1. #81081
    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    Literally anyone who's serious about lore wouldn't give a fuck about Ethereal for a race, same other meme requests such as Ogres, Murlocs, the list goes on.

    There's only a big clamour for them because of the teenage edgelord void tint, if you put them in the same attire as an Ethereal in Mana Tombs no one would care for it.
    This is a bait topic but the idea that Ethereals aren't a lorehead race request is laughable.

  2. #81082
    Quote Originally Posted by Wyrt View Post
    Except all the people who have been asking for them since BC.
    You're making out if its a big representation out of 20 million subs. The figure is around that anyways. It's literally that political party who doesn't get listened to and doesn't get elected.

    I wouldn't be surprised if they're done with Allied Races altogether after Harranir considering how devastatingly unpopular the last 2 have been. 0.1% 0.3% each side for Earthern and 0.4% for Vulpera hardly screams motivation to do another.

    I can't imagine team meeting going "How should we spend our development time? Well the last one, only 0.1% of Alliance players play at Max level, thats a good use of our development time"
    Last edited by OCoyne; 2024-12-21 at 08:24 PM.

  3. #81083
    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post

    I can't imagine team meeting going "How should we spend our development time? Well the last one, only 0.1% of Alliance players play at Max level, thats a good use of our development time"
    The most played races are Human, Belf and Nelf. Between Mists and Midnight only Nelf has gotten serious focus and content.

    Blizz doesn't care.

  4. #81084
    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    You're making out if its a big representation out of 20 million subs. The figure is around that anyways. It's literally that political party who doesn't get listened to and doesn't get elected.

    I wouldn't be surprised if they're done with Allied Races altogether after Harranir considering how devastatingly unpopular the last 2 have been. 0.1% 0.3% each side for Earthern and 0.4% for Vulpera hardly screams motivation to do another.

    I can't imagine team meeting going "How should we spend our development time? Well the last one, only 0.1% of Alliance players play at Max level, thats a good use of our development time"
    Earthen get a lot of mileage regardless out of getting tons of cool looking NPCs all over the continent without them all looking the same, I don't know how much of the investment cost is calculated with the expectation of players using them in the case of a central faction to the story (obviously doesn't apply to random additions such as vulpera, which could have easily just been 3, or 4 reused models)

  5. #81085
    Ethereal would absolutely not be an Allied Race anyway. They'd be a proper core playable race. So problem solved.

  6. #81086
    Quote Originally Posted by Wyrt View Post
    Ethereal would absolutely not be an Allied Race anyway. They'd be a proper core playable race. So problem solved.
    Midnight's main selling point is Player Housing so it would already take up significant resources to make sure it's actually functional. Problem not solved.

    - - - Updated - - -

    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    The most played races are Human, Belf and Nelf. Between Mists and Midnight only Nelf has gotten serious focus and content.

    Blizz doesn't care.
    You've forgotten Belf and Nelf are DH exclusive and Nelf are for the super PvP meta lords - Like literally everyone in the top 0.1% is a Nelf.
    Shadowmeld badly needs a redesign, how it didnt make the patch racial balance pass is beyond me

  7. #81087
    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    Midnight's main selling point is Player Housing so it would already take up significant resources to make sure it's actually functional. Problem not solved.
    They have a whole team specifically dedicated to doing player housing. The main team is perfectly capable of making new races and/or classes while the other team makes houses.

  8. #81088
    Quote Originally Posted by Wyrt View Post
    They have a whole team specifically dedicated to doing player housing. The main team is perfectly capable of making new races and/or classes while the other team makes houses.
    See you're now just guessing to suit your own agenda

  9. #81089
    Quote Originally Posted by bruxx View Post
    Earthen get a lot of mileage regardless out of getting tons of cool looking NPCs all over the continent without them all looking the same, I don't know how much of the investment cost is calculated with the expectation of players using them in the case of a central faction to the story (obviously doesn't apply to random additions such as vulpera, which could have easily just been 3, or 4 reused models)
    Yeah, Earthen AR exists because they were going to be NPCs anyway. It was them or nothing in TWW launch unless they completely redesigned the expansion to not mostly be about Earthen.
    Last edited by Cheezits; 2024-12-21 at 09:01 PM.

  10. #81090
    The Patient
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Rapture
    Posts
    342
    With all the Undermine and goblin heavy focus, I dont care what other people say, TWW should of launched with tinkers as a new class instead of the Earthen AR and the Dragondriving we are getting.

    Although I dont want to believe it but it feels like tinkers as its own class is dead for WoW. (Regardless what those fake ChatGBT survey wants us to believe)

    On a different note: They updated the Zuldazar map on the PTR and it has a (possible?) exit of the Goblin Rocketdrill. Seems weird but I dig (no pun) it.

  11. #81091
    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    Literally anyone who's serious about lore wouldn't give a fuck about Ethereal for a race
    > going into Void expansion
    > race whose planet was destroyed by the Void

    Besides, their traveling Arab merchant bit is already an interesting fantasy that doesn't strongly overlap with any existing race. It helps they have a unique aesthetic both to themselves and architecturally.

    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    same other meme requests such as Ogres
    lolwut? People seriously and genuinely want ogres because they've been in the lore since Warcraft II and have interesting lore. Ogres aren't a meme request in the slightest.

    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    teenage edgelord void tint
    You've got to be joking. I don't want to play a void ethereal, I'm sure there are plenty of people who don't want to be void ethereals, the race has a great deal of potential appeal beyond that due to their culture and aesthetic. An incorporeal race made of magic is a concept that isn't usually represented as a playable race in RPGs and would make for a fairly novel addition to the roster.

    Besides, there were two fairly substantive expansion concepts proposed on this forum before with playable ethereals as a significant focus. This alone should tell you there's some interest in it.

    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    You're making out if its a big representation out of 20 million subs. The figure is around that anyways. It's literally that political party who doesn't get listened to and doesn't get elected.
    > 20 million subs

    lolwut

  12. #81092
    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    See you're now just guessing to suit your own agenda
    Wasn't it confirmed that Proletariat was behind housing, just like they were behind plunderstorm ?
    MMO Champs :

  13. #81093
    Quote Originally Posted by AOL Instant Messenger View Post
    >

    > 20 million subs

    lolwut
    You do realise NetEase have recorded 13 million users in Ulduar in WOTLK classic since it reopened dont you? 7 million between Pacific America And Europe isn't a hard ask at all.

    Literal 20 iq thread.

    There's clearly no intelligent discussion here so I'm out.
    Last edited by OCoyne; 2024-12-21 at 09:33 PM.

  14. #81094
    The Unstoppable Force Raetary's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Base Camp
    Posts
    20,369
    Quote Originally Posted by OCoyne View Post
    Midnight's main selling point is Player Housing so it would already take up significant resources to make sure it's actually functional. Problem not solved.
    That is not true.
    The main selling point for Midnight so far is a return to Quel'thalas.

    Housing is a feature in addition to the content we are receiving, in the same vein as Plunderstorm or Remix is.
    It just happens to be released during whatever phase of development Midnight is in, in early winter 2025.




  15. #81095
    Quote Originally Posted by Ochinko View Post
    With all the Undermine and goblin heavy focus, I dont care what other people say, TWW should of launched with tinkers as a new class instead of the Earthen AR and the Dragondriving we are getting.

    Although I dont want to believe it but it feels like tinkers as its own class is dead for WoW. (Regardless what those fake ChatGBT survey wants us to believe)
    I disagree about Earthen as an Allied Race and Dragonriding-- Dragonriding outside of the Isles was always going to happen, and the Earthen as an AR were designed specifically to be an AR. I think they did a great job with Earthen culture and I like playing one. I know it's just yet another dwarf, but it was already a big part of the expansion, it seems easy to add on.

    I do agree we should have gotten a tinker class, but I just don't know why we didn't. My only theory is that we'll get Tinker as Articifer in TLT with it being Titan themed and racially agnostic.

    Quote Originally Posted by Ochinko View Post
    On a different note: They updated the Zuldazar map on the PTR and it has a (possible?) exit of the Goblin Rocketdrill. Seems weird but I dig (no pun) it.
    Zuldazar was updated and expanded and I believe is confirmed to have a second entrance for Undermine. There are stills of a cinematic with the drill in Zuldazar, so I have to imagine part of the intro questline will take us there.

  16. #81096
    The Unstoppable Force Raetary's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Base Camp
    Posts
    20,369
    Anyway, i would sell an arm and a leg for playable Ethereals.

    Incorporeal space mummies are the shit, and i doubt Blizzard doesn't recognize it.
    They are already setup for more narrative significance, they are visually and aesthetically interesting, they are in desperate need for some more lore and fit perfectly into upcoming developments, and they are more or less ever present in the game thanks to transmog.

    And they are humanoid on top of that.

    It'd be a really wasted opportunity if they don't end up playable.




  17. #81097
    Quote Originally Posted by Raetary View Post
    Anyway, i would sell an arm and a leg for playable Ethereals.

    Incorporeal space mummies are the shit, and i doubt Blizzard doesn't recognize it.
    They are already setup for more narrative significance, they are visually and aesthetically interesting, they are in desperate need for some more lore and fit perfectly into upcoming developments, and they are more or less ever present in the game thanks to transmog.

    And they are humanoid on top of that.

    It'd be a really wasted opportunity if they don't end up playable.
    I cannot imagine a reality where they're not, to be honest. They seem relatively easy to translate to a playable race and they're heavily involved in the upcoming stories.

  18. #81098
    Quote Originally Posted by Raetary View Post
    That is not true.
    The main selling point for Midnight so far is a return to Quel'thalas.

    Housing is a feature in addition to the content we are receiving, in the same vein as Plunderstorm or Remix is.
    It just happens to be released during whatever phase of development Midnight is in, in early winter 2025.
    Calling something the "main selling feature" that wasn't even part of the original announcement is pretty silly.

  19. #81099
    Quote Originally Posted by Raetary View Post
    Anyway, i would sell an arm and a leg for playable Ethereals.

    Incorporeal space mummies are the shit, and i doubt Blizzard doesn't recognize it.
    They are already setup for more narrative significance, they are visually and aesthetically interesting, they are in desperate need for some more lore and fit perfectly into upcoming developments, and they are more or less ever present in the game thanks to transmog.

    And they are humanoid on top of that.

    It'd be a really wasted opportunity if they don't end up playable.
    I completely agree. They've been the race I want most ever since Burning Crusade- long before there was any meaningful Void Ethereal presence, so I have no idea where that narrative that people only want it for edgy Void stuff comes from. I mean, I've said before that if we get a Void class in Midnight then I hope it'll be based on those Void Ethereals, but even if that happens, it would be the Ethereal theme making the Void appealing to me, not the other way around. I'd be just as happy if we just got Ethereals as a race.

    And between K'aresh and Dimensius being set up as incredibly important to the current story arc during the Harbinger questline, and the Shadowguard apparently being set up as prominent enemies, they're becoming extremely relevant.

    They've got an amazing aesthetic, a cool culture, cool arcane technology... As long as they get decent models, I'd probably change every character I can to Ethereal.

  20. #81100
    Quote Originally Posted by milkmustache View Post
    I cannot imagine a reality where they're not, to be honest. They seem relatively easy to translate to a playable race and they're heavily involved in the upcoming stories.
    I haven't dragged the model out to poke around with, but the ones we've seen on the preview aren't player compatible at the moment

    Haranir are still the only "Suspicious player compatible model added before being made available"

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •