Originally Posted by
Skulltaker
The man himself. Watches Data's daughter being brutally murdered. Also thinks that the extinction of the Romulan species is somehow his fault.
Agnes Jurati. Has a Tal Shiar agent mind-meld her the memory of a race that was brutally murdered because they made synths. Proceeds to brutally murder her former lover, which somehow goes unpunished.
Seven of Nine. Gets to recover the ravaged body of a child she deeply cared for who's brutally murdered on screen. Deals with that by vaporizing a bunch of criminals she considers responsible.
Captain Rios. Struggles with what Starfleet has become because he watched his captain brutally murder two synths under the threat of his ship being blown up, and then take his own life.
Raffi Musiker. Loses her career because... she had close ties to Picard? She was humiliated for that...? My memory is a bit foggy for that. Anyway, no brutal murder on this one. Just a drug addict and a horribly unprofessional officer. Refreshing, I guess.
Elnor. Abandoned as a child by Picard. Decapitates a few drifters. Maybe he's supposed to be symbolic for how the entire Romulan race felt abandoned by Picard and turned to violence...?
Soji. Finds out she's a synth. Proceeds to immediately confirm everyone's greatest fear and decides to wipe out all life in the Galaxy by weird tentacle robot, because some organics can't be trusted, thus proving the Romulans right. Has an attempt on her life by hot Romulan agent dude.
Will and Diana, live in seclusion after they watched their child die. Are given a measure of peace, still, I'm going to say watching your child die isn't an easy thing to process.
Did I forget someone?
All these characters are torn down and have their lives shattered, in various ways. Not one of them has anything akin to a 'normal human problem', except maybe for Raffi.
I don't mind trauma. But when everyone has a tragic back story, it becomes very boring. It takes away from the issues of other characters. It's like a poor DnD group where every character had a terrible fate. Villager pillaged by Ogres. Parents were eaten by Dragons. God abandoned her entire civilization!
You cannot have everyone in your story being a downer. Discovery at least tried to rectify this by adding Tig Notaros character. But that's what SNW does so much better. The characters are allowed to have some fun. Yes, their lives suck some times. But it also doesn't. That's the difference.
I don't think I'd agree that Sisko started in the dirt, because with all that had happened to him, he still was a professional officer who managed to take care of his child. He was in a rough spot but remained a keen functioning officer. Because that's what Starfleet officers are supposed to be, in the first place, especially seasoned ones like Sisko. Professionals. That doesn't mean that life gets them down some times, but when they wear the uniform, they act the part. Doesn't mean that he didn't have issues to deal with, but he still managed to do his job, and do it well albeit through gritted teeth, and be a responsible father and a friend to the Dax, while getting to know the crew.
And Pike, while choosing to leave Starfleet, didn't take much to pull himself together. He manages to function, swallow his fears, and move ahead until they come back to haunt him. He has trauma. He's not defined by it.