
Originally Posted by
Mecheon
An expansion has to expand the game, though. That's ultimately the reason why we get new islands and the like. Cata already filled in all of the blank spots on the map previously, and Cata's big draws at the time did include being able to go to those blank spots, not just 'this is a world revamp'
You can't convince people to slap down $60 dollaridoos on "All the old stuff you already have, but vaguely different" when two of your competition, in GW2 and ESO, have made absolute bank in expansions of 'Going to new places we've known about but were arbiterily barred from accessing', and even FF14 does that with both "Let's go to the moon" and "Hey you know that South America that's just been a flavour text thing? We're going there". An expansion requires the game to expand, and 'just a world revamp' doesn't expand the game. It just pretties up what's already there
Now, frankly, I think the elemental theories are completely wrong because Dragonflight is blatently elemental themed as it is, and following up "Hey we just had Elementally Themed Dragons" with "Let's fight Elementally Themed Dudes" is a bad storyline beat