoof has been around for almost 20 years and there's still no actual lore around it, I think it's fair to say that it isn't lore-valid.

- - - Updated - - -



Who needs to advocate for it? Blizzard put giant mech suits in the game, and they're lore based.

There's a vast difference between a class based on the technology of Gnomes and Goblins, and a class based on a Blizzard employee cover band.



Uh, yes it is. You can explain the giant mechs and Pandaren martial arts. Good luck explaining why a Tauren is running around Azeroth wearing a glam rock outfit and hitting people with an electric guitar.

There is lore around it. They're a band in the world. Do you think we need the backstory of all the band members before they're a valid part of the lore? There are plenty of characters we don't have any background on and yet are considered perfectly valid parts of the lore, even other tribute characters. The many characters and items related to Alex Afrasaibi come to mind.

Elite Tauren Chieftains have played in many locations, including Shattrath, BRD, Darkmoon Faire, and Caverns of time. Not to mention they're the main point of the Horde Childrens Day questline. That questline makes it obvious that they're popular in universe. In fact, they're still present in Silvermoon for this exact quest.

Ignoring that ETC is part of the lore makes no sense. They're obviously part of the world. The only reason to ignore their place in WoW is because you don't like it. You don't have to pretend they don't exist.

- - - Updated - - -

I would require those characters to actually participate in the general lore of the game. Not simply be wallpaper for a variety of side activities.

- - - Updated - - -



Which means they aren't heroes, just some random NPCs no different than shopkeepers or townsfolk. WoW's classes (especially the expansion classes) are based on heroes.

Demon Hunters and Death Knights weren't heroes until Blizzard made them be. Demon Hunters were villains following Illidan and the only ones you could have called "heroes" were those who are open traitors, of which there were only two examples pre-legion. Death Knights, likewise, were strictly villains we fought before circumstances contrived to make them on our side.

On the lore part, that also makes a lot of other characters not actually part of the lore. Anyone at the Darkmoon Fair, anyone from any Holiday, any character in an order hall who does nothing and is just there as a name. There were also many characters who were just "wallpaper" before blizzard made them important in future expansions. My point being that simply existing in the world is enough for Blizzard to make a character playable.

[Triceron]

Uh, yes it is. You can explain the giant mechs and Pandaren martial arts. Good luck explaining why a Tauren is running around Azeroth wearing a glam rock outfit and hitting people with an electric guitar.

You mean like we already had in TBC with the guitar and bass Axe weapons?

They were legit Epic weapons that were BIS for Paladins and Warriors for quite a while.

[Teriz]

There is lore around it. They're a band in the world. Do you think we need the backstory of all the band members before they're a valid part of the lore? There are plenty of characters we don't have any background on and yet are considered perfectly valid parts of the lore, even other tribute characters. The many characters and items related to Alex Afrasaibi come to mind.

Elite Tauren Chieftains have played in many locations, including Shattrath, BRD, Darkmoon Faire, and Caverns of time. Not to mention they're the main point of the Horde Childrens Day questline. That questline makes it obvious that they're popular in universe. In fact, they're still present in Silvermoon for this exact quest.

Ignoring that ETC is part of the lore makes no sense. They're obviously part of the world. The only reason to ignore their place in WoW is because you don't like it. You don't have to pretend they don't exist.

What major storylines have they taken part in? What are their heroic exploits? Where are similar characters like them in order to justify a class?

If we can't answer those questions, then they aren't really lore characters.

Demon Hunters and Death Knights weren't heroes until Blizzard made them be. Demon Hunters were villains following Illidan and the only ones you could have called "heroes" were those who are open traitors, of which there were only two examples pre-legion. Death Knights, likewise, were strictly villains we fought before circumstances contrived to make them on our side.

Villains can also be considered a "hero" character. Hero characters are not always aligned with good.

On the lore part, that also makes a lot of other characters not actually part of the lore. Anyone at the Darkmoon Fair, anyone from any Holiday, any character in an order hall who does nothing and is just there as a name. There were also many characters who were just "wallpaper" before blizzard made them important in future expansions. My point being that simply existing in the world is enough for Blizzard to make a character playable.

"Wallpaper" is exactly what I would classify characters like the ETC as. Nothing more than silly spoofs to add some levity to the world.

- - - Updated - - -

You mean like we already had in TBC with the guitar and bass Axe weapons?

They were legit Epic weapons that were BIS for Paladins and Warriors for quite a while.

There's a difference between creating a one-off weapon for shits and giggles, and creating an entire class that requires a legitimate lore basis.

[Triceron]

There's a difference between creating a one-off weapon for shits and giggles, and creating an entire class that requires a legitimate lore basis.

And they proven that they can and will do it when they made Brewmaster into a full spec for the Monk class with kegs and all intact.

So what exactly is so off about Rock and Roll when it already fits the aesthetics from punk rock Forsaken hairstyles to a clans literally named after Rock and Roll references (Black Tooth Grin) and weapons styled after musical instruments.

Are you saying Blizzard couldn't have added those because it doesn't fit Warcraft? Because if so, then you're just flat out wrong, and more importantly, a liar.

[Teriz]

And they proven that they can and will do it when they made Brewmaster into a full spec for the Monk class with kegs and all intact.

Er, the Brewmaster concept works just fine with a Monk concept because the Brewmaster is loosely based on an actual style of Chinese martial arts. The Monk class as a concept is also loosely based on Chinese martial arts. Further, Blizzard established an entire layer of lore surrounding Chen Stormstout, the Pandaren race, Brewmasters, and Pandaria in of itself. Also Blizzard made Chen a hero within Warcraft's storyline and had him participate in a major event in Warcraft's history.

You really can't compare that to what we have with ETC; A bunch of spoof characters who pop up and play songs from time to time.

So what exactly is so off about Rock and Roll when it already fits the aesthetics from punk rock Forsaken hairstyles to a clans literally named after Rock and Roll references (Black Tooth Grin) and weapons styled after musical instruments.

Are you saying Blizzard couldn't have added those because it doesn't fit Warcraft? Because if so, then you're just flat out wrong, and more importantly, a liar.

Seriously?

There's a huge difference between Blizzard pulling aesthetics from goth and punk for the Undead race, and creating a class based around rock and heavy metal music in a high fantasy game.

Is there a class of adventurers that are using heavy metal music and electric guitars to kill monsters? The answer is simply no, and they would never create such a class because it would be jumping the shark on multiple levels.

[Kyphael]

This is amazing, and I hope it happens. 10/10

Blizzard devs, if you're reading this, STOP ACTING INAPPROPRIATELY AND DO SOMETHING GOOD FOR A CHANGE.

[kiramon]

Er, the Brewmaster concept works just fine with a Monk concept because the Brewmaster is loosely based on an actual style of Chinese martial arts. The Monk class as a concept is also loosely based on Chinese martial arts. Further, Blizzard established an entire layer of lore surrounding Chen Stormstout, the Pandaren race, Brewmasters, and Pandaria in of itself. Also Blizzard made Chen a hero within Warcraft's storyline and had him participate in a major event in Warcraft's history.

You really can't compare that to what we have with ETC; A bunch of spoof characters who pop up and play songs from time to time.



Seriously?

There's a huge difference between Blizzard pulling aesthetics from goth and punk for the Undead race, and creating a class based around rock and heavy metal music in a high fantasy game.

Is there a class of adventurers that are using heavy metal music and electric guitars to kill monsters? The answer is simply no, and they would never create such a class because it would be jumping the shark on multiple levels.

This is incredibly lame thinking, especially in fantasy settings. Bards have been a mainstay for a very very long time, like 1976 for DND. Thinking they don’t fit in wow because they aren’t in it currently just doesn’t make sense.

[Teriz]

This is incredibly lame thinking, especially in fantasy settings. Bards have been a mainstay for a very very long time, like 1976 for DND. Thinking they don’t fit in wow because they aren’t in it currently just doesn’t make sense.

Except they have never been a mainstay in Warcraft, ever. There was never a Bard hero in WC3. There was never a Bard class in the tabletop Warcraft or WoW games. There are no Bard hero characters in WoW period. Blizzard even made classic Shaman and Paladins take up their niche. So yeah, they don’t fit as a WoW class.

Think about it; what possible expansion could bring a Bard class into the game? Who would be the major lore character on the cover?

[Triceron]

Also Blizzard made Chen a hero within Warcraft's storyline and had him participate in a major event in Warcraft's history.

And Hellscream has been at the stage and center of WC2, WC3 and his legacy carried well into WoW.

Hellscream is metal as fuck.

I mean you can say heavy metal has no place in WOW all you want, but Blizzard has already shown its been a part of the series since WC2, and the references permeate all of Warcraft lore.

Black Tooth Grin Clan is a literal reference to Pantera. We have actual Axe weapons that are instruments. We have rock concerts in the game every month. How is the aesthetic not part of WoW?

[Teriz]

And Hellscream has been at the stage and center of WC2, WC3 and his legacy carried well into WoW.

Yeah, in the Warrior class.

Hellscream is metal as fuck.

I mean you can say heavy metal has no place in WOW all you want, but Blizzard has already shown its been a part of the series since WC2, and the references permeate all of Warcraft lore.

Again, big difference between pulling aesthetics and references to metal music, and having a rock band class roaming around Azeroth with electric guitars and drum sets.

Black Tooth Grin Clan is a literal reference to Pantera.

So what? Where’s the adventurers in WoW fighting monsters with electric guitars and heavy metal songs?

[Triceron]

Yeah, in the Warrior class.

Yep, who can use weapons that are totally heavy metal inspired. So what's the problem again? Something about the Heavy Metal aesthetic doesn't work in WoW when Warriors can already run around with guitar-axes that turn them into rock stars?

[PolarityER]

Ngl, I did not read all of this, but from what I did read it looks really fun. I would probably consider coming back and at least trying it out.