
I don't mind a revamp, but I do think Cata dropped the ball because it was a full world revamp that had no future potential for growth. It just timestamped itself and became irrelevant.
If they do a world revamp, I really want them to create evergreen content out of it. Have certain things in the open world that can actually have relevance for the next few expansions, like seeding major questlines or zone and dungeon content that will be expanded slowly over the next 3-4 expansions. Or just have scaling open world content that literally treats the world as a giant Timeless Isle. We just need a reason to go back into the world, and Dragonriding already helps with some of that.

But they weren’t though, where are you getting that from?
I’m not saying they aren’t WoW. But people have criticised elements of both for not feeling like WoW and those arguments have both valid and invalid reasonings. Saying people don’t like new things is just being totally disingenuous. There have been many new things added to the game that people have loved.
without resetting everything they could just get away with two timelines at the same time, and then we stabilize them into one timeline during the expac. we even got some allies from the Infinites to help, Nozdormu could even partially become Murozond to keep both timelines
Tbf, I would rather have a propper raid tier with Murozond down the line, and they also said that his story is done for now. Buuuut we got a new Murozond model that was only seen for a few seconds during the DotI cinematic, so who knows.
- - - Updated - - -
Yeah, it works for stuff like Mortal Kombat .... for a MMO, not so much imo, until you go the Age of Sigmar route of totally changing everything, which is the opposide of what people want with WoW.
Yeah, in my view a revamp might even be less likely now because the game gives you so many options for leveling that you don't need to experience the old zones at all. Instead of going through Elwynn Forest or Durator, you can level through any of WoW's 8 expansions instead, so a revamp isn't really needed. I could see them simply updating the look of buildings and landscapes instead.

Last edited by pacotaco; 2023-09-26 at 08:21 PM.
Unpopular opinion but I's say yes. Mind you, it's my opinion, we all know the harm to the lore that's come from Shadowlands (and I'm one of the biggest fan of Shadowlands, I liked it so much I wouldn't have released it for fear of damaging it...). Jokes aside most of the WoW lore is in constant flux and can be salvaged one way or the other imho
This 100%.
The entire point of Cata's revamp was to update the leveling experience at the time AND to allow flying in the old world. This is why we still got our "new continent' in the form of spread out zones.
Tolborad, Uldum, hyjal, deepholm, vash, Twilight highlands were essentially that.
Now we have the option to level up with the expansion of our choice.
So there really is no real purpose to update the entirety of Kal and EK cata style.
That being said, updating all the outdated models and assets with fresh HD versions is something that can be done to keep the game fresh, but that's something that can be, and has been, done over time.

What on earth are you going on about? I never said they weren’t new. Do you even read peoples posts before responding?
You can hate people feeling that way but if the what we get in the Shadowlands doesn’t feel like “Warcraft” to people then that’s their prerogative. The reason for them complaining about those things isn’t because they’re new, which is what you were saying - which js disingenuous.


No one has ever said that the Incarnates don’t feel like WoW. People have been criticising the atmosphere of Dragonflight, not it’s villains. The Incarnates aside from Vyranoth switching sides so quickly have been nothing but praised - Fyrakk especially.
Just like no one has ever said Maldraxus doesn’t feel like WoW. It’s been said numerous times at how similar to EPL that it at times felt like a direct copy and nothing really original. In fact, it’s the one Shadowlands zone that felt the most like classic Warcraft. The exact same with Torghast.
Because rolling back time doesn't change when Arthas, or Deathwing, or the Legion show up?
If you're just regurgitating Kalimdor and Eastern Kingdoms as they were before and then ignoring all the threats and places you brought back by resetting to sail west, why are you bothering to reset shit at all? Just sail west now, when you don't have to come up for some absurdly convoluted reason for why everyone's just going to ignore Scourge invasions to go sailing.

No that was in response to you saying that early in Warcraft’s development, you know, the mid to late 90’s, people were criticising the Legion, Old Gods and Scourge for not feeling like Warcraft; which was just plain wrong. Again, read posts through before responding.
No an OPINION cannot be wrong. By it’s very definition it cannot be wrong. You’re being extremely petulant.