Yes. But that actually requires the ability to read the logs and even there just checking the ilvl% rank can lead to incorrect evaluation - but at least it's something definitely more reliable and true than a score or ilvl.
Anyway i found most people complaining about "casuals getting gear" don't even bother doing those extra steps.
I am a casual myself. I don't care about mythic raiding, nor pushing keys - yet i'm doing now my 15s and while slower than many other people i'm getting my 226s. In the eyes of many people i shouldn't get that loot because even if i did the exact same content as them, i didn't do it fast enough or when they did it.