1. #36241
    Quote Originally Posted by Ferlion View Post
    I'm still confused on how Harpies are in Avaloren
    One of my all-time criticisms of Blizzard's design. Give us new, unique creatures and denizens. Yes, it will require a new rig. Ok? Anything that screams BRAND NEW UNDISCOVERED LAND, not "You know this game's all about reskins, right?"

    Same with cave layouts, etc. Does it make sense that this new, untouched, heretofore unseen realm has roads, roadsigns, and ever-lit torches on every path? Many small design things in the aggregate. I get it, it's easier to reskin/color stuff.
    Google doc with all plate mogs complete with import codes! PLATE TRANSMOG-O-RAMA

  2. #36242
    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    Ok, so real talk.

    I'd be fine either that if they were like... crane and goose themed harpies, but also it's starting to also strike me as odd (in general) that I can't think of an instance of someone making a duck harpy, or a flamingo harpy

  3. #36243
    I am Murloc! Wangming's Avatar
    5+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Apr 2019
    Location
    Not Azeroth
    Posts
    5,389
    Quote Originally Posted by Myrrh View Post

    Oh I don't disagree haha - was using that as a conveniently timed point about expectations based on an image. A zone probably has more room for variance than a race :P
    I agree. But generally speaking it is considered counterproductive to put your most boring shots in the reveal trailer. You need the money shot. BfA was very good at this both in the feature trailer and the CGI cinematic.

  4. #36244
    Quote Originally Posted by flan1337 View Post
    I think we are going to somehow learn that this storm was created by the titans and maybe way back when Avalon was attached to kalimdor?

    You know did the legion also ever invade Avalon? Or do the storms cover Avalon?
    In theory, Avaloren was never attached to Kalimdor

  5. #36245
    Stood in the Fire Dragon ANX's Avatar
    7+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Anywhere
    Posts
    438
    Quote Originally Posted by Ferlion View Post
    I'm still confused on how Harpies are in Avaloren

    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    There could be many explanation:
    They are not the same, but share a common ancestor(Like in IRL where some animals are simillar in diferent continents because they share a common ancestor)
    They could be luck ones that traveled there and survived the sea storms.
    They could've been there because of the failed expedition to there took them there for some unknow reason,
    I could go on, but i think you got it.
    Last edited by Dragon ANX; 2023-10-26 at 02:44 PM.

  6. #36246
    I am Murloc! Wangming's Avatar
    5+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Apr 2019
    Location
    Not Azeroth
    Posts
    5,389
    Quote Originally Posted by Sondrelk View Post
    I hope not. That was the mistake Cataclysm made. A world revamp should utilize the revamped zones.
    I mean, it could do both. Yes, it was a mistake to only use the revamped zones for leveling. And only for new characters. But having new zones in a revamp isn't inherently bad.

  7. #36247
    The Insane Raetary's Avatar
    7+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Base Camp
    Posts
    19,602
    Quote Originally Posted by Ferlion View Post
    I'm still confused on how Harpies are in Avaloren
    Does it matter?
    Blizzard can create any lore they want to justify Harpie involvement.

    Maybe they have always been there.
    Maybe they migrated over before Avaloren was isolated.
    Maybe they managed to fly over/teleport over with the help of whatever mcguffin Blizzard wants to use.

    Just this expansion we got introduced to an ancient centaur tribe that predates our known centaur.
    Not much different to them.


    Formerly known as Arafal

  8. #36248
    Quote Originally Posted by Sondrelk View Post
    Don't see why the direhorn makes it real honestly. It's a new model, but it's also much easier to fake one when you can both copy the style of an available model, and you don't have to animate more than a still frame.
    Yeah sure, but every other model in the leak is unique. The direhorn is ripped straight from the game from a baby model and made older.

    So either the leak is real or the leaker is playing 4D chess and planned it out perfectly.

  9. #36249
    Mechagnome Draedarr's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    Cataguases, Brazil
    Posts
    692
    Quote Originally Posted by Well Done Steak View Post
    Yeah sure, but every other model in the leak is unique. The direhorn is ripped straight from the game from a baby model and made older.

    So either the leak is real or the leaker is playing 4D chess and planned it out perfectly.
    For some artists it's not so hard to work around a screenshot or model and give it a sense of 3D assets.

  10. #36250
    Quote Originally Posted by Ferlion View Post
    I'm still confused on how Harpies are in Avaloren
    There's dwarves who never met with EK dwarves and still develop similar culture in kaz algar.

    I'm sure they can spin it somehow

  11. #36251
    Scarab Lord ercarp's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Location
    Suramar
    Posts
    4,936
    @Demonly and I did some snooping around and found that the tree used in one of the screenshots already exists as an asset in-game.



    It's called 10can_tree_burnt_b01_off.m2 and it's found in the Waking Shores.





    My question is, has Blizzard reused this many assets in the past when going into what's supposed to be a brand new expansion?

    Combining this finding with @Marlamin's earlier analysis, it seems like there's an unusually high amount of assets from Dragonflight. It almost makes it seem like Avaloren (if real) should be 10.3, not 11.0.

  12. #36252
    Quote Originally Posted by Draedarr View Post
    For some artists it's not so hard to work around a screenshot or model and give it a sense of 3D assets.
    I mean no offense, but the amount of reaching this takes is more effort than it takes to post some screenshot they got.

  13. #36253
    Quote Originally Posted by Draedarr View Post
    For some artists it's not so hard to work around a screenshot or model and give it a sense of 3D assets.
    Right, I'm just saying that the chances of it being legit is higher by then using an existing model when all the other models in the leak are new.

  14. #36254
    Quote Originally Posted by ercarp View Post
    @Demonly and I did some snooping around and found that the tree used in one of the screenshots already exists as an asset in-game.



    It's called 10can_tree_burnt_b01_off.m2 and it's found in the Waking Shores.





    My question is, has Blizzard reused this many assets in the past when going into what's supposed to be a brand new expansion?

    Combining this finding with @Marlamin's earlier analysis, it seems like there's an unusually high amount of assets from Dragonflight. It almost makes it seem like Avaloren (if real) should be 10.3, not 11.0.
    What if its the trailer for 10.3? Hmmmm.
    Also: That is some mad detective work. Awesome.
    I will not reply to posts that are non-constructive or contain flaming and/or trolling.

  15. #36255
    Quote Originally Posted by ercarp View Post
    Combining this finding with @Marlamin's earlier analysis, it seems like there's an unusually high amount of assets from Dragonflight. It almost makes it seem like Avaloren (if real) should be 10.3, not 11.0.
    Highly unlikely, but wow would that be a killer surprise announcement of a 10.3 with Avaloren.

  16. #36256
    Quote Originally Posted by Sondrelk View Post
    Honestly, the more I look at it the more u am questioning he second and fourth picture. Specifically the models there that don't look like they are actually in the area, but rather pasted on with some shadow effects to hide it.

    Maybe I'm just overthinking it though.
    It reads as that way to me, too. It looks a lot like they were slapped there with WMV or a similar program.
    "We will soon be in a world in which a man may be howled down for saying that two and two make four."
    — G.K. Chesterton

    You hate dracthyr because you hate scalies, I hate dracthyr because I'm a scalie and know naga are better. We are not the same.

  17. #36257
    Quote Originally Posted by micwini View Post
    What if its the trailer for 10.3? Hmmmm
    If they do a surprise 10.3 reveal on top of an expansion reveal I'd be beyond hyped but I think it's more likely they are doing what they always do, reusing newer assets when able. If expansions were completely original from the ground up you'd get wow expac less frequently.

    This is still possibly fake, but if the OP faked this they did a crazy good job.

  18. #36258
    Quote Originally Posted by ercarp View Post
    @Demonly and I did some snooping around and found that the tree used in one of the screenshots already exists as an asset in-game.



    It's called 10can_tree_burnt_b01_off.m2 and it's found in the Waking Shores.





    My question is, has Blizzard reused this many assets in the past when going into what's supposed to be a brand new expansion?

    Combining this finding with @Marlamin's earlier analysis, it seems like there's an unusually high amount of assets from Dragonflight. It almost makes it seem like Avaloren (if real) should be 10.3, not 11.0.
    It wouldn't be too crazy to think Avaloren is the DF Timeless Isle, with Uldaz as a final dungeon before the 11.0 pre-patch.

  19. #36259
    Quote Originally Posted by ercarp View Post
    @Demonly and I did some snooping around and found that the tree used in one of the screenshots already exists as an asset in-game.



    It's called 10can_tree_burnt_b01_off.m2 and it's found in the Waking Shores.





    My question is, has Blizzard reused this many assets in the past when going into what's supposed to be a brand new expansion?

    Combining this finding with @Marlamin's earlier analysis, it seems like there's an unusually high amount of assets from Dragonflight. It almost makes it seem like Avaloren (if real) should be 10.3, not 11.0.
    That’s what some people here already said. This entire leak feels more like a part of Dragonflight / Dragonflight afterthought than it does feel like a new expansion.
    MAGA - Make Alliance Great Again

  20. #36260
    Quote Originally Posted by Arafal View Post
    Does it matter?
    Blizzard can create any lore they want to justify Harpie involvement.

    Maybe they have always been there.
    Maybe they migrated over before Avaloren was isolated.
    Maybe they managed to fly over/teleport over with the help of whatever mcguffin Blizzard wants to use.

    Just this expansion we got introduced to an ancient centaur tribe that predates our known centaur.
    Not much different to them.
    Within the story that was presented in the Emerald Dream and legends of the green dragon flying over, on top of Aviana, the progenitor of the Harpies, saying you can't leave the dream, yes.

    I.E. I think the implications we have is that Kalimdor/ known world is where the Emerald Dream is formed.

    Dragon Isles and Centaur, at least, is part of that.

    Creating a new continent, divorcing it from everything because it was sealed off, adding it in with the implications of heretics, then populating it with a race charged by the keepers (because who else would charge them), a new Earthen Variant, and wild God spawn linked to the Emerald Dream kind of just feels..

    Less than what I would expect.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •