Silithus Sword ignored in Dragonflight

[Darknessvamp]

I vaguely recall a developer "promise" that the remains of Gorribal in Silithus would be an important part of Shadowlands, Does anyone happen to have a source for this on hand by chance? Did some cursory Googling but I can't seem to find when and who said it originally, so I can't confirm if I'm just misremembering something.

Not sure if it was really a promise or considered an "important part" of the expansion but they did mention during one of the lore interviews during Shadowlands development that the sword wasn't as big a threat as before but it would get addressed in the expansion and I remember people then immediately started speculating everything from the Jailer was going to pull the sword from the planet and wield it in the final raid to Azeroth waking up in the final patch and using it to decapitate the Jailer.

[Aucald]

Not sure if it was really a promise or considered an "important part" of the expansion but they did mention during one of the lore interviews during Shadowlands development that the sword wasn't as big a threat as before but it would get addressed in the expansion and I remember people then immediately started speculating everything from the Jailer was going to pull the sword from the planet and wield it in the final raid to Azeroth waking up in the final patch and using it to decapitate the Jailer.

I found it, actually. It was in the 4/10/2020 Shadowlands Lore Interview with Steve Danuser and Taliesin and Evitel. Specifically, Danuser, when asked if the remains of the sword would "disappear from Silithus," replied "[t]he sword has a part to play in something to come" with no real further information. Since this was an interview about Shadowlands lore, it was generally assumed that this "something to come" would be part of the Shadowlands story, although Danuser's answer is open and evasive enough to mean it's just fuel for a future story they plan to tell, somewhere further down the pike.

[cparle87]

What the hell does basic first aid knowledge have to do with a gigantic mystical sword manifested in deep space and embedded into a planet? Clearly Ion is being hyperbolic by saying splinter. No splinter that size in relation to your body would just be sitting there forever and you paid it no mind.

Anyone with basic knowledge of first aid would realize the person with that splinter would probably die from internal damage before too long.

Except we didn't "pay it no mind". We spent an entire expansion gathering up her magical blood she was hemorrhaging and feeding it back to her to keep her stable, with the implication that with enough strength she could prevent her internal bleeding and stabilize. Remember the pandaren starting area where the ship was crashed into the turtle and the last ditch plan was to blow the ship out and heal the wound? There is no force on this world that we can wield that would allow us to fix the wound if we removed the sword. The poison in the sword was neutralized almost immediately, the bleeding was stopped, Azeroth is stable. There's nothing more we can do.

Also even in the real world people live with shrapnel in their bodies for the rest of their lives. You're not going to just magically die from having a foreign object inside you.

[AngerFork]

Given all that was happening during the last few years, I have to wonder if the long term plan for the story is "Alex did something crazy, we'll come back to that when we have to." It's a decent story hook that could go a few different ways & there's obvious interest in where that story hook might go, so no reason to rush to it if it could play out really well in the future.

[shise]

How do you know?

We know nothing of Dragonflight so far or about their intentions. Chances are it will be converted into a tree for teh night elf or something like that.

[matheney2k]

There's a fairly major difference between making something stop moving and removing it physically. We generally didn't kill these gods by seizing their body and suplexing it.

We literally did though lmao. Tractor beamed Sargeras while he was dry humping Azeroth and suplexed his ass in a jail or something.

Explain to me why they can't do that to some measly sword giving the planet a sliver if they could do it to a literal God???

Just pull it out and lay it down in silithus if nothing else or pull it out and chuck it into space I mean ffs almost anything would have been a better solution then just leaving it and forgetting about it like it doesn't exist anymore..

[qwerty123456]

do you really think, based on how Gallywix is written, that the goblins didn't try to mine it from the start? We likely have nothing that can cut the sword and no flying ships strong enough to pull it out.

They were too busy going for the Azerite since it was easy to grab power. Plus the sword wasn't even deactivated/purified until later. Now its inert so it would be more easy to deal with than before.

[huth]

We literally did though lmao. Tractor beamed Sargeras while he was dry humping Azeroth and suplexed his ass in a jail or something.

Explain to me why they can't do that to some measly sword giving the planet a sliver if they could do it to a literal God???

Just pull it out and lay it down in silithus if nothing else or pull it out and chuck it into space I mean ffs almost anything would have been a better solution then just leaving it and forgetting about it like it doesn't exist anymore..

We didn't. The Pantheon did, and they locked themselves up with Sargeras immediately afterwards.

[matheney2k]

We didn't. The Pantheon did, and they locked themselves up with Sargeras immediately afterwards.

Ok I say again. They could not have taken the big-ass sword out of the planet? I will also say this again so it's more clear: there were 100 different scenarios Blizz could have done to give true closure to Legion and the sword in the planet, completely leaving it there and ignoring it for several years is objectively the worst decision out of them..

Why are you so eager to excuse this laziness?

[Shadowmatrix]

Why are you so eager to excuse this laziness?

Is it really so hard to accept they want to use it later?

[huth]

Ok I say again. They could not have taken the big-ass sword out of the planet?

No, because they locked themselves up immediately after pulling away Sargeras so as to keep him from causing more trouble.

Also, because what they did with it is actually sensible behaviour and you need to stop trying to get Azeroth killed already.

[matheney2k]

Is it really so hard to accept they want to use it later?

2 expansions later...when?

And use it for what exactly? Ion just said it's nothing more than a ''sliver'' (aka: insignificant) and doesn't mean anything. Logic would say that he said something like that because they don't have explicit plans for it.

- - - Updated - - -

No, because they locked themselves up immediately after pulling away Sargeras so as to keep him from causing more trouble.

Also, because what they did with it is actually sensible behaviour and you need to stop trying to get Azeroth killed already.

Get Azeroth killed? It's a ''sliver'' and nothing more. Nothing would happen to the planet if/when it gets removed because Ion just admitted to the sword being meaningless and long forgotten about.

[chrisisvacant]

If you don't have any means of removing it safely? Yes, it would be sitting there forever. Why do you think people live with shrapnel in their body?

Maybe actually inform yourself on the topic. Also, please don't tend to anybody with major objects lodged in their body, you'd probably kill them. Faster than the object would, at any rate.

So, you want to keep moving the goalposts? We've gone from basic first aid to surgical necessity?

Please, do tell me of a scenario where someone gets stabbed with a sword and is allowed to walk around? And please do tell me how there is a comparison between a piece of shrapnel which is small in relation to the body versus a giant fucking sword? You're busy comparing apples and, well, giant fucking swords.

Don't rush out to get your own medical degree any time soon.

[huth]

Get Azeroth killed? It's a ''sliver'' and nothing more. Nothing would happen to the planet if/when it gets removed because Ion just admitted to the sword being meaningless and long forgotten about.

Well, nothing will happen if it doesn't get removed, so why bother then? This doesn't work for your argument any better than the other option. Also, he said splinter, not sliver.

[Kumorii]

So, you want to keep moving the goalposts? We've gone from basic first aid to surgical necessity?

Please, do tell me of a scenario where someone gets stabbed with a sword and is allowed to walk around? And please do tell me how there is a comparison between a piece of shrapnel which is small in relation to the body versus a giant fucking sword? You're busy comparing apples and, well, giant fucking swords.

Don't rush out to get your own medical degree any time soon.

It's equally ridiculous to compare a sword to the stomach of a human and a sword stuck in a planet in a fictional world...

The intent of the writers is clearly that, for now, it's best if we leave it. We've stabilized the situation so it's not threatening.
it's not exactly rocket surgery.

[Nowhere886]

Is there a sword in Silithus?

[Wonderment2]

The end of BFA would have been the ideal time to have dealt with the Sword. They should of had N'zoth using it as a conduit to courrpt the world Soul or something.

It seems like a massive, literally, unresolved plot point. I doubt it will ever get resolved....

Edit: My main issue is that the Blade was cleansed of its courrption, great, but it still being there caused Azeroth to bleed all over the planet. We spent BFA closing wounds etc but to my knowledge nothing substantial was done to fix the bleed coming from the sword.

[Mehrunes]

Gotta love the arguments in defense of Blizzard here. From failed comparison to shrapnel which is 1. small and 2. completely enveloped by the body as opposed to a gigantic sword sticking out from what still is an open wound to "it will be dealt with when that story is revisited" excuse, which doesn't address how an approach where something is an issue only when the story focuses on a given area is completely artificial, because from the perspective of proper world building things don't just get frozen in time in some lore void just because they aren't the center of attention.

[Shadowmatrix]

A complete non-issue getting turned into a senseless argument, it is time to agree to disagree and walk away from this thread.

[exsanguinate]

Why would they focus on an old zone in a new expansion? Until we get a world revamp expansion they aren't going to deal with it.

Uldum, vale of eternal blossoms, silithus in bfa, arathi highlands etc.

yea why would they focus on old zones in a new expansion.