Originally Posted by
Val the Moofia Boss
I wouldn't call STO or GW2 trash, but I would be very hesitant to recommend them.
Star Trek Online is for ST fans. STO is pretty much the closest you're going to get to a true continuation of Star Trek after DS9 (though it does have tie in promos with nu-Trek like the Abrams films and Discovery, STO thankfully did not jump the shark like them).
The early story arcs of STO are pretty so-so/okay/meh, but once you start getting into the DS9 and Delta Quadrant stuff, it gets pretty good. They even got a lot of the actors from the shows to come back and voice their characters. Also, wish fulfillment stuff in seeing people like Geordi and Nog become Starfleet captains, or cast reunions.
The one major conceit with STO's storytelling is that... well, it was a video game designed to appeal to the lowest common denominator, and the preeminent game design philosophy for appealing to everyone was (and still is) to create a game where you kill people and blow stuff up. Which means that the bulk of the gameplay is combat, which feels unnatural for a "Star Trek" entry. And that affects the lore, as now suddenly the Alpha Quadrant is a battlefield where everyone is at war with each other. The ground combat is mediocre, but the space combat is quite fun. Also, you can do missions co-op with other people, and there is level scaling, which is nice. That being said, there are quite a lot of non-combat missions in STO.
In STO, you can choose to be either 1. Starfleet, 2. Klingon Empire (the empire consisting of the Klingons, Gorn, Orion, and one other race), 3. the Romulan Flotilla (basically survivors of the Hobus Supernova who did not join the evil Empress Sela), and 4. Dominion (basically Jem'Hadar only). You can choose to play as a canon race, or create your own rubberhead alien (except for Dominion, who are exclusively Jem'Hadar. Can't create your own alien for Dominion). You also captain your own ship and can basically pick from any ship in the franchise (IIRC faction locks were removed, so your character can be in Starfleet and yet still fly Jem'Hadar warships), as well as customize it a little bit visually. You can create your own AI party members (called "bridge officers") who follow you into battle on the ground (and provide abilities for the spaceship segments). There are also A LOT of character customization in STO, with you being able to pick pretty much any uniform from the franchise. There are also a lot of new, STO exclusive ship designs and uniforms and outfits you can pick too, which are pretty cool.
There are two major problems with STO. The first is the clunky engine: the engine is very clunky. As mentioned before, the ground combat is mediocre, partly because of the sluggish physics. Also, the game just doesn't look good graphically, and can even inexplicably seem to lag at higher resolutions (even though, again, the graphics are nothing revolutionary).
The other problem is the cash shop: the really milk you. Some alien races, such as the fan favorite Catians, are locked behind the cash shop (and you can't recreate them via the "create your own rubberhead alien" option). There was also a big pay-2-win controversy a few years back, where with the Delta Quadrant expansion they raised the level cap from 50 to 60, and introduced a sixth tier of ships that where the new ships were far more powerful than the T5s, but you couldn't earn the T6s. You had to buy them from the cash shop. And the new Delta Quadrant expansion was way overturned so that you couldn't really do it with T5 ships, even with the best builds. I can't remember if they fixed that, but the fact that they did in the first place makes me wary that they might try to do mandatory p2w powerlevel creep again.
If you try out STO and really like it, and you stick around to like level 30, then at that point I would recommend sucking it up and just dropping money on a cash shop ship. The cash shop ships level scale, so you can be a level 1 character and buy a tier 5 ship and it will scale down to your level, and scale up with you as your character levels up.