1. #32181
    Quote Originally Posted by Baraden View Post
    Honestly the only bad part of WoD is the "draenor is free" which only happened because they were rushing to get Legion out and they changed the ending
    One Legion in all universes is the dumbest part of WoD. It means KJ and Magtheridon went and tried to do the exact same plan that had already failed, knowing that it had failed, to invade an Azeroth that was more prepared than it had been before.

    Also Metzen has written plenty of other stupid shit before, the community fucking hated him when he was still at Blizzard. Heck, the way people in this thread are talking about cosmic stuff sounds exactly like people losing their shit at spaceship protoss Draenei back in 2005. Never mind how characters like Illidan and Kael'thas were ran through the mud for raid content.

  2. #32182
    Quote Originally Posted by Ferlion View Post
    Anduin isn't near the strength of a Titan and seriously injured an Eternal One.
    Power levels in WoW are as inconsistent as a marvel film, trying to use that as an actual metric is just folly

    Look at Malfurion; lorewise he could be able to body every Horde leader and most raid bosses without breaking a sweat - in game he's nearly beaten by Sylvanas

    Sylvanas is a great example; just look at how powerful WoW has portrayed her - she even was able to beat a fully powered lich king like it was nothing, whereas in the halls of reflection a greatly weakened lich king as Arthas nearly kills her

  3. #32183
    Quote Originally Posted by Baraden View Post
    The obvious answer is even Blizzard doesn't know a fucking thing about Mr. Jay Lore

    He WILL be memoryhole'd
    sorry but the janitor is too iconic

    "death comes for the soul of your world"

    "a cosmo divided will not survive what is to come"

    i will never forget these lines

  4. #32184
    Warchief Catastrophy349's Avatar
    3+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Jan 2022
    Location
    K'aresh is Midnight!
    Posts
    2,223
    Why is player housing such a "deal-breaker" for people? I never really interacted with player housing in an MMORPG before, so I think it would be really fun (especially in WoW). However, I'm not going "yep, no player housing. Dead game" either.

  5. #32185
    Quote Originally Posted by Baraden View Post
    Power levels in WoW are as inconsistent as a marvel film, trying to use that as an actual metric is just folly

    Look at Malfurion; lorewise he could be able to body every Horde leader and most raid bosses without breaking a sweat - in game he's nearly beaten by Sylvanas

    Sylvanas is a great example; just look at how powerful WoW has portrayed her - she even was able to beat a fully powered lich king like it was nothing, whereas in the halls of reflection a greatly weakened lich king as Arthas nearly kills her
    Not to disagree with your overall point, but she was explicitly empowered by the Lich King's daddy (Zovaal) in Shadowlands, including the cinematic. When she murdered Saurfang and fucked off, characters comment that she's using powers she never had before, that none of them had even seen before.

    This is how WoW has us deal with gigathreats like Titans or Eternal Ones while still having Fucko the Pirate be a dungeon boss in the next expansion still be a threat. When fighting these big fuckoff guys we're empowered by some giga person or artifact or w/e

  6. #32186
    Quote Originally Posted by Baraden View Post
    Honestly the only bad part of WoD is the "draenor is free" which only happened because they were rushing to get Legion out and they changed the ending

    I think WoD would be far more favorably remembered if it had one more raid with the Iron Horde and actually killing them; and M+ - those two elements and it would've been one of the greatest expansions to date imo
    That's a solid take. Thinking back, WoD is one of the expansions I enjoyed the most gameplay-wise. If only they had enough time to deliver the full story/all intended content. sadge

  7. #32187
    Quote Originally Posted by Futhark View Post
    Just a reminder, N'Zoth was first revealed in HearthStone, so for the cosmic stuff, it can't be discounted completely.

    The rest are good points.
    Some of Hearthstone MAY make it into the WoW lore, especially character designs, since they dont really matter that much. Theyve also adopted MU Blackhands new design from the Warcraft movie.
    But the majority of Hearthstones lore ideas will not, just like a lot of the Warcraft movies lore changes are not canon in the games story.
    For example, i doubt well ever see Archimonde grow to titan size and do something with Sargeras's sword - which he did in a Hearthstone card.
    The crooked shitposter with no eyes is watching from the endless thread.

    From the space that is everywhere and nowhere, the crooked shitposter feasts on memes.

    He has no eyes to see, but he dreams of infinite memeing and trolling.

  8. #32188
    Over 9000! Makabreska's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Streets Strange by Moonlight
    Posts
    9,377
    Quote Originally Posted by Catastrophy349 View Post
    Why is player housing such a "deal-breaker" for people? I never really interacted with player housing in an MMORPG before, so I think it would be really fun (especially in WoW). However, I'm not going "yep, no player housing. Dead game" either.
    It's yet another instance of some tiny few individuals stating "Expansion has to have X feature, else it will be a failure. Cuz I say so!". We can put it together with stuff like "LFR is ruining the game!".
    Sometimes, the light of the moon is a key to other spaces. I've found a place where, for a night or two, the streets curve in unfamiliar ways. If I walk here, I might find insight, or I might be touched by madness.

  9. #32189
    Quote Originally Posted by Selorian View Post
    One Legion in all universes is the dumbest part of WoD. It means KJ and Magtheridon went and tried to do the exact same plan that had already failed, knowing that it had failed, to invade an Azeroth that was more prepared than it had been before.

    Also Metzen has written plenty of other stupid shit before, the community fucking hated him when he was still at Blizzard. Heck, the way people in this thread are talking about cosmic stuff sounds exactly like people losing their shit at spaceship protoss Draenei back in 2005. Never mind how characters like Illidan and Kael'thas were ran through the mud for raid content.
    Fringe elements versus mainstream opinions

    You can't seriously believe people were equally annoyed at the writing of the game back in BC versus how much they are now

    The One Legion in all universes thing was just a vehicle to justify old faces coming back; now than Legion is over you can bet they won't really mention that plot point again - that's why we conveniently are able to kill Archimonde and Kil'Jaden in the Nether this time

    I'm not saying Metzen is perfect - but would anyone REALLY choose Danuser over him? I'd even take Green Jesus over the retcons of Shadowlands and the dullness of Dragonflight

  10. #32190
    Quote Originally Posted by Baraden View Post
    If he isn't bullshitting, which he probably is, maybe an insider has suggested some of the writing team are getting purged for the new expansion with the return of metzen

    Honestly I hope to god this is true; just give him the reigns - WoD is the worst thing he's done and is there even a debate about the fact it still shits on anything post Legion lorewise
    WoD was bad because it was a complete self insert nolstsgia trip that was completely devoid of what people actually liked about wow. People complain about the writing now, but it at least tries to be both reverent but also evolutionary of what WoW is, rather than "rule of cooling" a million other players and other devs before realizing it's all orcs.

    See also the warcraft movie.

  11. #32191
    Quote Originally Posted by Selorian View Post
    One Legion in all universes is the dumbest part of WoD. It means KJ and Magtheridon went and tried to do the exact same plan that had already failed, knowing that it had failed, to invade an Azeroth that was more prepared than it had been before.

    Also Metzen has written plenty of other stupid shit before, the community fucking hated him when he was still at Blizzard. Heck, the way people in this thread are talking about cosmic stuff sounds exactly like people losing their shit at spaceship protoss Draenei back in 2005. Never mind how characters like Illidan and Kael'thas were ran through the mud for raid content.
    A vocal minority of "the community" maybe.

  12. #32192
    Quote Originally Posted by NoTimeToDie5426 View Post
    That's a solid take. Thinking back, WoD is one of the expansions I enjoyed the most gameplay-wise. If only they had enough time to deliver the full story/all intended content. sadge
    I think it also suffered gameplay wise from the stat squish. It felt absolutely fucking awful going from seeing SoO numbers to WoD numbers and it soured a lot of it. Or maybe that's just me. I just know it heavily impacted my first impression and over the years my opinion on WoD has definitely turned around. Still the worst expansion by far just less worse much closer to being a solid experience.

  13. #32193
    Does anyone know if this Shadowlands "leak" was ever admitted to be fake?

    It showed up 3 months before 8.3 was even announced and 6 months before 8.3 was released. It's layout is structurally similar to the actual Shadowlands except Nyalotha is in Oribos's spot. It seems plausible that this could have been an early iteration of Shadowlands in development.

    https://i.imgur.com/5S7McrG.jpg

  14. #32194
    Warchief Catastrophy349's Avatar
    3+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Jan 2022
    Location
    K'aresh is Midnight!
    Posts
    2,223
    I guess this does bring up an interesting point, though. To my MMO-C family: what would you consider a "dealbreaker(s)" to turn you completely off from caring/playing 11.0?

  15. #32195
    Quote Originally Posted by Catastrophy349 View Post
    I guess this does bring up an interesting point, though. To my MMO-C family: what would you consider a "dealbreaker(s)" to turn you completely off from carring/playing 11.0?
    another expansion with boring content like dragonflight

    also, another expansion of disney-like writing. don't care if the writing is bad, but it has to be cool

  16. #32196
    Quote Originally Posted by Catastrophy349 View Post
    I guess this does bring up an interesting point, though. To my MMO-C family: what would you consider a "dealbreaker(s)" to turn you completely off from caring/playing 11.0?
    If the game goes F2P

  17. #32197
    Quote Originally Posted by Baraden View Post
    Fringe elements versus mainstream opinions

    You can't seriously believe people were equally annoyed at the writing of the game back in BC versus how much they are now

    The One Legion in all universes thing was just a vehicle to justify old faces coming back; now than Legion is over you can bet they won't really mention that plot point again - that's why we conveniently are able to kill Archimonde and Kil'Jaden in the Nether this time

    I'm not saying Metzen is perfect - but would anyone REALLY choose Danuser over him? I'd even take Green Jesus over the retcons of Shadowlands and the dullness of Dragonflight
    Good point. Also, who do you think would be more fun to quest with: Green Jesus, or the rainbowdreamteamofdragons? I'd take GJ any day of the week.

  18. #32198
    Over 9000! Makabreska's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Streets Strange by Moonlight
    Posts
    9,377
    Quote Originally Posted by Go Woke View Post
    WoD was bad because it was a complete self insert nolstsgia trip that was completely devoid of what people actually liked about wow. People complain about the writing now, but it at least tries to be both reverent but also evolutionary of what WoW is, rather than "rule of cooling" a million other players and other devs before realizing it's all orcs.

    See also the warcraft movie.
    This nostalgia worked well for me. I started playing in BC, and it was really cool to see all those BC characters in different roles and configurations.
    Last edited by Makabreska; 2023-10-20 at 09:03 PM.
    Sometimes, the light of the moon is a key to other spaces. I've found a place where, for a night or two, the streets curve in unfamiliar ways. If I walk here, I might find insight, or I might be touched by madness.

  19. #32199
    Warchief Catastrophy349's Avatar
    3+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Jan 2022
    Location
    K'aresh is Midnight!
    Posts
    2,223
    Quote Originally Posted by Zebir95 View Post
    another expansion with boring content like dragonflight
    Great answer! But seriously, what does that mean? That's a "subjective" take. Be more specific, please.

  20. #32200
    Scarab Lord ercarp's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    Suramar
    Posts
    4,936
    Quote Originally Posted by matijwow View Post
    Does anyone know if this Shadowlands "leak" was ever admitted to be fake?

    It showed up 3 months before 8.3 was even announced and 6 months before 8.3 was released. It's layout is structurally similar to the actual Shadowlands except Nyalotha is in Oribos's spot. It seems plausible that this could have been an early iteration of Shadowlands in development.

    https://i.imgur.com/5S7McrG.jpg
    It's possible it was a very early concept, but if so, damn... everything except the name of the expansion was changed lol.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •