Yes, but this is a reply to a longer series of comments made by the person I replied to.
The person I am replying to is stating that the mage talent trees are not utter garbage in their current state and that they're better than Classic's versions.
I'm suggesting that Classic's versions are much superior in terms of focused identity, and that the mage trees do need some dramatic overhauling in order to be as effective. Small tweaks are not going to fix some of the problems that the mage trees have as he has suggested.