1. #45021
    Quote Originally Posted by Houle View Post
    Oh no we dont need to know everything about it in detail, some mystery around it is good, fully agreed.
    That wasnt the point tho. The guy i was arguing with said the addition of the First Ones cleared things up and made for a better defined story. I was just making the point that that very much isnt the case.
    Oh okay, then i misunderstood, i apologize

  2. #45022
    Quote Originally Posted by justwatching View Post
    Agreed. People acting like every screenshot in an expansions presskit looks amazing.

    However I think the reason most people are bummed is cause it indicates another 4 zone island expansion.
    Even so, a 4 zone island could be about titans, old gods, void, etc. The only thing 4 zone island doesn't mean is zone revamp unless Blizzard decides to surprise us with a 4 zone island AND some world revamp stuff.

    edit: 4 not 5

  3. #45023
    The Insane Nymrohd's Avatar
    3+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Mar 2022
    Location
    Greece
    Posts
    17,421
    Quote Originally Posted by kavikor View Post
    Even if it is, people shouldn't judge an entire expansion based on 4 stills of probably 1% of each zone.

    There could be a lot to it.
    At the very least, it still means it is a themepark continent. Instead of trying for thematic consistency, it has 4 zones with wildly diferent visual themes. And that is jarring and breaks immersion.

  4. #45024
    The Lightbringer Valysar's Avatar
    15+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    France
    Posts
    3,927
    Quote Originally Posted by Merryck View Post
    Where are the real leaks ...
    We can't have true leaks now with AI
    (one true leak between thousands)
    Last edited by Valysar; 2023-11-01 at 08:02 PM.

  5. #45025
    Quote Originally Posted by kavikor View Post
    Even so, a 4 zone island could be about titans, old gods, void, etc. The only thing 4 zone island doesn't mean is zone revamp unless Blizzard decides to surprise us with a 4 zone island AND some world revamp stuff.

    edit: 4 not 5
    I think for a good chunk of people(me included tbh) its revamp or bust. An Island expansion would need a major feature to even have a chance at grabbing my attention.

  6. #45026
    I really hope we don't do Dwarf/Khaz Algar expansion next
    BfA was a step in my ideal direction, Shadowlands was a step WAY too far (skipping over what I wanted), and then Dragonflight was several steps backwards.
    Leave Khaz Algar and Avaloren for 12.X stuff just like how the Dragon Isles was brought up in BfA but wasn't relevant until 2 expansions later.
    Bring on the Light, Void, and Arcane invasion for 11.X

  7. #45027
    Quote Originally Posted by justwatching View Post
    Its the 4 Screenshots.
    It‘s maybe the most convincing fake leak yet.
    Make Alliance Great Again

  8. #45028


    I still think this was best shot we got so far
    same as red-eyed bolvar and dragon before df

  9. #45029
    Quote Originally Posted by vintage79 View Post
    I still think this was best shot we got so far
    same as red-eyed bolvar and dragon before df
    This was already confirmed fake by the author.

  10. #45030
    Scarab Lord ercarp's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    Suramar
    Posts
    4,970
    Has someone written up a recap of everything the binary riddler has claimed? I would like to add their info to the spreadsheet but it's so spread out (and in binary...) that it's a bit difficult to do that.

  11. #45031
    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    The lack of the faction Dracthyr feels intentional. If this is a two-part expansion then I'm sure we will get stories where they actually come into the factions.
    I'm not so sure. The two faction leader dracthyr never really got any spotlight; Sarkereth suffers the same problem in that he's a borderline nobody unless you played the dracthyr starting zone, but he had the much larger story burden to carry in the end. It feels less intentional and more like they got slotted into DF's storytelling methodology of developing a ton of sidestories and questlines at the expense of a strong and compelling main story.

    If their plot threads are meant to continue on into 11.0, then I guess I'll just be baffled. People grew weary of even much more positively received expansions by their end. I don't think anyone can argue that the appetite for more dragon and dracthyr focus is even stronger than it was in 2022. I honestly don't know if an Avaloren expansion that's practically just DF 2 would make me more or less dumbfounded than WoD's reveal.

    If they do show back up, then pile another one onto the list of DF spending more of its time spinning up new plot teases and hooks rather than trying to get you invested into the story happening in the moment. Not really a good omen that we're also three expansions in a row where they don't seem to figure out what the whole story will be until after it's over.
    Last edited by Murlocos; 2023-11-01 at 08:14 PM.

  12. #45032
    Quote Originally Posted by Nymrohd View Post
    At the very least, it still means it is a themepark continent. Instead of trying for thematic consistency, it has 4 zones with wildly diferent visual themes. And that is jarring and breaks immersion.
    It's several things I would say. It's theme park zones, which is always slightly annoying. The parts we see are boring, which doesnt bode well for the zone overall given the zone is supposed to only be shown from the choicest of angles in the trailer. And the zones look like ones we already have, which is a stak departure from how basically all zones outside revamps or callback zones offer at least a subtly different take on the same idea. Uldum being difficult to mistake for Vol'dun for instance, despite both being desert zones with Titan pyramids in them.

    A lot of this could be explained by these being the few seconds on the trailer that only show boring stuff, though that seems unlikely given four images are a large sample size given they dont seem to be taken in succession.
    The world revamp dream will never die!

  13. #45033
    Quote Originally Posted by Nyel View Post
    It‘s maybe the most convincing fake leak yet.
    I mean I think its pure to cope to call it fake at this point. Its so extremely well made and also clearly done in engine that if its fake the person who made it could use it to get a job at blizzard.

    The fact it has matching vertical fog pretty much sold it for me so I'm expecting it to be real.

  14. #45034
    At 2400 pages in and the only semi-real looking leak is the four screenshots (and I don't buy them) either Blizzard has something really big to reveal and are playing it incredibly close to the vest or there's no expansion announcement, lol.

  15. #45035
    The Unstoppable Force Raetary's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Base Camp
    Posts
    20,496
    Quote Originally Posted by ercarp View Post
    Has someone written up a recap of everything the binary riddler has claimed? I would like to add their info to the spreadsheet but it's so spread out (and in binary...) that it's a bit difficult to do that.
    Revamp + Khaz Algar
    Earthen playable race
    Artificer class
    N'zoth and Xal relevancy
    Removal of transmog restrictions
    Path of the Titans.




  16. #45036
    Legendary! Fahrad Wagner's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Ruins of Dalaran
    Posts
    6,994
    Quote Originally Posted by kavikor View Post
    Perhaps, but they're still the 'realest' of everything so far
    because there is a screenshot doesn't mean it's the real deal, for all we know a lost leak page 1312 could end up being the one leak, and then would be the realest thing. If we had a leak similar to what happened with SL and DF, sure, I'd be ok with calling it the realest thing out there. But those 4 screenshots... are not that.
    If they end up being the real deal, I'll apologise for how persistent and annoying I've been about this, but I will say it again: these screenshots are f-a-k-e.

  17. #45037
    Quote Originally Posted by Nymrohd View Post
    At the very least, it still means it is a themepark continent. Instead of trying for thematic consistency, it has 4 zones with wildly diferent visual themes. And that is jarring and breaks immersion.
    I do think worst case scenario would be getting another 4 zone island that has similar visuals to the Dragon Isles, that we dragonride all around, with no additional new major gameplay feature. It would actually feel like DF 2.0, but this is their 10th expansion and I'm hopeful.

  18. #45038
    Watch one of the AI looking leaks being real because they used AI for Environment building

  19. #45039
    Quote Originally Posted by kavikor View Post
    So far the realest leak is still the 4 images, I'd love to get something else.
    I used to think so too, but then more glaring things came up like "Why reuse assets for an island that we've never seen before?" and "Why make the new biomes the same as what we've seen in the Post MoP setting?" Like how the first image looks like Stormheim, the second image with the blue dwarf/drogbar looks like a Frostfire Ridge, the third image with the harpies look like Vol'dun and Gorgrond, and finally the last one is basically Val'sharah with Ohn'ahran Plains with Troll Bridges and Titan Sentinels.

    Like, none of this stuff is going to get people excited...

  20. #45040
    Assuming additional classes get unlocked for dractgyr, what would you play? I don’t think I’d make another dracthyr, but paladin or druid might be cool.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •